JEE Main 2019 Physics question — Electric field of continuous charge distributions
Four point charges -q, +q, +q and -q are placed on y-axis at y = -2d, y = -d, and y = +2d, respectively. The magnitude of the electric field E at a point on the x-axis at x = D, with D >> d, will behave as:
SOLUTION
We have four point charges placed on the y-axis. Their positions and values are
Now we first check the y-components. The charges at y=+d and y=−d have the same sign +q but opposite yi, so their Eiy cancel. In the same way the charges at y=+2d and y=−2d have the same sign −q and again opposite yi, so those Eiy also cancel. Hence,
∑i=14Eiy=0,
and the total electric field at P is purely along the x-direction.
Therefore the magnitude of the net field equals the sum of the x-components:
E=∑i=14Eix=kD∑i=14(D2+yi2)3/2qi.
Because D≫d, we expand each denominator with the binomial series. We start from
(D2+yi2)−3/2=D−3(1+D2yi2)−3/2.
Using (1+s)−3/2=1−23s+815s2−…, we substitute s=D2yi2 to obtain
(D2+yi2)−3/2=D−3[1−23D2yi2+815D4yi4−…].
Substituting this expansion back into the expression for E gives
E=kD∑i=14qiD−3[1−23D2yi2+815D4yi4−…].
Simplifying the common factor D with D−3 we have
E=k∑i=14qi[D−2−23D4yi2+815D6yi4−…].
We now evaluate the sums term by term.
1. The monopole term (total charge):
∑i=14qi=(−q)+(+q)+(+q)+(−q)=0.
So the entire D−2 contribution vanishes.