We begin with Newton’s universal law of gravitation, which gives the magnitude of the force exerted by a body of mass M on a small test mass m situated at a distance r as
F=r2GMm,
where G is the gravitational constant.
The earth is a sphere of radius R=6400km. For a celestial body whose centre is at a distance D from the centre of the earth, the distance of that body from
• the nearest point on the earth’s surface is D−R,
• the farthest point on the earth’s surface is D+R.
Hence the forces on a unit test mass at these two points are
Fnear=(D−R)2GM,Ffar=(D+R)2GM.
The difference (which is what produces the tidal effect) is therefore
ΔF=Fnear−Ffar=GM[(D−R)21−(D+R)21].
Because the earth’s radius is very small compared with any celestial distance (i.e. R≪D), we expand each denominator by writing
(D±R)−2=D−2(1±DR)−2≈D−2(1∓2DR),
using the binomial approximation (1+x)n≈1+nx for small x.
Substituting the expanded forms, we get
(D−R)21≈D−2(1+2DR),(D+R)21≈D−2(1−2DR).
Taking their difference yields
(D−R)21−(D+R)21≈D−2(1+2DR−1+2DR)=4D3R.
Hence
ΔF≈4GMD3R.
Notice that G, the earth’s radius R and the test mass have the same values for both the moon and the sun, so they will cancel when we form the required ratio. Writing
ΔF1 (moon)=4GMmoonDmoon3R,
ΔF2 (sun)=4GMsun Dsun 3R,
we obtain
ΔF2ΔF1=MsunMmoon(DmoonDsun)3.
Now we substitute the numerical data (the units are all consistent because every distance is in kilometres and every mass in kilograms):
Mmoon=8×1022,Msun=2×1030,
Dmoon=0.4×106,Dsun=150×106.
First the mass ratio:
MsunMmoon=2×10308×1022=4×10−8.
Next the distance ratio:
DmoonDsun=0.4×106150×106=0.4150=375.
Its cube is
3753=(375)2×375=140625×375=52734375.
Finally, combining everything,
ΔF2ΔF1=(4×10−8)×52734375=2.109375≈2.
Thus the number closest to ΔF2ΔF1 is 2.
Hence, the correct answer is Option A.