RankRizz
JEE MAIN 2019 · 12 APR S1+4 / −1MEDIUMTRANSCRIBED

JEE Main 2019 Physics question — Earth's magnetism

A magnetic compass needle oscillates 30 times per minute at a place where the dip is 45° and 40 times per minute where the dip is 30°. If B1_1 and B2_2 are the net magnetic fields due to the earth at the two places respectively, then the ratio B1_1/B2_2 is approximately equal to

SOLUTION

We begin by recalling the theory of the small oscillations of a magnetic (compass) needle. When the needle is displaced slightly in the horizontal plane, the restoring torque is τ=MBHsin⁡θ≈MBHθ\tau = M B_H \sin\theta \approx M B_H \theta for small θ,\theta, where MM is the magnetic moment and BHB_H is the horizontal component of the earth’s magnetic field. For a body executing small-angle simple harmonic motion, the angular frequency is given by the standard formula

ω=restoring torque per unit anglemoment of inertia=MBHI.\omega = \sqrt{\dfrac{\text{restoring torque per unit angle}}{\text{moment of inertia}}} = \sqrt{\dfrac{M B_H}{I}}.

The ordinary (linear) frequency is f=ω2π,f = \dfrac{\omega}{2\pi}, so we have

f=12πMI BH.f = \dfrac{1}{2\pi}\sqrt{\dfrac{M}{I}}\,\sqrt{B_H}.

Everything except BHB_H is constant for the same needle; hence

f∝BH⟹BH∝f2.f \propto \sqrt{B_H} \quad\Longrightarrow\quad B_H \propto f^2.

Now we convert the given “oscillations per minute” to “oscillations per second” (hertz):

At the first place, the needle makes 30 oscillations in 60 s, so

f1=3060=0.50 Hz.f_1 = \dfrac{30}{60} = 0.50\ \text{Hz}.

At the second place, the needle makes 40 oscillations in 60 s, so

f2=4060=0.667 Hz.f_2 = \dfrac{40}{60} = 0.667\ \text{Hz}.

Using BH∝f2,B_H \propto f^2, we obtain

BH1BH2=(f1f2)2=(0.500.667)2=(0.75)2=0.5625.\dfrac{B_{H1}}{B_{H2}} = \left(\dfrac{f_1}{f_2}\right)^2 = \left(\dfrac{0.50}{0.667}\right)^2 = \left(0.75\right)^2 = 0.5625.

However, the question asks for the ratio of the total earth’s magnetic fields B1B_1 and B2,B_2, not just their horizontal components. The total field is related to its horizontal component by the well-known relation

BH=Bcos⁡δ,B_H = B\cos\delta,

where δ\delta is the dip (angle of inclination). Thus

B=BHcos⁡δ.B = \dfrac{B_H}{\cos\delta}.

So, for the two places,

B1B2=BH1/cos⁡δ1BH2/cos⁡δ2=BH1BH2  cos⁡δ2cos⁡δ1.\dfrac{B_1}{B_2} = \dfrac{B_{H1}/\cos\delta_1}{B_{H2}/\cos\delta_2} = \dfrac{B_{H1}}{B_{H2}}\;\dfrac{\cos\delta_2}{\cos\delta_1}.

The dips are δ1=45∘\delta_1 = 45^\circ and δ2=30∘.\delta_2 = 30^\circ. We substitute their cosines:

cos⁡45∘=12≈0.7071,cos⁡30∘=32≈0.8660.\cos45^\circ = \dfrac{1}{\sqrt2} \approx 0.7071,\qquad \cos30^\circ = \dfrac{\sqrt3}{2} \approx 0.8660.

Therefore,

cos⁡δ2cos⁡δ1=0.86600.7071≈1.2247.\dfrac{\cos\delta_2}{\cos\delta_1} = \dfrac{0.8660}{0.7071} \approx 1.2247.

Multiplying this with the earlier ratio of horizontal components, we get

B1B2=0.5625×1.2247≈0.688.\dfrac{B_1}{B_2} = 0.5625 \times 1.2247 \approx 0.688.

This value is very close to 0.7. Among the given options, the one that matches is 0.7.

Hence, the correct answer is Option D.

Tagged Earth's magnetism. Machine-assigned, so read it as a strong shortlist rather than a verdict.

SubjectPhysics
TopicEarth's magnetism
TypeMultiple choice