A plano-convex lens of refractive index and focal length is kept in contact with another plano-concave lens of refractive index and focal length . If the radius of curvature of their spherical faces is each and , the and are related as:
For a thin lens kept in air we always begin with the lens-maker’s formula
Here is the focal length of the lens, its refractive index and the radii of curvature of its first and second spherical surfaces. By the Cartesian sign convention a radius is taken positive if the centre of curvature lies on the side toward which light finally travels (the right-hand side in our discussion) and negative otherwise. A plane surface is represented by so that its reciprocal is zero.
Plano-convex lens The plano-convex lens has one plane face and one convex spherical face of radius . We keep the plane face on the left and the convex face on the right; therefore
Substituting these values in the formula we get
Because the expression is negative, the algebraic value of obtained from it would be negative; however, for the present problem we shall use the magnitude of the focal length. Hence we write
Plano-concave lens This lens again has one plane face and one spherical face of the same numerical radius , but that face is concave. Keeping its plane surface on the right and the concave face on the left gives
Putting these in the lens-maker’s expression yields
Again taking the magnitude of the focal length we obtain
Given relation between the focal lengths The question states that the plano-convex lens has a focal length twice that of the plano-concave lens, i.e.
Substituting the individual focal lengths found above, we write
Because the same radius appears in both numerators, it cancels out immediately:
Now we cross-multiply to remove the denominators:
Expanding the right-hand side first, we have
Next we collect like terms, bringing every term involving refractive indices to the left and numbers to the right:
Finally, multiplying through by gives the neat relation
This is exactly the condition appearing in Option D.
Hence, the correct answer is Option D.
Tagged Thin lenses: lens formula, lens maker's formula and power. Machine-assigned, so read it as a strong shortlist rather than a verdict.