JEE MAIN 2015 · 04 APR OFFLINE+4 / −1MEDIUMTRANSCRIBED
JEE Main 2015 Physics question — Electric potential and potential energy
A uniformly charged solid sphere of radius R has potential V0 (measured with respect to ∞) on its surface. For this sphere the equipotential surfaces with potential 23V0, 45V0, 43V0 and 4V0 have radius R1, R2, R3 and R4 respectively. Then Note: This question had two options correct at the time of examination. Proper corrections are made in the question to avoid it.
SOLUTION
For a uniformly charged solid sphere whose total charge is Q and radius is R, the electro-static potential at any point is obtained from the well-known results of electrostatics. We first state these results.
• At an external point, that is for r≥R, the sphere behaves like a point charge at its centre, so
Vout(r)=4πε01rQ.
• At an internal point, that is for r≤R, the potential is
Vin(r)=4πε012R3Q(3R2−r2).
On the surface r=R these two expressions must give the same value, which is the given surface potential V0. Putting r=R in either formula we get
V0=4πε01RQ.
For convenience we now write every subsequent potential in terms of V0.
1. Potential inside the sphere
Substituting 4πε0Q=V0R in the internal formula gives
Vin(r)=2R3V0R(3R2−r2)=V0[23−2R2r2].
2. Potential outside the sphere
Similarly, substituting in the external formula yields
Vout(r)=V0rR.
We now locate the radii of the four equipotential surfaces mentioned in the problem.
(a) Surface with potential 23V0
This value of potential exceeds V0, so the point must lie inside the sphere. We therefore equate it to the internal potential:
V0[23−2R2r2]=23V0.
Cancelling V0 from both sides,
23−2R2r2=23⟹−2R2r2=0⟹r2=0⟹r=0.
Hence R1=0.
This is only a single point—the centre of the sphere.
(b) Surface with potential 45V0
Again this value is larger than V0, so we use the internal expression:
V0[23−2R2r2]=45V0.
Dividing by V0 and rewriting the left side with a common denominator 4,
46−2R2r2=45.
Taking the difference,
46−45=2R2r2⟹41=2R2r2.
Multiplying both sides by 2R2,
r2=2R2⟹r=2R.
Thus R2=2R(≈0.707R).
(c) Surface with potential 43V0
Now the potential is belowV0, so we are outside the sphere. Using the external formula,
V0rR=43V0.
Eliminating V0 gives
rR=43⟹r=34R.
Hence R3=34R(≈1.333R).
(d) Surface with potential 4V0
Again we are outside, so
V0rR=4V0⟹rR=41⟹r=4R.
Thus R4=4R.
We have obtained
R1=0,R2=2R,R3=34R,R4=4R.
Let us now examine each option.
Option A states 2R>R4. Substituting R4=4R gives 2R>4R, which is clearly false.
Option B asserts two points: R1=0 (true) and R2>(R4−R3).
Compute R4−R3=4R−34R=312R−4R=38R(≈2.667R).
But R2=2R(≈0.707R).
Since 0.707R>2.667R is false, the whole option is false.
Option C says R1=0 (false, we have R1=0), so the option is already ruled out.
Option D combines R1=0 (true) with R2<(R4−R3).
We have R2≈0.707R and R4−R3≈2.667R, so indeed 0.707R<2.667R.
Both parts are satisfied, therefore Option D is correct.
Hence, the correct answer is Option D.
Tagged Electric potential and potential energy. Machine-assigned, so read it as a strong shortlist rather than a verdict.