RankRizz
JEE MAIN 2018 · 15 APR S1+4 / −1MEDIUMTRANSCRIBED

JEE Main 2018 Physics question — Kepler's laws and planetary motion

Take the mean distance of the moon and the sun from the earth to be 0.4×1060.4 \times 10^6 km and 150×106150 \times 10^6 km respectively. Their masses are 8×10228 \times 10^{22} kg and 2×10302 \times 10^{30} kg respectively. The radius of the earth is 6400 km. Let ΔF1\Delta F_1 be the difference in the forces exerted by the moon at the nearest and farthest points on the earth and ΔF2\Delta F_2 be the difference in the force exerted by the sun at the nearest and farthest points on the earth. Then, the number closest to ΔF1ΔF2\frac{\Delta F_1}{\Delta F_2} is:

SOLUTION

We begin with Newton’s universal law of gravitation, which gives the magnitude of the force exerted by a body of mass MM on a small test mass mm situated at a distance rr as

F  =  G M mr2,F \;=\; \dfrac{G\,M\,m}{r^{2}},

where GG is the gravitational constant.

The earth is a sphere of radius R=6400  kmR = 6400\;\text{km}. For a celestial body whose centre is at a distance DD from the centre of the earth, the distance of that body from

• the nearest point on the earth’s surface is D−RD - R,

• the farthest point on the earth’s surface is D+RD + R.

Hence the forces on a unit test mass at these two points are

Fnear=G M(D−R)2,Ffar=G M(D+R)2.F_{\text{near}} = \dfrac{G\,M}{(D - R)^{2}}, \qquad F_{\text{far}} = \dfrac{G\,M}{(D + R)^{2}}.

The difference (which is what produces the tidal effect) is therefore

ΔF  =  Fnear  −  Ffar  =  G M ⁣[1(D−R)2  −  1(D+R)2].\Delta F \;=\; F_{\text{near}} \;-\; F_{\text{far}} \;=\; G\,M \!\left[ \dfrac{1}{(D - R)^{2}} \;-\; \dfrac{1}{(D + R)^{2}} \right].

Because the earth’s radius is very small compared with any celestial distance (i.e. R≪DR \ll D), we expand each denominator by writing

(D±R)−2  =  D−2 (1±RD)−2  ≈  D−2 (1∓2RD),(D \pm R)^{-2} \;=\; D^{-2}\,(1 \pm \tfrac{R}{D})^{-2} \;\approx\; D^{-2}\,\bigl(1 \mp 2\tfrac{R}{D}\bigr),

using the binomial approximation (1+x)n≈1+nx(1 + x)^{n} \approx 1 + nx for small xx.

Substituting the expanded forms, we get

1(D−R)2≈D−2 ⁣(1+2RD),1(D+R)2≈D−2 ⁣(1−2RD).\dfrac{1}{(D - R)^{2}} \approx D^{-2}\!\left(1 + 2\frac{R}{D}\right), \qquad \dfrac{1}{(D + R)^{2}} \approx D^{-2}\!\left(1 - 2\frac{R}{D}\right).

Taking their difference yields

1(D−R)2−1(D+R)2≈D−2 ⁣(1+2RD−1+2RD)  =  4 RD3.\dfrac{1}{(D - R)^{2}} - \dfrac{1}{(D + R)^{2}} \approx D^{-2}\!\Bigl(1 + 2\frac{R}{D} - 1 + 2\frac{R}{D}\Bigr) \;=\; 4\,\dfrac{R}{D^{3}}.

Hence

  ΔF≈4 G M RD3  .\boxed{\;\Delta F \approx 4\,G\,M\,\dfrac{R}{D^{3}}\;}.

Notice that GG, the earth’s radius RR and the test mass have the same values for both the moon and the sun, so they will cancel when we form the required ratio. Writing

ΔF1 (moon)=4 G MmoonRDmoon 3,\Delta F_{1} \text{ (moon)} = 4\,G\,M_{\text{moon}}\dfrac{R}{D_{\text{moon}}^{\,3}}, ΔF2 (sun)=4 G Msun RDsun  3,\Delta F_{2} \text{ (sun)} = 4\,G\,M_{\text{sun }}\dfrac{R}{D_{\text{sun }}^{\,3}},

we obtain

ΔF1ΔF2=MmoonMsun(DsunDmoon) ⁣3.\dfrac{\Delta F_{1}}{\Delta F_{2}} = \dfrac{M_{\text{moon}}}{M_{\text{sun}}} \left(\dfrac{D_{\text{sun}}}{D_{\text{moon}}}\right)^{\!3}.

Now we substitute the numerical data (the units are all consistent because every distance is in kilometres and every mass in kilograms):

Mmoon=8×1022,Msun=2×1030,M_{\text{moon}} = 8 \times 10^{22}, \qquad M_{\text{sun}} = 2 \times 10^{30},

Dmoon=0.4×106,Dsun=150×106.D_{\text{moon}} = 0.4 \times 10^{6}, \qquad D_{\text{sun}} = 150 \times 10^{6}.

First the mass ratio:

MmoonMsun=8×10222×1030=4×10−8.\dfrac{M_{\text{moon}}}{M_{\text{sun}}} = \dfrac{8 \times 10^{22}}{2 \times 10^{30}} = 4 \times 10^{-8}.

Next the distance ratio:

DsunDmoon=150×1060.4×106=1500.4=375.\dfrac{D_{\text{sun}}}{D_{\text{moon}}} = \dfrac{150 \times 10^{6}}{0.4 \times 10^{6}} = \dfrac{150}{0.4} = 375.

Its cube is

3753=(375)2×375=140 625×375=52 734 375.375^{3} = (375)^{2}\times 375 = 140\,625 \times 375 = 52\,734\,375.

Finally, combining everything,

ΔF1ΔF2=(4×10−8)  ×52 734 375=2.109375  ≈  2.\dfrac{\Delta F_{1}}{\Delta F_{2}} = \bigl(4 \times 10^{-8}\bigr)\; \times 52\,734\,375 = 2.109375 \; \approx \; 2.

Thus the number closest to ΔF1ΔF2\dfrac{\Delta F_{1}}{\Delta F_{2}} is 22.

Hence, the correct answer is Option A.

Tagged Kepler's laws and planetary motion. Machine-assigned, so read it as a strong shortlist rather than a verdict.

SubjectPhysics
TopicKepler's laws and planetary motion
TypeMultiple choice