RankRizz
JEE MAIN 2021 · 27 AUG S1+4MEDIUMTRANSCRIBED

JEE Main 2021 Physics question — Gravitational potential energy of systems

A body of mass (2M)(2M) splits into four masses {m,M−m,m,M−m}\{m, M-m, m, M-m\}, which are rearranged to form a square as shown in the figure. The ratio of Mm\frac{M}{m} for which, the gravitational potential energy of the system becomes maximum is x:1x : 1. The value of xx is _________.

Figure for JEE Main 2021 Physics question on Gravitational potential energy of systems
SOLUTION

1. Understand the System Configuration

Let the four masses be placed at the corners of a square of side dd in a cyclic order:

  • Corner 1: mm
  • Corner 2: M−mM-m
  • Corner 3: mm
  • Corner 4: M−mM-m

The distance between adjacent corners is dd, and the distance between diagonally opposite corners is 2d\sqrt{2}d.


2. Write the Expression for Total Gravitational Potential Energy (UU)

The total gravitational potential energy of a system of particles is the sum of the potential energies of all unique pairs:

U=−∑GmimjrijU = -\sum \frac{G m_i m_j}{r_{ij}}

Let's calculate the interactions by grouping them by distance:

  • Four Adjacent Pairs (at distance dd):
    • Between Corner 1 and Corner 2: −Gm(M−m)d-\frac{G m(M-m)}{d}
    • Between Corner 2 and Corner 3: −G(M−m)md-\frac{G(M-m)m}{d}
    • Between Corner 3 and Corner 4: −Gm(M−m)d-\frac{G m(M-m)}{d}
    • Between Corner 4 and Corner 1: −G(M−m)md-\frac{G(M-m)m}{d}
    Sum of adjacent interactions = −4Gm(M−m)d-4 \frac{G m(M-m)}{d}

  • Two Diagonal Pairs (at distance 2d\sqrt{2}d):
    • Between Corner 1 and Corner 3 (both mass mm): −Gm22d-\frac{G m^2}{\sqrt{2}d}
    • Between Corner 2 and Corner 4 (both mass M−mM-m): −G(M−m)22d-\frac{G (M-m)^2}{\sqrt{2}d}
    Sum of diagonal interactions = −G2d[m2+(M−m)2]-\frac{G}{\sqrt{2}d} \left[ m^2 + (M-m)^2 \right]

Combining all pairs, the total potential energy expression is:

U=−Gd[4m(M−m)+12(m2+(M−m)2)]U = -\frac{G}{d} \left[ 4m(M-m) + \frac{1}{\sqrt{2}}(m^2 + (M-m)^2) \right]


3. Maximize the Potential Energy

Since gravitational potential energy is a negative quantity, maximizing the potential energy means making its absolute magnitude minimum, or directly finding the critical point where dUdm=0\frac{dU}{dm} = 0.

Let's differentiate the expression inside the bracket with respect to mm and set it to zero:

ddm[4(Mm−m2)+12(m2+M2−2Mm+m2)]=0\frac{d}{dm} \left[ 4(Mm - m^2) + \frac{1}{\sqrt{2}}(m^2 + M^2 - 2Mm + m^2) \right] = 0

ddm[4Mm−4m2+12(2m2−2Mm+M2)]=0\frac{d}{dm} \left[ 4Mm - 4m^2 + \frac{1}{\sqrt{2}}(2m^2 - 2Mm + M^2) \right] = 0

Performing the differentiation step-by-step:

[4M−8m+12(4m−2M)]=0\left[ 4M - 8m + \frac{1}{\sqrt{2}}(4m - 2M) \right] = 0

4M−8m+42m−22M=04M - 8m + \frac{4}{\sqrt{2}}m - \frac{2}{\sqrt{2}}M = 0

4M−2M=8m−22m4M - \sqrt{2}M = 8m - 2\sqrt{2}m


4. Determine the Ratio Mm\frac{M}{m}

Factor out MM on the left side and mm on the right side:

M(4−2)=m(8−22)M(4 - \sqrt{2}) = m(8 - 2\sqrt{2})

Notice that the right side can be factored further by pulling out a 22:

M(4−2)=2m(4−2)M(4 - \sqrt{2}) = 2m(4 - \sqrt{2})

Canceling out the common term (4−2)(4 - \sqrt{2}) from both sides gives:

M=2m  ⟹  Mm=2M = 2m \implies \frac{M}{m} = 2

Given that the ratio Mm=x:1\frac{M}{m} = x : 1, we find that x=2x = 2.

Final Answer: 2

Tagged Gravitational potential energy of systems. Machine-assigned, so read it as a strong shortlist rather than a verdict.

SubjectPhysics
TopicGravitational potential energy of systems
TypeNumerical answer