RankRizz
JEE MAIN 2020 · 07 JAN S1+4 / −1HARDTRANSCRIBED

JEE Main 2020 Physics question — Escape speed

A satellite of mass MM is launched vertically upwards with an initial speed uu from the surface of the earth. After it reaches height RR (RR = radius of the earth), it ejects a rocket of mass M10\frac{M}{10} so that subsequently the satellite moves in a circular orbit. The kinetic energy of the rocket is (GG is the gravitational constant; MeM_e is the mass of the earth):

SOLUTION

We have a satellite of mass MM that is fired vertically from the surface of the earth (radius RR) with speed uu. Its total mechanical energy just after launch is

E0=12Mu2−GMeMR.E_0=\frac12Mu^{2}-\frac{GM_eM}{R}.

When it rises to a height RR above the surface its distance from the earth’s centre is r=R+R=2Rr=R+R=2R. At that instant let its speed be vv. Applying conservation of mechanical energy between the point of launch and the point r=2Rr=2R, we write

12Mu2−GMeMR=12Mv2−GMeM2R.\frac12Mu^{2}-\frac{GM_eM}{R}= \frac12Mv^{2}-\frac{GM_eM}{2R}.

Simplifying,

12Mu2−GMeMR+GMeM2R=12Mv2</p><p>  ⟹  </p><p>12Mv2=12Mu2−GMeM2R.\frac12Mu^{2}-\frac{GM_eM}{R}+ \frac{GM_eM}{2R}= \frac12Mv^{2} </p> <p>\;\Longrightarrow\;</p> <p>\frac12Mv^{2}= \frac12Mu^{2}-\frac{GM_eM}{2R}.

Dividing by 12M\tfrac12M we get

v2=u2−GMeR.−(1)v^{2}=u^{2}-\frac{GM_e}{R}. \quad -(1)

Immediately afterwards the satellite ejects a small rocket of mass M10\dfrac{M}{10}, so the remaining mass of the satellite becomes

Ms=9M10.M_s=\frac{9M}{10}.

The problem states that the satellite (of mass 9M10\dfrac{9M}{10}) now moves in a circular orbit of radius 2R2R. The speed required for a circular orbit of radius rr is obtained from the centripetal-gravitational balance

vc2r=GMer2</p><p>  ⟹  </p><p>vc=GMer</p><p>=GMe2R.−(2)\frac{v_c^{2}}{r}=\frac{GM_e}{r^{2}}</p> <p>\;\Longrightarrow\;</p> <p>v_c=\sqrt{\frac{GM_e}{r}}</p> <p> =\sqrt{\frac{GM_e}{2R}}. \quad -(2)

During the extremely short interval of ejection, the only external force is gravity, which is radial; its impulse is therefore negligible. Hence the linear momentum of the system (satellite + rocket) is conserved separately in the radial and tangential directions.

Radial direction. Before ejection the entire mass MM is moving radially outward with speed vv, so the initial radial momentum is

Pr, initial=Mv.P_{r,\,\text{initial}}=Mv.

After ejection, the satellite is moving purely tangentially (no radial component), so all the radial momentum must be carried by the rocket (mass M10\dfrac{M}{10}). Let vr,∥v_{r,\parallel} be the radial component of the rocket’s velocity. Conservation gives

Mv=M10 vr,∥</p><p>  ⟹  </p><p>vr,∥=10v.−(3)Mv=\frac{M}{10}\,v_{r,\parallel}</p> <p>\;\Longrightarrow\;</p> <p>v_{r,\parallel}=10v. \quad -(3)

Tangential direction. Initially the tangential momentum is zero (vertical launch). After ejection the satellite (mass 9M10\dfrac{9M}{10}) moves tangentially with speed vcv_c. Let vr,⊥v_{r,\perp} be the tangential component of the rocket’s velocity. Conservation of tangential momentum gives

0=9M10 vc+M10 vr,⊥</p><p>  ⟹  </p><p>vr,⊥=−9vc.−(4)0=\frac{9M}{10}\,v_c+\frac{M}{10}\,v_{r,\perp}</p> <p>\;\Longrightarrow\;</p> <p>v_{r,\perp}=-9v_c. \quad -(4)

(The negative sign shows that the rocket’s tangential motion is opposite to that of the satellite.)

Magnitude of the rocket’s velocity. Because the radial and tangential components are perpendicular, the speed of the rocket is

vr=vr,∥2+vr,⊥2</p><p>=(10v)2+(−9vc)2</p><p>=100v2+81vc2.−(5)v_r=\sqrt{v_{r,\parallel}^{2}+v_{r,\perp}^{2}}</p> <p> =\sqrt{(10v)^{2}+(-9v_c)^{2}}</p> <p> =\sqrt{100v^{2}+81v_c^{2}}. \quad -(5)

Kinetic energy of the rocket. Using K=12mv2K=\tfrac12mv^{2},

Kr=12(M10)vr2</p><p>=M20(100v2+81vc2).−(6)K_r=\frac12\left(\frac{M}{10}\right)v_r^{2}</p> <p> =\frac{M}{20}\bigl(100v^{2}+81v_c^{2}\bigr). \quad -(6)

Now substitute from (1) and (2):

v2=u2−GMeR,</p><p>vc2=GMe2R.v^{2}=u^{2}-\frac{GM_e}{R}, \qquad</p> <p>v_c^{2}=\frac{GM_e}{2R}.

Putting these into (6),

</p><p></p><p>Kr</p><p>=M20[100(u2−GMeR)</p><p>+81(GMe2R)]</p><p>=M20[100u2−100GMeR</p><p>+812GMeR]</p><p>=M20[100u2−100GMeR</p><p>+40.5GMeR]</p><p>=M20[100u2−59.5GMeR].</p><p></p><p></p> <p>\begin{aligned}</p> <p>K_r</p> <p>&=\frac{M}{20}\Bigl[100\Bigl(u^{2}-\frac{GM_e}{R}\Bigr)</p> <p> +81\Bigl(\frac{GM_e}{2R}\Bigr)\Bigr] \\</p> <p>&=\frac{M}{20}\Bigl[100u^{2}-100\frac{GM_e}{R}</p> <p> +\frac{81}{2}\frac{GM_e}{R}\Bigr] \\</p> <p>&=\frac{M}{20}\Bigl[100u^{2}-100\frac{GM_e}{R}</p> <p> +40.5\frac{GM_e}{R}\Bigr] \\</p> <p>&=\frac{M}{20}\Bigl[100u^{2}-59.5\frac{GM_e}{R}\Bigr].</p> <p>\end{aligned}</p> <p>

Factorising the common factor 100100 inside the bracket,

</p><p>Kr</p><p>=M20⋅100[u2−0.595GMeR]</p><p>=5M(u2−119200GMeR).−(7)</p><p></p> <p>K_r</p> <p>=\frac{M}{20}\cdot100\Bigl[u^{2}-0.595\frac{GM_e}{R}\Bigr]</p> <p>=5M\left(u^{2}-\frac{119}{200}\frac{GM_e}{R}\right). \quad -(7)</p> <p>

This matches Option B exactly.

Hence, the correct answer is Option 2.

Tagged Escape speed. Machine-assigned, so read it as a strong shortlist rather than a verdict.

SubjectPhysics
TopicEscape speed
TypeMultiple choice