RankRizz
JEE MAIN 2014 · 06 APR OFFLINE+4 / −1EASYTRANSCRIBED

JEE Main 2014 Physics question — Vernier calipers: least count and zero error

A student measured the length of a rod and wrote it as 3.50 cm. Which instrument did he use to measure it?

SOLUTION

We begin by recalling that the number of digits written in a measurement tells us up to which place-value the observer was certain.

If a reading is written as 3.50 cm3.50\ \text{cm}, the last digit “0” is significant; hence the observer was sure up to 0.01 cm0.01\ \text{cm} (one-hundredth of a centimetre).

So, the measuring instrument used must have a least count (i.e. the smallest length it can resolve) of 0.01 cm0.01\ \text{cm}.

Now we examine the least count of each given instrument one by one.

Option A : Meter scale
A common meter scale is ruled millimetre by millimetre.

One main scale division =1 mm=0.1 cm=1\ \text{mm}=0.1\ \text{cm}.

Hence its least count =0.1 cm=0.1\ \text{cm}.

This is ten times coarser than 0.01 cm0.01\ \text{cm}, so a meter scale cannot justify writing “3.50 cm”.

Option B : Vernier calliper
We are told:

• Main scale has 10 divisions in 1 cm1\ \text{cm}, so

One MSD=1 cm10=0.1 cm\text{One MSD}= \frac{1\ \text{cm}}{10}=0.1\ \text{cm}.

• Ten vernier divisions coincide with nine main scale divisions, thus

10 VSD=9 MSD=9(0.1 cm)=0.9 cm,10\ \text{VSD}=9\ \text{MSD}=9(0.1\ \text{cm})=0.9\ \text{cm},

hence

One VSD=0.9 cm10=0.09 cm.\text{One VSD}= \frac{0.9\ \text{cm}}{10}=0.09\ \text{cm}.

The formula for least count of a vernier calliper is

Least count=1 MSD−1 VSD.\text{Least count} = 1\ \text{MSD} - 1\ \text{VSD}.

Substituting, we get

Least count=0.1 cm−0.09 cm=0.01 cm.\text{Least count}=0.1\ \text{cm}-0.09\ \text{cm}=0.01\ \text{cm}.

This exactly matches the required0.01 cm0.01\ \text{cm}, so such a vernier calliper can legitimately lead to the notation “3.50 cm”.

Option C : Screw gauge (100 divisions, pitch 1 mm1\ \text{mm})
First we convert the pitch:

1 mm=0.1 cm.1\ \text{mm}=0.1\ \text{cm}.

The formula for least count of a screw gauge is

Least count=PitchNumber of circular scale divisions.\text{Least count}= \frac{\text{Pitch}}{\text{Number of circular scale divisions}}.

Hence

Least count=0.1 cm100=0.001 cm  (10−3 cm).\text{Least count}= \frac{0.1\ \text{cm}}{100}=0.001\ \text{cm}\;(10^{-3}\ \text{cm}).

With such fine resolution the reading would normally be recorded to three decimal places, e.g. 3.500 cm3.500\ \text{cm}, not 3.50 cm3.50\ \text{cm}.

Option D : Screw gauge (50 divisions, pitch 1 mm1\ \text{mm})
Again converting the pitch gives 0.1 cm0.1\ \text{cm}.

Therefore

Least count=0.1 cm50=0.002 cm.\text{Least count}= \frac{0.1\ \text{cm}}{50}=0.002\ \text{cm}.

This device resolves to the third decimal place (about 2×10−3 cm2\times10^{-3}\ \text{cm}), so one would also write 3.502 cm3.502\ \text{cm}, 3.504 cm3.504\ \text{cm} etc., but not simply 3.50 cm3.50\ \text{cm}.

Comparing all four instruments, only the vernier calliper in Option B has the least count 0.01 cm0.01\ \text{cm} that agrees with the notation used by the student.

Hence, the correct answer is Option B.

Tagged Vernier calipers: least count and zero error. Machine-assigned, so read it as a strong shortlist rather than a verdict.

SubjectPhysics
TopicVernier calipers: least count and zero error
TypeMultiple choice