RankRizz
JEE MAIN 2019 · 09 JAN S2+4 / −1MEDIUMTRANSCRIBED

JEE Main 2019 Physics question — Equations of motion for uniform acceleration

In a car race on straight road, car A takes a time tt less than car BB at the finish and passes finishing point with a speed vv more than that of car BB. Both the cars start from rest and travel with constant acceleration a1a_1 and a2a_2 respectively. Then vv is equal to:

SOLUTION

Let the total distance of the race be SS. Both cars start from rest, so their initial velocities are zero.

For motion with uniform (constant) acceleration, the basic kinematic relations we shall use are

1. Distance covered from rest in time TT: S=12 a T2.S=\dfrac12\,a\,T^{2}.

2. Final speed attained from rest in time TT: vfinal=a T.v_{\text{final}}=a\,T.

Denote

TB=T_B= time taken by car B,B,

TA=T_A= time taken by car A.A.

The statement “car A takes a time tt less than car B” gives us

TA=TB−t.−(1)T_A=T_B-t. \quad -(1)

Since both cars run over the same total distance SS, we write the distance formula for each:

For car AA (acceleration a1a_1):

S=12 a1 TA2.S=\dfrac12\,a_1\,T_A^{2}.

For car BB (acceleration a2a_2):

S=12 a2 TB2.S=\dfrac12\,a_2\,T_B^{2}.

Because the right-hand sides are both equal to the same SS, we equate them:

12 a1 TA2=12 a2 TB2.\dfrac12\,a_1\,T_A^{2}=\dfrac12\,a_2\,T_B^{2}.

The factor 12\dfrac12 appears on both sides, so we cancel it, obtaining

a1 TA2=a2 TB2.−(2)a_1\,T_A^{2}=a_2\,T_B^{2}. \quad -(2)

Now substitute the relation (1), TA=TB−t,T_A=T_B-t, into equation (2):

a1 (TB−t)2=a2 TB2.a_1\,(T_B-t)^{2}=a_2\,T_B^{2}.

We expand the square carefully:

a1(TB2−2 TB t+t2)=a2 TB2.a_1\left(T_B^{2}-2\,T_B\,t+t^{2}\right)=a_2\,T_B^{2}.

Multiplying term by term gives

a1 TB2−2 a1 TB t+a1 t2=a2 TB2.a_1\,T_B^{2}-2\,a_1\,T_B\,t+a_1\,t^{2}=a_2\,T_B^{2}.

Next we bring every term to the left side to form a quadratic equation in TBT_B:

(a1−a2) TB2−2 a1 TB t+a1 t2=0.−(3)(a_1-a_2)\,T_B^{2}-2\,a_1\,T_B\,t+a_1\,t^{2}=0. \quad -(3)

Equation (3) is a quadratic of the standard form A TB2+B TB+C=0A\,T_B^{2}+B\,T_B+C=0 with

A=a1−a2,B=−2 a1 t,C=a1 t2.A=a_1-a_2,\quad B=-2\,a_1\,t,\quad C=a_1\,t^{2}.

We need TBT_B, so we apply the quadratic-formula statement

TB=−B±B2−4AC2A.T_B=\dfrac{-B\pm\sqrt{B^{2}-4AC}}{2A}.

Substituting A,B,CA,B,C from above:

TB=−(−2 a1 t)±(−2 a1 t)2−4 (a1−a2) (a1 t2)2 (a1−a2).T_B=\dfrac{-(-2\,a_1\,t)\pm\sqrt{(-2\,a_1\,t)^{2}-4\,(a_1-a_2)\,(a_1\,t^{2})}}{2\,(a_1-a_2)}.

Simplifying step by step:

• The first numerator term: −(−2 a1 t)=2 a1 t.-(-2\,a_1\,t)=2\,a_1\,t.

• Inside the square root:

(−2 a1 t)2=4 a12 t2,(-2\,a_1\,t)^{2}=4\,a_1^{2}\,t^{2},

4AC=4 (a1−a2) (a1 t2)=4 a1 (a1−a2) t2.4AC=4\,(a_1-a_2)\,(a_1\,t^{2})=4\,a_1\,(a_1-a_2)\,t^{2}.

