RankRizz
JEE MAIN 2018 · 08 APR OFFLINE+4 / −1TRANSCRIBED

JEE Main 2018 Physics question — Magnetic dipole moment of current loops and torque on loops

An electron, a proton and an alpha particle having the same kinetic energy are moving in circular orbits of radii rer_e, rpr_p, rαr_\alpha respectively in a uniform magnetic field B. The relation between rer_e, rpr_p, rαr_\alpha is:

SOLUTION

We begin with the fact that a charged particle of mass mm and charge magnitude ∣q∣|q|, moving with speed vv perpendicular to a uniform magnetic field of induction BB, describes a circular path whose radius is given by the cyclotron‐motion formula

r=mv∣q∣ B.r=\frac{m v}{|q|\,B}.

The electron, the proton and the alpha particle are all said to possess the same kinetic energy. Let us call this common value KK. The usual expression for kinetic energy is

K=12 mv2.K=\frac{1}{2}\,m v^{2}.

Solving this relation for the speed vv of any one of the particles, we obtain

v=2Km.v=\sqrt{\frac{2K}{m}}.

Now we substitute this value of vv back into the radius formula. Doing so gives

r=m∣q∣ B  2Km.r=\frac{m}{|q|\,B}\;\sqrt{\frac{2K}{m}}.

Inside the square root the factor mm in the denominator cancels partly with the mm in the numerator, leaving us with

r=2KB  m∣q∣.r=\frac{\sqrt{2K}}{B}\;\frac{\sqrt{m}}{|q|}.

Because 2K/B\sqrt{2K}/B is a constant common to all three particles (the kinetic energy and the magnetic field are the same for each of them), the radius for any particle is directly proportional to the factor m∣q∣\dfrac{\sqrt{m}}{|q|}. So we can write symbolically

r  ∝  m∣q∣.r\;\propto\;\frac{\sqrt{m}}{|q|}.

We therefore compare the three particles only through their masses and charges:

• Electron: mass mem_e, charge magnitude ee.
• Proton:    mass mpm_p, charge magnitude ee.
• Alpha particle: mass mα=4mpm_\alpha = 4m_p, charge magnitude 2e2e (because it carries two positive elementary charges).

Computing the relevant proportional factors one by one:

For the electron

re  ∝  mee.r_e \;\propto\;\frac{\sqrt{m_e}}{e}.

For the proton

rp  ∝  mpe.r_p \;\propto\;\frac{\sqrt{m_p}}{e}.

For the alpha particle we first take its mass mα=4mpm_\alpha = 4m_p, so mα=4mp=2mp\sqrt{m_\alpha}=\sqrt{4m_p}=2\sqrt{m_p}. Hence

rα  ∝  mα2e  =  2mp2e  =  mpe.r_\alpha \;\propto\;\frac{\sqrt{m_\alpha}}{2e} \;=\;\frac{2\sqrt{m_p}}{2e} \;=\;\frac{\sqrt{m_p}}{e}.

This shows immediately that

rp=rαr_p = r_\alpha

because both are proportional to the identical factor mpe\dfrac{\sqrt{m_p}}{e}, whereas the electron radius is proportional to mee\dfrac{\sqrt{m_e}}{e} with me≪mp\sqrt{m_e} \ll \sqrt{m_p} (the electron’s mass is about 1836 times smaller than the proton’s mass).

Therefore we have the inequality

re  <  rp=rα.r_e \;<\; r_p = r_\alpha.

Among the given options this order corresponds exactly to option 3.

Hence, the correct answer is Option 3.

Tagged Magnetic dipole moment of current loops and torque on loops. Machine-assigned, so read it as a strong shortlist rather than a verdict.

SubjectPhysics
TopicMagnetic dipole moment of current loops and torque on loops
TypeMultiple choice