A hoop and a solid cylinder of same mass and radius are made of a permanent magnetic material with their respective axes. But the magnetic moment of hoop is twice of solid cylinder. They are placed in a uniform magnetic field in such a manner that their magnetic moments make a small angle with the field. If the oscillation periods of hoop and cylinder are and respectively, then:
We first recall the relation between the restoring torque acting on a magnetic dipole and the angular acceleration it produces. A magnetic dipole of moment kept in a uniform magnetic field experiences a torque
where is the angle between and . For very small oscillations, , so the torque becomes
(The minus sign only indicates that the torque is restoring.)
In rotational dynamics the torque is also related to the angular acceleration by
where is the moment of inertia about the axis of rotation. Combining the two expressions, we obtain
This is the differential equation of simple harmonic motion, with the square of the angular frequency given by
Hence the time-period of small oscillations is
Now we analyse the two given bodies one by one.
Hoop (ring)
We are told that the mass of the hoop is and the radius is . About its own axis the moment of inertia is well known:
The magnetic moment of the hoop is twice that of the solid cylinder, so if we denote the cylinder’s magnetic moment by , then
Substituting these values in the period formula, we find
Solid cylinder
For a solid cylinder of the same mass and radius , the moment of inertia about its own axis is
Its magnetic moment is simply
Putting these quantities into the period formula gives
We see that the square-root expressions for and are identical:
Therefore
Hence, the correct answer is Option B.
Tagged Magnetic dipole moment of current loops and torque on loops. Machine-assigned, so read it as a strong shortlist rather than a verdict.