Consider the force F on a charge 'q' due to a uniformly charged spherical shell of radius R carrying charge Q distributed uniformly over it. Which one of the following statements is true for F, if 'q' is placed at distance r from the centre of the shell?
We start with Gauss’s law in integral form, stated as
A uniformly charged thin spherical shell of radius carries a total charge spread evenly over its surface. We place the test charge at a distance from the centre of the shell and look for the electrostatic force acting on it.
Because the shell is spherically symmetric, the electric field at any point depends only on the distance from the centre. We therefore choose a concentric spherical Gaussian surface of radius . On this Gaussian surface, the magnitude of the field is the same everywhere and is directed radially. The area element is also radial, so the dot-product simplifies to . The closed-surface integral then becomes
Now we distinguish the two possible locations of the test charge.
Case 1: (inside the shell)
For a point strictly inside the shell, the Gaussian surface of radius encloses no charge, because all the charge resides on the shell’s surface, which lies outside our Gaussian sphere. Therefore
Substituting into Gauss’s law gives
so
The force on the charge is obtained from . Because the field magnitude is zero, we have
Case 2: (outside the shell)
When the Gaussian surface lies completely outside the shell, it encloses the entire charge . Thus
Gauss’s law now gives
so
The corresponding force on the test charge is
Summarising the results:
We now compare these findings with each option:
Option A asserts a non-zero constant force for , but we have just shown that the force is zero inside, so Option A is false.
Option B claims for . Since the true value of inside is exactly zero, the inequality is violated; hence Option B is also false.
Option C states for , which matches the expression we derived. Therefore, Option C is correct.
Option D maintains the same expression for all values of , but we know it fails for , so Option D is incorrect.
Hence, the correct answer is Option C.
Tagged Electric field due to point charges and superposition. Machine-assigned, so read it as a strong shortlist rather than a verdict.