RankRizz
JEE MAIN 2019 · 09 JAN S1+4 / −1EASYTRANSCRIBED

JEE Main 2019 Physics question — Electric charge and Coulomb's law

Three charges +Q+Q, qq, +Q+Q are placed respectively, at distance, 00, d/2d/2 and dd from the origin, on the xx-axis. If the net force experienced by +Q+Q, placed at x=0x = 0, is zero, then value of qq is:

SOLUTION

We have three point charges placed on the xx-axis.

At x=0x = 0 is the charge +Q+Q, at x=d/2x = d/2 is the charge qq, and at x=dx = d is another charge +Q+Q. Our task is to adjust the value of qq so that the net electrostatic force acting on the charge +Q+Q at the origin becomes zero.

First, we recall Coulomb’s law. It states that the magnitude of the force between two point charges Q1Q_1 and Q2Q_2 separated by a distance rr is

F  =  k  ∣Q1Q2∣r2,F \;=\; k\;\dfrac{|Q_1Q_2|}{r^2},

where kk is Coulomb’s constant. The direction of the force is along the line joining the charges: like charges repel, unlike charges attract.

Now, we calculate the individual forces acting on the charge +Q+Q at the origin.

1. Force due to the charge qq at x=d/2x=d/2
The distance between +Q+Q at the origin and qq at x=d/2x=d/2 is d/2d/2.
Hence, the magnitude of that force is

Fq  =  k ∣Q q∣(d/2)2.F_{q} \;=\; k \,\dfrac{|Q\,q|}{(d/2)^2}.

We simplify the denominator:

(d/2)2=d24,\bigl(d/2\bigr)^2 = \dfrac{d^2}{4},

so

Fq=k ∣Q q∣d2/4=  4k ∣Q q∣d2.F_{q} = k \,\dfrac{|Q\,q|}{d^2/4} = \;4k \,\dfrac{|Q\,q|}{d^2}.

2. Force due to the charge +Q+Q at x=dx=d
The distance from the origin to this charge is dd, so the magnitude of the force is

FQ  =  k ∣Q Q∣d2=k Q2d2.F_{Q} \;=\; k \,\dfrac{|Q\,Q|}{d^2} = k \,\dfrac{Q^2}{d^2}.

Next, we assign directions. The two charges located at x>dx>d lie to the right of the origin.

  • The charge at x=dx=d is +Q+Q. Since the charge at the origin is also +Q+Q, the force between them is repulsive, pushing the origin charge toward the left (negative xx-direction).
  • For the charge qq at x=d/2x=d/2, the direction depends on the sign of qq. • If qq were positive, it would also repel +Q+Q at the origin, producing another leftward force. • To balance the leftward force from the charge at x=dx=d, we require a rightward force. That rightward pull can only arise if qq is negative, because unlike charges attract. Therefore, qq must indeed be negative.

Let us therefore write q=− ∣q∣q = -\,|q|, emphasising its negative sign, but keep ∣q∣|q| for its magnitude.

The rightward attractive force (toward the positive xx-direction) on the origin charge is then

Fq=4k Q ∣q∣d2.F_{q} = 4k \,\dfrac{Q\,|q|}{d^2}.

The leftward repulsive force (toward the negative xx-direction) is

FQ=k Q2d2.F_{Q} = k \,\dfrac{Q^2}{d^2}.

For the net force on the origin charge to be zero, these two forces must be equal in magnitude but opposite in direction. Hence we set

Fq=FQ.F_{q} = F_{Q}.

Substituting the expressions we have just obtained,

4k Q ∣q∣d2  =  k Q2d2.4k \,\dfrac{Q\,|q|}{d^2} \;=\; k \,\dfrac{Q^2}{d^2}.

We notice that the factor k/d2k/d^2 appears on both sides, so we can divide both sides by k/d2k/d^2 to simplify:

4Q ∣q∣  =  Q2.4Q\,|q| \;=\; Q^2.

Now we solve for ∣q∣|q|. Dividing both sides by 4Q4Q gives

∣q∣  =  Q4.|q| \;=\; \dfrac{Q}{4}.

But we have already established that qq must be negative. Therefore,

q  =  − Q4.q \;=\; -\,\dfrac{Q}{4}.

So the required charge qq is negative one-quarter of QQ.

Hence, the correct answer is Option C.

Tagged Electric charge and Coulomb's law. Machine-assigned, so read it as a strong shortlist rather than a verdict.

SubjectPhysics
TopicElectric charge and Coulomb's law
TypeMultiple choice