RankRizz
JEE MAIN 2019 · 12 JAN S2+4 / −1EASYTRANSCRIBED

JEE Main 2019 Physics question — Satellites: orbital speed, period, energy and geostationary orbits

Two satellites, A and B, have masses m and 2m respectively. A is in a circular orbit of radius R and B is in a circular orbit of radius 2R around the earth. The ratio of their kinetic energies, KAKB\frac{K_A}{K_B} is:

SOLUTION

Let the mass of the earth be denoted by MEM_E and the universal gravitational constant by GG. For a satellite moving in a circular orbit, the necessary centripetal force comes entirely from the gravitational attraction of the earth. Hence we write the force-centripetal balance equation:

G ME msr2=ms v2r.\frac{G\,M_E\,m_s}{r^2} = \frac{m_s\,v^2}{r}.

Here msm_s is the mass of the satellite, rr is the orbital radius and vv is the orbital speed. Cancelling the common factor msm_s and one power of rr we get

v2=G MEr.v^2 = \frac{G\,M_E}{r}.

The kinetic energy of a body of mass msm_s moving with speed vv is given by the standard formula K=12msv2K = \tfrac12 m_s v^2. Substituting the expression for v2v^2 obtained above, we have

K=12ms(G MEr)=G ME ms2 r.K = \tfrac12 m_s \left(\frac{G\,M_E}{r}\right) = \frac{G\,M_E\,m_s}{2\,r}.

This shows that for satellites around the same planet, the kinetic energy is directly proportional to the satellite mass and inversely proportional to the orbital radius:

K∝msr.K \propto \frac{m_s}{r}.

Now we apply this result to the two satellites mentioned in the question.

Satellite A has mass mA=mm_A = m and orbital radius rA=Rr_A = R. Therefore,

KA=G ME m2 R.K_A = \frac{G\,M_E\,m}{2\,R}.

Satellite B has mass mB=2mm_B = 2m and orbital radius rB=2Rr_B = 2R. Therefore,

KB=G ME (2m)2 (2R)=2 G ME m4 R=G ME m2 R.K_B = \frac{G\,M_E\,(2m)}{2\,(2R)} = \frac{2\,G\,M_E\,m}{4\,R} = \frac{G\,M_E\,m}{2\,R}.

We observe that the factors GG, MEM_E and 2R2R neatly cancel to give the same numerator and denominator as in the expression for KAK_A. Hence

KA=KB.K_A = K_B.

Taking the ratio,

KAKB=KBKB=1.\frac{K_A}{K_B} = \frac{K_B}{K_B} = 1.

Hence, the correct answer is Option C.

Tagged Satellites: orbital speed, period, energy and geostationary orbits. Machine-assigned, so read it as a strong shortlist rather than a verdict.

SubjectPhysics
TopicSatellites: orbital speed, period, energy and geostationary orbits
TypeMultiple choice