RankRizz
JEE MAIN 2019 · 10 APR S1+4 / −1EASYTRANSCRIBED

JEE Main 2019 Physics question — Motion of charged particles in a magnetic field

A proton, an electron, and a Helium nucleus, have the same energy. They are in circular orbits in a plane due to magnetic field perpendicular to the plane. Let rpr_p, rer_e and rHer_{He} be their respective radii, then,

SOLUTION

We consider a uniform magnetic field that is perpendicular to the plane of motion of the charged particle. For a charged particle of charge qq and mass mm moving with speed vv in a circle of radius rr, the magnetic Lorentz force provides the required centripetal force. The relation is

q v B=mv2rq\,v\,B = \dfrac{m v^{2}}{r}

First we isolate the radius rr. Cancelling one factor of vv from both sides, we obtain

qB=mvr⟹r=mvqBq B = \dfrac{m v}{r} \quad \Longrightarrow \quad r = \dfrac{m v}{q B}

The question tells us that the proton, the electron, and the Helium nucleus all possess the same kinetic energy, which we denote by EE. The kinetic energy of a particle is given by

E=12mv2E = \dfrac{1}{2} m v^{2}

Solving this expression for the speed vv, we have

v=2Emv = \sqrt{\dfrac{2E}{m}}

We now substitute this expression for vv into the formula for the radius:

r=mqB 2Em</p><p>=2E mqBr = \dfrac{m}{q B} \,\sqrt{\dfrac{2E}{m}}</p> <p> = \dfrac{\sqrt{2 E}\, \sqrt{m}}{q B}

The factors 2E\sqrt{2E} and BB are common to all three particles because the energy and the magnetic field are the same for each. Hence, for comparison of radii, we may write the proportionality

r  ∝  mqr \;\propto\; \dfrac{\sqrt{m}}{q}

Therefore, the ordering of the radii depends solely on the ratio m/q\sqrt{m}/q for the proton, the electron, and the Helium nucleus. We list their masses and charges (magnitude of charge only, because radius is a positive quantity):

  • Electron: m=me,  q=em = m_e,\; q = e
  • Proton: m=mp,  q=em = m_p,\; q = e
  • Helium nucleus (alpha particle): m=4mp,  q=2em = 4 m_p,\; q = 2e

Now we compute the proportional factors:

</p><p></p><p>re∝mee,</p><p>rp∝mpe,</p><p>rHe∝4mp2e</p><p>=2mp2e</p><p>=mpe.</p><p></p><p></p> <p>\begin{aligned}</p> <p>r_e &\propto \dfrac{\sqrt{m_e}}{e},\\[4pt]</p> <p>r_p &\propto \dfrac{\sqrt{m_p}}{e},\\[4pt]</p> <p>r_{He} &\propto \dfrac{\sqrt{4 m_p}}{2e}</p> <p> = \dfrac{2\sqrt{m_p}}{2e}</p> <p> = \dfrac{\sqrt{m_p}}{e}.</p> <p>\end{aligned}</p> <p>

We immediately observe that

rHe∝mpe=rp.r_{He} \propto \dfrac{\sqrt{m_p}}{e} = r_p.

Thus rHe=rp.r_{He} = r_p. To compare with the electron, note that the electron’s mass is enormously smaller than the proton’s mass, i.e.

me≪mp⟹me≪mp.m_e \ll m_p \quad\Longrightarrow\quad \sqrt{m_e} \ll \sqrt{m_p}.

Consequently

re∝mee≪mpe∝rp=rHe.r_e \propto \dfrac{\sqrt{m_e}}{e} \ll \dfrac{\sqrt{m_p}}{e} \propto r_p = r_{He}.

Collecting these results, we obtain the order

re<rp=rHe.r_e \lt r_p = r_{He}.

This ordering corresponds to Option B.

Hence, the correct answer is Option B.

Tagged Motion of charged particles in a magnetic field. Machine-assigned, so read it as a strong shortlist rather than a verdict.

SubjectPhysics
TopicMotion of charged particles in a magnetic field
TypeMultiple choice