Therefore

B2−4AC=4 a12 t2−4 a1 (a1−a2) t2=4 t2(a12−a1(a1−a2)).B^{2}-4AC=4\,a_1^{2}\,t^{2}-4\,a_1\,(a_1-a_2)\,t^{2} =4\,t^{2}\left(a_1^{2}-a_1(a_1-a_2)\right).

Inside the brackets we simplify the expression:

a12−a1(a1−a2)=a12−a12+a1 a2=a1 a2.a_1^{2}-a_1(a_1-a_2)=a_1^{2}-a_1^{2}+a_1\,a_2=a_1\,a_2.

So the discriminant becomes

B2−4AC=4 t2 a1 a2.B^{2}-4AC=4\,t^{2}\,a_1\,a_2.

The square root therefore is

B2−4AC=2 t a1 a2.\sqrt{B^{2}-4AC}=2\,t\,\sqrt{a_1\,a_2}.

Putting everything back into the expression for TBT_B:

TB=2 a1 t  ±  2 t a1 a22 (a1−a2)=a1 t  ±  t a1 a2a1−a2.T_B=\dfrac{2\,a_1\,t\;\pm\;2\,t\,\sqrt{a_1\,a_2}}{2\,(a_1-a_2)} =\dfrac{a_1\,t\;\pm\;t\,\sqrt{a_1\,a_2}}{a_1-a_2}.

Only the “plus” or “minus” that keeps TBT_B positive is physically acceptable; we shall keep both for the moment and the correct sign will reveal itself automatically when we calculate the speed difference.

Now we focus on the required quantity, namely the speed difference at the finish. Using the second kinematic relation vfinal=a Tv_{\text{final}}=a\,T, the individual finish speeds are

For car AA: vA=a1 TA=a1 (TB−t).v_A=a_1\,T_A=a_1\,(T_B-t).

For car BB: vB=a2 TB.v_B=a_2\,T_B.

The problem defines vv as “the speed of car A at the finish is vv more than that of car B,” which translates to

v=vA−vB.v=v_A-v_B.

Substituting the expressions of vAv_A and vBv_B, we have

v=a1 (TB−t)−a2 TB=a1 TB−a1 t−a2 TB=(a1−a2) TB−a1 t.−(4)v=a_1\,(T_B-t)-a_2\,T_B =a_1\,T_B-a_1\,t-a_2\,T_B =(a_1-a_2)\,T_B-a_1\,t. \quad -(4)

Equation (4) already contains the factor (a1−a2) TB,(a_1-a_2)\,T_B, which suggests inserting the value of TBT_B that we just derived. So we substitute TB=a1 t  ±  t a1 a2a1−a2T_B=\dfrac{a_1\,t\;\pm\;t\,\sqrt{a_1\,a_2}}{a_1-a_2} into (4):

v=(a1−a2)(a1 t  ±  t a1 a2a1−a2)−a1 t.v=(a_1-a_2)\left(\dfrac{a_1\,t\;\pm\;t\,\sqrt{a_1\,a_2}}{a_1-a_2}\right)-a_1\,t.

The factor (a1−a2)(a_1-a_2) cancels immediately, leaving

v=a1 t  ±  t a1 a2−a1 t=t a1 a2,v=a_1\,t\;\pm\;t\,\sqrt{a_1\,a_2}-a_1\,t=t\,\sqrt{a_1\,a_2},

because the a1 ta_1\,t terms subtract out. The sign that survives is the positive one; speed difference must be positive. Thus we finally obtain

v=t a1 a2.v=t\,\sqrt{a_1\,a_2}.

Looking at the given options, this matches exactly with Option C: a1 a2  t.\sqrt{a_1\,a_2}\;t.

Hence, the correct answer is Option C.

Tagged Equations of motion for uniform acceleration. Machine-assigned, so read it as a strong shortlist rather than a verdict.

SubjectPhysics
TopicEquations of motion for uniform acceleration
TypeMultiple choice