JEE Main 2024 Physics question — Kepler's laws and planetary motion
Two planets A and B having masses m1 and m2 move around the sun in circular orbits of r1 and r2 radii respectively. If angular momentum of A is L and that of B is 3L, the ratio of time period (TBTA) is:
SOLUTION
For a planet of mass m moving in a circular orbit of radius r around the Sun (mass M⊙), the necessary centripetal force is provided by gravitation:
r2GM⊙m=rmv2
Solving for the orbital speed,
v=rGM⊙−(1)
Angular momentum about the Sun is
L=mvr
Substituting v from (1),
L=mrrGM⊙=mGM⊙r−(2)
Applying (2) to planets A and B:
LA=m1GM⊙r1 LB=m2GM⊙r2
Given LB=3LA,
m2GM⊙r2=3m1GM⊙r1
Canceling the common factor GM⊙,
m2r2=3m1r1−(3)
From (3),
r1r2=m23m1
Squaring both sides: r1r2=m229m12−(4)
Kepler’s third law for circular orbits gives the time period:
T=2πGM⊙r3∝r3/2−(5)
Therefore,
TBTA=(r2r1)3/2−(6)
Insert r2r1 from (4) into (6):
TBTA=(9m12m22)3/2
Compute the exponent:
(9m12m22)3/2=(m1m2)3(91)3/2
Since 9=32, we have 93/2=33=27. Thus
TBTA=271(m1m2)3
Hence, the correct ratio is 271(m1m2)3, which corresponds to Option B.
Tagged Kepler's laws and planetary motion. Machine-assigned, so read it as a strong shortlist rather than a verdict.