JEE MAIN 2014 · 19 APR ONLINE+4 / −1MEDIUMTRANSCRIBED
JEE Main 2014 Physics question — Static and kinetic friction
A heavy box is to be dragged along a rough horizontal floor. To do so, the person A pushes it at an angle 30° from the horizontal and requires a minimum force FA, while the person B pulls the box at an angle 60° from the horizontal and needs minimum force FB. If the coefficient of friction between the box and the floor is 53, the ratio FBFA is:
SOLUTION
A heavy box is dragged along a rough horizontal floor. The coefficient of friction is given as μ=53. Person A pushes the box at an angle of 30° from the horizontal with a minimum force FA, and person B pulls it at an angle of 60° from the horizontal with a minimum force FB. We need to find the ratio FBFA.
First, consider the forces acting on the box. The weight of the box is mg, where m is the mass and g is the acceleration due to gravity. The normal force N is the force exerted by the floor perpendicular to the surface. The friction force opposes motion and is given by f=μN. The minimum force required to move the box occurs when the horizontal component of the applied force equals the maximum static friction force.
Start with person A, who pushes the box at 30° to the horizontal. When pushing, the vertical component of the force acts downward, increasing the normal force. Resolve FA into components:
Horizontal component: FAcos30∘
Vertical component: FAsin30∘ (downward)
The normal force NA is:
NA=mg+FAsin30∘
The friction force is:
fA=μNA=μ(mg+FAsin30∘)
At the point of motion, the horizontal component equals the friction force:
FAcos30∘=μ(mg+FAsin30∘)
Substitute the trigonometric values: cos30∘=23 and sin30∘=21:
FA⋅23=μ(mg+FA⋅21)
Given μ=53, substitute:
FA⋅23=53(mg+2FA)
Divide both sides by 3 (since 3=0):
2FA=51(mg+2FA)
Multiply both sides by 5 to eliminate the denominator:
5⋅2FA=mg+2FA
25FA=mg+2FA
Subtract 2FA from both sides:
25FA−2FA=mg
24FA=mg
2FA=mg
FA=2mg
Now, consider person B, who pulls the box at 60° to the horizontal. When pulling, the vertical component acts upward, reducing the normal force. Resolve FB into components:
Horizontal component: FBcos60∘
Vertical component: FBsin60∘ (upward)
The normal force NB is:
NB=mg−FBsin60∘
The friction force is:
fB=μNB=μ(mg−FBsin60∘)
At the point of motion, the horizontal component equals the friction force:
FBcos60∘=μ(mg−FBsin60∘)
Substitute the trigonometric values: cos60∘=21 and sin60∘=23:
FB⋅21=μ(mg−FB⋅23)
Given μ=53, substitute:
2FB=53(mg−23FB)
Multiply both sides by 10 to eliminate denominators:
10⋅2FB=10⋅53(mg−23FB)
5FB=23(mg−23FB)
Expand the right side:
5FB=23⋅mg−23⋅23FB
Simplify the second term:
23⋅23FB=3⋅3FB=3FB
So:
5FB=23mg−3FB
Add 3FB to both sides:
5FB+3FB=23mg
8FB=23mg
Divide both sides by 2:
4FB=3mg
FB=43mg
Now, find the ratio FBFA:
FBFA=43mg2mg=2mg⋅3mg4=234=32
The ratio FBFA=32, which matches option B.
Hence, the correct answer is Option B.
Tagged Static and kinetic friction. Machine-assigned, so read it as a strong shortlist rather than a verdict.