RankRizz
JEE MAIN 2020 · 06 SEP S2+4 / −1MEDIUMTRANSCRIBED

JEE Main 2020 Physics question — River-boat, rain-umbrella and wind problems

When a car is at rest, its driver sees rain drops falling on it vertically. When driving the car with speed vv, he sees that rain drops coming at an angle 60∘60^\circ from the horizontal. On further increasing the speed of the car to (1+β)v(1+\beta)v, this angle changes to 45∘45^\circ. The value of β\beta is close to:

SOLUTION

First let us choose a convenient coordinate system. We take the horizontal road surface as the xx-axis and the vertically downward direction (the direction in which raindrops actually fall) as the negative yy-axis. All speeds mentioned are measured with respect to the ground.

When the car is standing still, the driver observes the rain to be falling exactly vertically downward. Because the car is at rest in this situation, the velocity of the rain relative to the ground must itself be vertical. We therefore write the ground-frame velocity of the rain as

u⃗=−u ȷ^,\vec u=-u\,\hat{\jmath},

where u>0u>0 is the speed of the rain and the minus sign signifies the downward (negative yy) direction.

Now the car starts moving to the right (positive xx-direction) with speed vv. The ground-frame velocity of the car is then

v⃗c=v ı^.\vec v_c = v\,\hat{\imath}.

The driver in the car does not see the ground-frame velocity of the rain; instead he sees the relative velocity of the rain with respect to the car. The standard formula for relative velocity is stated first:

v⃗rain relative to car=u⃗−v⃗c.\vec v_{\text{rain relative to car}}=\vec u-\vec v_c.

Substituting the expressions for u⃗\vec u and v⃗c\vec v_c we obtain

v⃗rc=(−u ȷ^)−(v ı^)=−v ı^−u ȷ^.\vec v_{rc}=(-u\,\hat{\jmath})-(v\,\hat{\imath})=-v\,\hat{\imath}-u\,\hat{\jmath}.

The driver now sees this vector making an angle of 60∘60^\circ with the horizontal. The horizontal component is ∣−v∣=v|-v|=v and the vertical component is ∣−u∣=u|-u|=u, so from the definition of the tangent of an angle we have

tan⁡60∘=vertical componenthorizontal component=uv.\tan 60^\circ=\frac{\text{vertical component}}{\text{horizontal component}}=\frac{u}{v}.

Using tan⁡60∘=3\tan 60^\circ=\sqrt3 gives

3=uv⟹u=v3.−(1)\sqrt3=\frac{u}{v}\quad\Longrightarrow\quad u=v\sqrt3. \quad -(1)

Next the car’s speed is increased to (1+β)v(1+\beta)v. Its new ground-frame velocity becomes

v⃗c′=(1+β)v ı^.\vec v_c'=(1+\beta)v\,\hat{\imath}.

The new relative velocity of the rain with respect to the faster car is

v⃗rc′=u⃗−v⃗c′=(−u ȷ^)−(1+β)v ı^=−(1+β)v ı^−u ȷ^.\vec v_{rc}'=\vec u-\vec v_c'=(-u\,\hat{\jmath})-(1+\beta)v\,\hat{\imath}=-(1+\beta)v\,\hat{\imath}-u\,\hat{\jmath}.

This time the driver measures the angle made by this vector with the horizontal to be 45∘45^\circ. Therefore

tan⁡45∘=u(1+β)v.\tan 45^\circ=\frac{u}{(1+\beta)v}.

Because tan⁡45∘=1\tan 45^\circ=1, we get

1=u(1+β)v⟹u=(1+β)v.−(2)1=\frac{u}{(1+\beta)v}\quad\Longrightarrow\quad u=(1+\beta)v. \quad -(2)

We now have two expressions, (1) and (2), for the same quantity uu. Equating them gives

v3=(1+β)v.v\sqrt3=(1+\beta)v.

Since v≠0v\neq0, we can cancel vv from both sides to obtain

3=1+β⟹β=3−1.\sqrt3=1+\beta\quad\Longrightarrow\quad\beta=\sqrt3-1.

Using 3≈1.732\sqrt3\approx1.732 we calculate

β≈1.732−1=0.732  (approximately).\beta\approx1.732-1=0.732\;(\text{approximately}).

The closest option to this value is 0.730.73.

Hence, the correct answer is Option D.

Tagged River-boat, rain-umbrella and wind problems. Machine-assigned, so read it as a strong shortlist rather than a verdict.

SubjectPhysics
TopicRiver-boat, rain-umbrella and wind problems
TypeMultiple choice