RankRizz
JEE MAIN 2019 · 12 JAN S1+4 / −1MEDIUMTRANSCRIBED

JEE Main 2019 Physics question — Kepler's laws and planetary motion

A straight rod of length L extends from x=ax = a to x=L+ax = L + a. The gravitational force it exerts on a point mass 'm' at x=0x = 0, if the mass per unit length of the rod is A+Bx2A + Bx^2, is given by:

SOLUTION

We have a point mass of magnitude mm placed at the origin x=0x = 0. A thin straight rod lies along the positive xx-axis, beginning at x=ax = a and ending at x=a+Lx = a + L. Its mass per unit length (linear mass density) varies with position according to

λ(x)=A+Bx2.\lambda(x)=A + Bx^{2}.

Our aim is to find the total gravitational force (magnitude) exerted by every small element of the rod on the mass at the origin. Throughout we shall use Newton’s law of gravitation, which in differential form for two small masses separated by a distance rr is

dF=G dm1 dm2r2.dF=\frac{G\,dm_1\,dm_2}{r^{2}}.

Here dm1=mdm_1 = m (the point mass) and dm2=dmdm_2 = dm (an infinitesimal element of the rod). The separation between the element located at position xx and the origin is simply r=xr = x. Substituting these facts, we get

dF=G m dmx2.dF = \frac{G\,m\,dm}{x^{2}}.

Because each element lies on the positive xx-axis while the point mass is at the origin, every elemental force acts along the negative xx-direction. We shall calculate its magnitude first and later attach the direction if required.

The infinitesimal mass element of the rod is given by the product of its linear density and an infinitesimal length dxdx:

dm=λ(x) dx=(A+Bx2) dx.dm = \lambda(x)\,dx = (A + Bx^{2})\,dx.

Placing this expression for dmdm into the formula for dFdF, we obtain

dF=G m (A+Bx2)x2  dx.dF = \frac{G\,m\,(A + Bx^{2})}{x^{2}}\;dx.

Now we separate the fraction:

dF=Gm(Ax2+B) dx.dF = Gm\left(\frac{A}{x^{2}} + B\right)\,dx.

To find the total force, we integrate dFdF from the near end of the rod at x=ax = a to the far end at x=a+Lx = a + L:

F=Gm∫aa+L(Ax2+B) dx.F = Gm \int_{a}^{a+L} \left(\frac{A}{x^{2}} + B\right)\,dx.

We evaluate the integral term by term.

First term: for ∫Ax2 dx\displaystyle \int \frac{A}{x^{2}}\,dx, we recall the standard result

∫x−2 dx=−x−1+C,\int x^{-2}\,dx = -x^{-1} + C,

so

∫Ax2 dx=A∫x−2 dx=−Ax.\int \frac{A}{x^{2}}\,dx = A\int x^{-2}\,dx = -\frac{A}{x}.

Second term: for ∫B dx\displaystyle \int B\,dx, BB is a constant, hence

∫B dx=Bx.\int B\,dx = Bx.

Combining these results, the definite integral becomes

F=Gm[ −Ax+Bx  ]x=ax=a+L.F = Gm\left[\,-\frac{A}{x} + Bx\;\right]_{x=a}^{x=a+L}.

We substitute the limits. First, the upper limit x=a+Lx = a + L:

Upper contribution  =−Aa+L+B(a+L).= -\frac{A}{a + L} + B(a + L).

Next, the lower limit x=ax = a:

Lower contribution  =−Aa+Ba.= -\frac{A}{a} + Ba.

Subtracting the lower contribution from the upper gives the net value of the bracketed expression:

F=Gm[(−Aa+L+B(a+L))  −  (−Aa+Ba)]=Gm[−Aa+L+B(a+L)+Aa−Ba].\begin{aligned} F &= Gm\Bigg[\left(-\frac{A}{a + L} + B(a + L)\right) \;-\; \left(-\frac{A}{a} + Ba\right)\Bigg] \\ &= Gm\Bigg[-\frac{A}{a + L} + B(a + L) + \frac{A}{a} - Ba\Bigg]. \end{aligned}

The two BaBa terms cancel:

B(a+L)−Ba  =  BL.B(a + L) - Ba \;=\; BL.

Hence the expression inside the brackets simplifies to

−Aa+L+Aa+BL.-\frac{A}{a + L} + \frac{A}{a} + BL.

Reordering the terms more conventionally, we write

Aa−Aa+L+BL.\frac{A}{a} - \frac{A}{a + L} + BL.

Therefore the magnitude of the gravitational force is

F=Gm[A ⁣(1a−1a+L)+BL].F = Gm\left[A\!\left(\frac{1}{a} - \frac{1}{a + L}\right) + BL\right].

This matches the expression given in Option D.

Hence, the correct answer is Option D.

Tagged Kepler's laws and planetary motion. Machine-assigned, so read it as a strong shortlist rather than a verdict.

SubjectPhysics
TopicKepler's laws and planetary motion
TypeMultiple choice