JEE Main 2021 Physics question — Gravitational potential energy of systems
A body of mass (2M) splits into four masses {m,M−m,m,M−m}, which are rearranged to form a square as shown in the figure. The ratio of mM for which, the gravitational potential energy of the system becomes maximum is x:1. The value of x is _________.
SOLUTION
1. Understand the System Configuration
Let the four masses be placed at the corners of a square of side d in a cyclic order:
Corner 1: m
Corner 2: M−m
Corner 3: m
Corner 4: M−m
The distance between adjacent corners is d, and the distance between diagonally opposite corners is 2d.
2. Write the Expression for Total Gravitational Potential Energy (U)
The total gravitational potential energy of a system of particles is the sum of the potential energies of all unique pairs:
U=−∑rijGmimj
Let's calculate the interactions by grouping them by distance:
Four Adjacent Pairs (at distance d):
Between Corner 1 and Corner 2: −dGm(M−m)
Between Corner 2 and Corner 3: −dG(M−m)m
Between Corner 3 and Corner 4: −dGm(M−m)
Between Corner 4 and Corner 1: −dG(M−m)m
Sum of adjacent interactions = −4dGm(M−m)
Two Diagonal Pairs (at distance 2d):
Between Corner 1 and Corner 3 (both mass m): −2dGm2
Between Corner 2 and Corner 4 (both mass M−m): −2dG(M−m)2
Sum of diagonal interactions = −2dG[m2+(M−m)2]
Combining all pairs, the total potential energy expression is:
U=−dG[4m(M−m)+21(m2+(M−m)2)]
3. Maximize the Potential Energy
Since gravitational potential energy is a negative quantity, maximizing the potential energy means making its absolute magnitude minimum, or directly finding the critical point where dmdU=0.
Let's differentiate the expression inside the bracket with respect to m and set it to zero:
dmd[4(Mm−m2)+21(m2+M2−2Mm+m2)]=0
dmd[4Mm−4m2+21(2m2−2Mm+M2)]=0
Performing the differentiation step-by-step:
[4M−8m+21(4m−2M)]=0
4M−8m+24m−22M=0
4M−2M=8m−22m
4. Determine the Ratio mM
Factor out M on the left side and m on the right side:
M(4−2)=m(8−22)
Notice that the right side can be factored further by pulling out a 2:
M(4−2)=2m(4−2)
Canceling out the common term (4−2) from both sides gives:
M=2m⟹mM=2
Given that the ratio mM=x:1, we find that x=2.
Final Answer:2
Tagged Gravitational potential energy of systems. Machine-assigned, so read it as a strong shortlist rather than a verdict.