RankRizz
JEE MAIN 2019 · 12 JAN S1+4 / −1MEDIUMTRANSCRIBED

JEE Main 2019 Physics question — Satellites: orbital speed, period, energy and geostationary orbits

A satellite of mass M is in a circular orbit of radius R about the center of the earth. A meteorite of the same mass, falling towards the earth, collides with the satellite completely inelastic. The speeds of the satellite and the meteorite are the same, just before the collision. The subsequent motion of the combined body will be:

SOLUTION

Let the mass of the earth be denoted by MEM_E and the universal gravitational constant by GG. For a satellite of mass MM moving in a circular orbit of radius RR the velocity is obtained from the condition for uniform circular motion

G ME MR2=Mv2R    ⟹    v=G MER  .\displaystyle \frac{G\,M_E\,M}{R^2}= \frac{M v^2}{R}\;\;\Longrightarrow\;\;v=\sqrt{\frac{G\,M_E}{R}}\;.

The meteorite has the same mass MM and, just before impact, is given to have the same speed vv. At the instant of collision the two velocity directions are orthogonal: the satellite velocity is tangential while the meteorite velocity is radially inward. Hence the angle between v⃗ ⁣s\vec v_{\!s} (satellite) and v⃗ ⁣m\vec v_{\!m} (meteorite) is 90∘  .90^\circ\;.

The collision is perfectly inelastic, so the two bodies stick together to form a single body of mass 2M2M. Because external forces on the system are purely central (gravity through the earth’s centre), the angular momentum about the earth’s centre is conserved during the collision.

Initially, only the satellite possesses angular momentum because the meteorite is moving radially. Using L⃗=M  r⃗×v⃗\vec L=M\;\vec r\times\vec v with r=Rr=R we have

Li=M R v  .L_i = M\,R\,v\;.

After the collision the linear momenta add vectorially:

p⃗f=Mv⃗ ⁣s+Mv⃗ ⁣m=M(v⃗ ⁣s+v⃗ ⁣m).\vec p_f = M\vec v_{\!s}+M\vec v_{\!m} = M(\vec v_{\!s}+\vec v_{\!m}).

Since the two velocities are at right angles and equal in magnitude, their vector sum has magnitude

∣v⃗ ⁣s+v⃗ ⁣m∣=v2  .|\vec v_{\!s}+\vec v_{\!m}| = v\sqrt{2}\;.

The velocity of the fused body (mass 2M2M) is therefore

v⃗′=p⃗f2M=v⃗ ⁣s+v⃗ ⁣m2,∣v⃗′∣=v22=v2  .\vec v'=\frac{\vec p_f}{2M}= \frac{\vec v_{\!s}+\vec v_{\!m}}{2},\qquad |\vec v'|=\frac{v\sqrt{2}}{2}= \frac{v}{\sqrt2}\;.

Because v⃗′\vec v' bisects the right angle between the original velocities, it makes 45∘45^\circ with the tangent. Its tangential and radial components are each

vt=v2,vr=v2  .v_t=\frac{v}{2},\qquad v_r=\frac{v}{2}\;.

The conserved angular momentum after collision equals

Lf=2M R vt=2M R(v2)=M R v=Li  ,L_f = 2M\,R\,v_t = 2M\,R\left(\frac{v}{2}\right)=M\,R\,v=L_i\;,

so angular momentum conservation is satisfied.

The specific (per-unit-mass) angular momentum of the combined body is

h=Lf2M=R vt=R(v2)=R v2  .h=\frac{L_f}{2M}=R\,v_t = R\left(\frac{v}{2}\right)=\frac{R\,v}{2}\;.

Next we evaluate the specific mechanical energy ε=v′22−G MER  .\varepsilon=\dfrac{v'^2}{2}-\dfrac{G\,M_E}{R}\;. Using v′2=v22v'^2=\dfrac{v^2}{2} and v2=G MERv^2=\dfrac{G\,M_E}{R} we obtain

ε=12(v22)−v21=v24−v2=−3 v24  .\varepsilon=\frac{1}{2}\left(\frac{v^2}{2}\right)-\frac{v^2}{1}= \frac{v^2}{4}-v^2=-\frac{3\,v^2}{4}\;.

The energy is negative, indicating a bound orbit.

To decide whether the bound orbit is circular or elliptical we employ the standard formula for the eccentricity ee of a Keplerian orbit expressed in terms of specific energy ε\varepsilon and specific angular momentum hh :

e= 1+2εh2(G ME)2   .e=\sqrt{\,1+\frac{2\varepsilon h^{2}}{(G\,M_E)^{2}}\,}\;.

Because v2=G MERv^2=\dfrac{G\,M_E}{R} we write G ME=v2R  .G\,M_E = v^2 R\;. Now compute the term inside the square root:

2εh2(G ME)2=2(−3v24)(R2v24)(v2R)2=−3R2v4/8R2v4=−38  .\frac{2\varepsilon h^{2}}{(G\,M_E)^{2}} =\frac{2\left(-\dfrac{3v^{2}}{4}\right)\left(\dfrac{R^{2}v^{2}}{4}\right)}{(v^{2}R)^{2}} =\frac{-3R^{2}v^{4}/8}{R^{2}v^{4}} =-\frac{3}{8}\;.

Therefore

e2=1−38=58⟹e=58<1  .e^{2}=1-\frac{3}{8}=\frac{5}{8}\quad\Longrightarrow\quad e=\sqrt{\frac{5}{8}}<1\;.

An eccentricity less than unity but greater than zero corresponds to an ellipse that is not a circle. Thus the fused body of mass 2M2M moves in an elliptical orbit whose apogee is at the collision point (radius RR) and whose perigee lies closer to the earth.

Hence, the correct answer is Option A.

Tagged Satellites: orbital speed, period, energy and geostationary orbits. Machine-assigned, so read it as a strong shortlist rather than a verdict.

SubjectPhysics
TopicSatellites: orbital speed, period, energy and geostationary orbits
TypeMultiple choice