RankRizz
JEE MAIN 2020 · 06 SEP S2+4 / −1MEDIUMTRANSCRIBED

JEE Main 2020 Physics question — Newton's laws, free-body diagrams and equilibrium of a particle

A particle moving in the xy-plane experiences a velocity dependent force F⃗=k(vyi^+vxj^)\vec{F} = k(v_y\hat{i} + v_x\hat{j}), where vxv_x and vyv_y are the x and y components of its velocity v⃗\vec{v}. If a⃗\vec{a} is the acceleration of the particle, then which of the following statements is true for the particle?

SOLUTION

We have a particle of mass mm moving only in the xyxy-plane, so its velocity may be written as v⃗=vxi^+vyj^\vec v = v_x \hat i + v_y \hat j with vx=dxdtv_x = \dfrac{dx}{dt} and vy=dydtv_y = \dfrac{dy}{dt}. The force acting on it is given in the question as

F⃗=k(vyi^+vxj^).\vec F = k\bigl(v_y\hat i + v_x\hat j\bigr).

By Newton’s second law F⃗=ma⃗\vec F = m\vec a, therefore the acceleration components satisfy

ax=Fxm=km vy,ay=Fym=km vx.\begin{aligned} a_x &= \dfrac{F_x}{m} = \dfrac{k}{m}\,v_y,\\[4pt] a_y &= \dfrac{F_y}{m} = \dfrac{k}{m}\,v_x. \end{aligned}

So the two coupled differential equations for the velocity components are

dvxdt=km vy,(1)dvydt=km vx.(2)\begin{aligned} \frac{dv_x}{dt} &= \frac{k}{m}\,v_y, \quad\quad (1)\\[6pt] \frac{dv_y}{dt} &= \frac{k}{m}\,v_x. \quad\quad (2) \end{aligned}

Now we examine each statement one by one, using these relations.

Testing the constancy of v⃗×a⃗\vec v\times\vec a (Option A).

Because motion is confined to the plane, both v⃗\vec v and a⃗\vec a have zero zz-components, so their cross-product points along k^\hat k and its magnitude equals the scalar expression

v⃗×a⃗=(vxi^+vyj^)×(axi^+ayj^)=(vxay−vyax) k^.\vec v \times \vec a = (v_x\hat i + v_y\hat j)\times\bigl(a_x\hat i + a_y\hat j\bigr) = (v_x a_y - v_y a_x)\,\hat k.

Substituting axa_x and aya_y from above,

vxay−vyax=vx(kmvx)−vy(kmvy)=km(vx2−vy2).\begin{aligned} v_x a_y - v_y a_x &= v_x\left(\frac{k}{m}v_x\right) - v_y\left(\frac{k}{m}v_y\right)\\ &= \frac{k}{m}\left(v_x^2 - v_y^2\right). \end{aligned}

We differentiate this quantity with respect to time to see whether it changes:

ddt ⁣(vxay−vyax)=km ddt ⁣(vx2−vy2)=km (2vxv˙x−2vyv˙y)=2km (vxdvxdt−vydvydt).\begin{aligned} \frac{d}{dt}\!\left(v_x a_y - v_y a_x\right) &=\frac{k}{m}\,\frac{d}{dt}\!\left(v_x^2 - v_y^2\right)\\[6pt] &=\frac{k}{m}\,\bigl(2v_x\dot v_x - 2v_y\dot v_y\bigr)\\[6pt] &=\frac{2k}{m}\,\Bigl(v_x\frac{dv_x}{dt} - v_y\frac{dv_y}{dt}\Bigr). \end{aligned}

Using Eqs. (1) and (2): v˙x=kmvy\dot v_x = \dfrac{k}{m}v_y and v˙y=kmvx\dot v_y = \dfrac{k}{m}v_x, so

ddt ⁣(vxay−vyax)=2km(vx(kmvy)−vy(kmvx))=2km⋅km (vxvy−vyvx)=2k2m2 (0)=0.\begin{aligned} \frac{d}{dt}\!\left(v_x a_y - v_y a_x\right) &=\frac{2k}{m}\Bigl(v_x\left(\frac{k}{m}v_y\right) - v_y\left(\frac{k}{m}v_x\right)\Bigr)\\[6pt] &=\frac{2k}{m}\cdot\frac{k}{m}\,(v_x v_y - v_y v_x)\\[6pt] &=\frac{2k^2}{m^2}\,(0)=0. \end{aligned}

The time derivative is zero, so vxay−vyaxv_x a_y - v_y a_x, and hence v⃗×a⃗\vec v\times\vec a, is a constant vector. Therefore statement A is correct.

Testing whether F⃗\vec F could be a magnetic force (Option B).

A magnetic (Lorentz) force on a charge qq has the form F⃗=q v⃗×B⃗\vec F = q\,\vec v\times\vec B, which is always perpendicular to v⃗\vec v, implying v⃗⋅F⃗=0\vec v\cdot\vec F = 0. For the given force, however,

v⃗⋅F⃗=vx(kvy)+vy(kvx)=2k vxvy,\vec v\cdot\vec F = v_x(kv_y) + v_y(kv_x) = 2k\,v_x v_y,

which is in general non-zero. Hence the given force cannot come purely from a magnetic field, so statement B is false.

Testing the constancy of kinetic energy (Option C).

Kinetic energy is K=12mv2=12m(vx2+vy2).K = \dfrac12 m v^2 = \dfrac12 m(v_x^2 + v_y^2). Its time derivative is

dKdt=m v⃗⋅a⃗.\frac{dK}{dt} = m\,\vec v\cdot\vec a.

We have just computed v⃗⋅a⃗=2kmvxvy\vec v\cdot\vec a = 2\frac{k}{m}v_x v_y, so

dKdt=m(2kmvxvy)=2k vxvy,\frac{dK}{dt} = m\left(2\frac{k}{m}v_x v_y\right) = 2k\,v_x v_y,

which is not generally zero. Thus kinetic energy is not constant, and statement C is false.

Testing whether v⃗⋅a⃗\vec v\cdot\vec a itself is constant (Option D).

From above v⃗⋅a⃗=2kmvxvy.\vec v\cdot\vec a = 2\dfrac{k}{m}v_x v_y. Differentiating using the product rule and Eqs. (1) and (2),

ddt ⁣(v⃗⋅a⃗)=2km(vxv˙y+vyv˙x)=2km(vx⋅kmvx+vy⋅kmvy)=2k2m2(vx2+vy2),\begin{aligned} \frac{d}{dt}\!\bigl(\vec v\cdot\vec a\bigr) &=2\frac{k}{m}\Bigl(v_x\dot v_y + v_y\dot v_x\Bigr)\\[6pt] &=2\frac{k}{m}\Bigl(v_x\cdot\frac{k}{m}v_x + v_y\cdot\frac{k}{m}v_y\Bigr)\\[6pt] &=2\frac{k^2}{m^2}\bigl(v_x^2 + v_y^2\bigr), \end{aligned}

which is strictly positive (unless the particle is at rest). Therefore v⃗⋅a⃗\vec v\cdot\vec a is not constant, and statement D is false.

Only Option A stands up to scrutiny.

Hence, the correct answer is Option A.

Tagged Newton's laws, free-body diagrams and equilibrium of a particle. Machine-assigned, so read it as a strong shortlist rather than a verdict.

SubjectPhysics
TopicNewton's laws, free-body diagrams and equilibrium of a particle
TypeMultiple choice