RankRizz
JEE MAIN 2019 · 09 APR S2+4 / −1MEDIUMTRANSCRIBED

JEE Main 2019 Physics question — Electric field of continuous charge distributions

Four point charges -q, +q, +q and -q are placed on y-axis at y = -2d, y = -d, and y = +2d, respectively. The magnitude of the electric field E at a point on the x-axis at x = D, with D >> d, will behave as:

SOLUTION

We have four point charges placed on the y-axis. Their positions and values are

q1=−q  at  (0,−2d),q2=+q  at  (0,−d),q3=+q  at  (0,+d),q4=−q  at  (0,+2d).q_1=-q\;{\rm at}\;(0,-2d),\qquad q_2=+q\;{\rm at}\;(0,-d),\qquad q_3=+q\;{\rm at}\;(0,+d),\qquad q_4=-q\;{\rm at}\;(0,+2d).

The point at which we want the electric field is P(D,0) ,P(D,0)\,, i.e. a point on the x-axis with x=Dx=D and y=0y=0, where D≫d.D\gg d.

For any point charge qiq_i located at (0,yi)(0,y_i) the position vector from the charge to PP is

r⃗i=(D i^+(0−yi) j^)=D i^−yi j^.\vec r_i=\bigl(D\,\hat i+(0-y_i)\,\hat j\bigr)=D\,\hat i-y_i\,\hat j.

The distance of the point from the charge is therefore

ri=D 2+yi 2.r_i=\sqrt{D^{\,2}+y_i^{\,2}}.

Statement of the formula: The electric field due to a point charge is

E⃗i=k qiri 2  r^i=k qiri 3  r⃗i,\vec E_i=\dfrac{k\,q_i}{r_i^{\,2}}\;\hat r_i =\dfrac{k\,q_i}{r_i^{\,3}}\;\vec r_i, where k=14πε0k=\dfrac{1}{4\pi\varepsilon_0} and r^i=r⃗iri.\hat r_i=\dfrac{\vec r_i}{r_i}.

Substituting r⃗i\vec r_i we get the two Cartesian components for every charge:

Eix=k qiD(D 2+yi 2)3/2,Eiy=k qi(−yi)(D 2+yi 2)3/2.E_{ix}= \dfrac{k\,q_i D}{\bigl(D^{\,2}+y_i^{\,2}\bigr)^{3/2}},\qquad E_{iy}= \dfrac{k\,q_i(-y_i)}{\bigl(D^{\,2}+y_i^{\,2}\bigr)^{3/2}}.

Now we first check the yy-components. The charges at y=+dy=+d and y=−dy=-d have the same sign +q+q but opposite yiy_i, so their EiyE_{iy} cancel. In the same way the charges at y=+2dy=+2d and y=−2dy=-2d have the same sign −q-q and again opposite yiy_i, so those EiyE_{iy} also cancel. Hence,

∑i=14Eiy=0,\sum_{i=1}^{4}E_{iy}=0, and the total electric field at PP is purely along the x-direction.

Therefore the magnitude of the net field equals the sum of the x-components:

E=∑i=14Eix=kD∑i=14qi(D 2+yi 2)3/2.E=\sum_{i=1}^{4}E_{ix}=kD\sum_{i=1}^{4} \dfrac{q_i}{\bigl(D^{\,2}+y_i^{\,2}\bigr)^{3/2}}.

Because D≫d,D\gg d, we expand each denominator with the binomial series. We start from

(D 2+yi 2)−3/2=D−3(1+yi 2D 2)−3/2.\bigl(D^{\,2}+y_i^{\,2}\bigr)^{-3/2}=D^{-3}\Bigl(1+\dfrac{y_i^{\,2}}{D^{\,2}}\Bigr)^{-3/2}. Using (1+s)−3/2=1−32s+158s2−…,(1+s)^{-3/2}=1-\dfrac{3}{2}s+\dfrac{15}{8}s^{2}-\ldots, we substitute s=yi 2D 2s=\dfrac{y_i^{\,2}}{D^{\,2}} to obtain

(D 2+yi 2)−3/2=D−3[1−32yi 2D 2+158yi 4D 4−…].\bigl(D^{\,2}+y_i^{\,2}\bigr)^{-3/2}=D^{-3}\Bigl[1-\dfrac{3}{2}\dfrac{y_i^{\,2}}{D^{\,2}} +\dfrac{15}{8}\dfrac{y_i^{\,4}}{D^{\,4}}-\ldots\Bigr].

Substituting this expansion back into the expression for EE gives

E=kD∑i=14qiD−3[1−32yi 2D 2+158yi 4D 4−…].E=kD\sum_{i=1}^{4}q_i D^{-3}\Bigl[1-\dfrac{3}{2}\dfrac{y_i^{\,2}}{D^{\,2}} +\dfrac{15}{8}\dfrac{y_i^{\,4}}{D^{\,4}}-\ldots\Bigr].

Simplifying the common factor DD with D−3D^{-3} we have

E=k∑i=14qi[D−2−32yi 2D 4+158yi 4D 6−…].E=k\sum_{i=1}^{4}q_i \Bigl[D^{-2}-\dfrac{3}{2}\dfrac{y_i^{\,2}}{D^{\,4}} +\dfrac{15}{8}\dfrac{y_i^{\,4}}{D^{\,6}}-\ldots\Bigr].

We now evaluate the sums term by term.

1. The monopole term (total charge):

∑i=14qi=(−q)+(+q)+(+q)+(−q)=0.\sum_{i=1}^{4}q_i=(-q)+(+q)+(+q)+(-q)=0. So the entire D−2D^{-2} contribution vanishes.

2. The next (quadrupole) term involves ∑qiyi 2 ⁣:\sum q_i y_i^{\,2}\!:

∑i=14qiyi 2=(−q)(4d2)+(+q)(d2)+(+q)(d2)+(−q)(4d2)=−4qd2+qd2+qd2−4qd2=−6qd2    (≠0).\begin{aligned} \sum_{i=1}^{4}q_i y_i^{\,2}&=(-q)(4d^{2})+(+q)(d^{2})+(+q)(d^{2})+(-q)(4d^{2})\\ &=-4qd^{2}+qd^{2}+qd^{2}-4qd^{2}\\ &=-6qd^{2}\;\;(\neq0). \end{aligned}

Hence the first non-vanishing contribution to EE is

E=−32k(∑qiyi 2)D−4+higher-order terms.E=-\dfrac{3}{2}k\bigl(\sum q_i y_i^{\,2}\bigr)D^{-4} +\text{higher-order terms}. Since ∑qiyi 2\sum q_i y_i^{\,2} is merely a constant factor, this clearly shows

E∝1D4.E\propto\dfrac{1}{D^{4}}.

All still-higher terms vary as 1/D6, 1/D8,…1/D^{6},\,1/D^{8},\ldots and are even smaller when D≫d.D\gg d. Thus the leading behaviour of the electric field magnitude is

E  ∼  constantD4.E\;{\Large\sim}\;\dfrac{\text{constant}}{D^{4}}.

Hence, the correct answer is Option A.

Tagged Electric field of continuous charge distributions. Machine-assigned, so read it as a strong shortlist rather than a verdict.

SubjectPhysics
TopicElectric field of continuous charge distributions
TypeMultiple choice