RankRizz
JEE MAIN 2021 · 27 JUL S1+4 / −1MEDIUMTRANSCRIBED

JEE Main 2021 Physics question — Vertical motion under gravity

A ball is thrown up with a certain velocity so that it reaches a height hh. Find the ratio of the two different times of the ball reaching h3\frac{h}{3} in both the directions.

SOLUTION

Let the ball be projected vertically upward with initial speed uu from the point that we shall call the origin. It reaches its highest point after its velocity has become zero. At that highest point the vertical displacement from the origin is given to be hh.

For a freely falling body, the kinematic relation between velocity vv, initial velocity uu, acceleration aa and displacement ss is stated first:

v2=u2+2as.v^{2}=u^{2}+2as.

Here at the top v=0v=0, the acceleration is that of gravity downward so a=−ga=-g, and the displacement is upward s=hs=h. Substituting these values we get

02=u2+2(−g)h    ⟹    u2=2gh.0^{2}=u^{2}+2(-g)h \;\;\Longrightarrow\;\; u^{2}=2gh.

This result will be useful shortly. Now we need the two instants at which the ball passes the height h3\dfrac{h}{3}, once on the way up and again on the way down. For vertical motion with constant acceleration the displacement after time tt is given by

y=ut−12gt2.y = ut-\dfrac12 gt^{2}.

At the required instants the vertical coordinate yy equals h3\dfrac{h}{3}, so we write

ut−12gt2=h3.ut-\dfrac12 gt^{2}=\dfrac{h}{3}.

Move every term to one side to obtain a quadratic equation in tt:

−12gt2+ut−h3=0.-\dfrac12 gt^{2}+ut-\dfrac{h}{3}=0.

Multiplying through by −1-1 to keep the leading coefficient positive,

12gt2−ut+h3=0.\dfrac12 gt^{2}-ut+\dfrac{h}{3}=0.

This is of the standard form at2+bt+c=0at^{2}+bt+c=0 with

a=g2,b=−u,c=h3.a=\dfrac{g}{2}, \qquad b=-u, \qquad c=\dfrac{h}{3}.

The quadratic-formula gives the two roots:

t=−b± b2−4ac 2a.t=\dfrac{-b\pm\sqrt{\,b^{2}-4ac\,}}{2a}.

Substituting the coefficients,

t=u±u2−2gh3g.t=\dfrac{u\pm\sqrt{u^{2}-\dfrac{2gh}{3}}}{g}.

In the discriminant we already know u2=2ghu^{2}=2gh, hence

u2−2gh3=2gh−2gh3=4gh3.u^{2}-\dfrac{2gh}{3}=2gh-\dfrac{2gh}{3}=\dfrac{4gh}{3}.

The square-root therefore becomes

u2−2gh3=4gh3=23gh.\sqrt{u^{2}-\dfrac{2gh}{3}}=\sqrt{\dfrac{4gh}{3}}=\dfrac{2}{\sqrt3}\sqrt{gh}.

Now put u=2ghu=\sqrt{2gh} and factor gh\sqrt{gh} out of the numerators:

t=2gh  ±  23ghg=ghg(2  ±  23).t=\dfrac{\sqrt{2gh}\;\pm\;\dfrac{2}{\sqrt3}\sqrt{gh}}{g} =\dfrac{\sqrt{gh}}{g}\left(\sqrt2 \;\pm\;\dfrac{2}{\sqrt3}\right).

Thus the earlier time (ascending) is

t1=ghg(2−23),t_{1}=\dfrac{\sqrt{gh}}{g}\left(\sqrt2-\dfrac{2}{\sqrt3}\right),

and the later time (descending) is

t2=ghg(2+23).t_{2}=\dfrac{\sqrt{gh}}{g}\left(\sqrt2+\dfrac{2}{\sqrt3}\right).

The required ratio of the two times is therefore

t1t2=2−232+23.\dfrac{t_{1}}{t_{2}} =\dfrac{\sqrt2-\dfrac{2}{\sqrt3}} {\sqrt2+\dfrac{2}{\sqrt3}}.

Multiply numerator and denominator by 3\sqrt3 to clear the fractional terms:

t1t2=32−232+2=6−26+2.\dfrac{t_{1}}{t_{2}} =\dfrac{\sqrt3\sqrt2-2} {\sqrt3\sqrt2+2} =\dfrac{\sqrt6-2}{\sqrt6+2}.

One may notice that an equivalent, and more compact, form is obtained by multiplying the previous numerator and denominator by 3−23−2\dfrac{\sqrt3-\sqrt2}{\sqrt3-\sqrt2}, yielding

t1t2=3−23+2.\dfrac{t_{1}}{t_{2}}=\dfrac{\sqrt3-\sqrt2}{\sqrt3+\sqrt2}.

This expression matches Option C in the list provided.

Hence, the correct answer is Option C.

Tagged Vertical motion under gravity. Machine-assigned, so read it as a strong shortlist rather than a verdict.

SubjectPhysics
TopicVertical motion under gravity
TypeMultiple choice