RankRizz
JEE MAIN 2015 · 10 APR ONLINE+4 / −1HARDTRANSCRIBED

JEE Main 2015 Physics question — Gravitational field and potential of rings, shells and spheres

A very long (length LL) cylindrical galaxy is made of uniformly distributed mass and has radius RR (R<<L)(R << L). A star outside the galaxy is orbiting the galaxy in a plane perpendicular to the galaxy and passing through its centre. If the time period of the star is TT and its distance from the galaxy's axis is rr, then

SOLUTION

Consider a very long cylindrical galaxy of length LL and radius RR (with R≪LR \ll L), with mass uniformly distributed. A star orbits the galaxy in a plane perpendicular to the galaxy's axis and passing through its center, at a distance rr from the axis (where r>Rr > R since the star is outside the galaxy). We need to find the relationship between the orbital time period TT and rr.

Due to the cylindrical symmetry and the condition R≪LR \ll L, we can approximate the galaxy as an infinitely long cylinder for gravitational effects at distances rr (where r≪Lr \ll L). The mass per unit length λ\lambda is constant and given by the total mass divided by LL. For an infinitely long cylinder, the gravitational field outside the cylinder depends only on λ\lambda.

Using Gauss's law for gravity, consider a cylindrical Gaussian surface of radius rr and length ll, coaxial with the galaxy. The mass enclosed by this surface is λl\lambda l. The gravitational flux through the curved surface is g⋅2πrlg \cdot 2\pi r l (since the field is radial and uniform), and through the ends is zero (as the field is parallel to the ends). Gauss's law states:

∫g⋅dA=−4πGMenc\int \mathbf{g} \cdot d\mathbf{A} = -4\pi G M_{\text{enc}}

Substituting the values:

g⋅2πrl=−4πG(λl)g \cdot 2\pi r l = -4\pi G (\lambda l)

Solving for the magnitude of the gravitational field gg (ignoring the negative sign for direction):

g=2Gλrg = \frac{2G\lambda}{r}

This gravitational force provides the centripetal force for the star's circular orbit. Let mm be the mass of the star and vv its orbital speed. The centripetal force is:

Fc=mv2rF_c = \frac{m v^2}{r}

The gravitational force is:

Fg=mg=m⋅2GλrF_g = m g = m \cdot \frac{2G\lambda}{r}

Setting Fg=FcF_g = F_c:

m⋅2Gλr=mv2rm \cdot \frac{2G\lambda}{r} = \frac{m v^2}{r}

Canceling mm and rr (assuming m≠0m \neq 0 and r≠0r \neq 0):

2Gλr=v2r\frac{2G\lambda}{r} = \frac{v^2}{r}

Multiplying both sides by rr:

2Gλ=v22G\lambda = v^2

Thus:

v2=2Gλv^2 = 2G\lambda

Since λ\lambda is constant for the galaxy, vv is constant and independent of rr.

The orbital period TT is the time for one complete orbit, which is the circumference divided by the speed:

T=2πrvT = \frac{2\pi r}{v}

As vv is constant, TT is proportional to rr:

T∝rT \propto r

Comparing with the options:

A. T∝rT \propto \sqrt{r}

B. T∝rT \propto r

C. T∝r2T \propto r^2

D. T2∝r3T^2 \propto r^3

Option B matches the derived relationship.

Hence, the correct answer is Option B.

Tagged Gravitational field and potential of rings, shells and spheres. Machine-assigned, so read it as a strong shortlist rather than a verdict.

SubjectPhysics
TopicGravitational field and potential of rings, shells and spheres
TypeMultiple choice