RankRizz
JEE MAIN 2011TRANSCRIBED

JEE Main 2011 Physics question — Electric charge and Coulomb's law

Two identical charged spheres suspended from a common point by two massless strings of length ll are initially a distance d (d≪l)d \, (d \ll l) apart because of their mutual repulsion. The charge begins to leak from both the spheres at a constant rate. As a result the charges approach each other with a velocity vv. Then as a function of distance xx between them,

SOLUTION

Let each sphere have mass mm and (instantaneous) charge qq. The two light strings of equal length ll make an angle θ\theta with the vertical when the spheres are separated by a horizontal distance xx. Because d≪ld\ll l, the angles are small and the system can be treated as quasistatic (the spheres readjust their positions continuously as the charge leaks).

Force balance at any instant
For one sphere, the horizontal component of the string tension balances the electrostatic repulsion while the vertical component balances the weight:
Tsin⁡θ=k q2x2,Tcos⁡θ=mgT\sin\theta = \frac{k\,q^{2}}{x^{2}}, \qquad T\cos\theta = mg
Dividing the two equations gives
tan⁡θ=k q2mg x2  −(1)\tan\theta = \frac{k\,q^{2}}{mg\,x^{2}} \; -(1)

Small-angle geometry
With both strings making the same angle, the separation is x=2lsin⁡θ≈2lθx = 2l\sin\theta \approx 2l\theta, so θ≈x2l\theta \approx \dfrac{x}{2l}. For small angles tan⁡θ≈θ\tan\theta \approx \theta, hence from (1)

x2l=k q2mg x2    ⟹    q2=mg2lk x3\frac{x}{2l} = \frac{k\,q^{2}}{mg\,x^{2}} \;\;\Longrightarrow\;\; q^{2} = \frac{mg}{2lk}\,x^{3}

Therefore q=C x3/2,whereC=mg2lk=constantq = C\,x^{3/2}, \quad\text{where}\quad C = \sqrt{\frac{mg}{2lk}} = \text{constant}

Relating leak rate to approach speed
Charge leaks at a constant rate, so dqdt=−λ\dfrac{dq}{dt} = -\lambda with λ\lambda positive and constant.
Differentiate q=Cx3/2q = Cx^{3/2} with respect to time:

dqdt=32 C x1/2 dxdt\frac{dq}{dt} = \frac{3}{2}\,C\,x^{1/2}\,\frac{dx}{dt}

The spheres are approaching, so we deal with the magnitude of velocity v=∣dxdt∣v = \left|\dfrac{dx}{dt}\right|. Using ∣dqdt∣=λ\left|\dfrac{dq}{dt}\right| = \lambda:

λ=32 C x1/2 v    ⟹    v=2λ3C x−1/2\lambda = \frac{3}{2}\,C\,x^{1/2}\,v \;\;\Longrightarrow\;\; v = \frac{2\lambda}{3C}\,x^{-1/2}

Thus the speed varies inversely with the square root of the instantaneous separation:

v∝x−1/2v \propto x^{-1/2}

Hence, the correct choice is Option D.

Tagged Electric charge and Coulomb's law. Machine-assigned, so read it as a strong shortlist rather than a verdict.

SubjectPhysics
TopicElectric charge and Coulomb's law
TypeMultiple choice