RankRizz
JEE MAIN 2009TRANSCRIBED

JEE Main 2009 Physics question — Electric charge and Coulomb's law

A charge QQ is placed at each of the opposite corners of a square. A charge qq is placed at each of the other two corners. If the net electrical force on QQ is zero, then the Q/qQ/q equals

SOLUTION

Consider a square of side aa. Label the corners in order as A(0,0),  B(a,0),  C(a,a),  D(0,a)A(0,0),\;B(a,0),\;C(a,a),\;D(0,a).

Charges placed:
  • QQ at the opposite corners AA and CC.
  • qq at the remaining corners BB and DD.

We need the net electrostatic force on the charge QQ at corner AA to be zero.

Forces on QQ at AA

1. Force due to the other QQ at CC (diagonal corner)
  Distance AC=a2AC = a\sqrt{2}.
  Magnitude FAC=kQ2(a2) 2=kQ22a2F_{AC} = k\dfrac{Q^2}{(a\sqrt{2})^{\,2}} = \dfrac{kQ^2}{2a^{2}}.
  Direction: from AA towards CC makes 45∘45^{\circ} with both axes; because both charges QQ are alike, the force on AA is repulsive, i.e. along −i^−j^-\hat i-\hat j.
  Components: FAC,x=FAC,y=−kQ22a212=−kQ222 a2F_{AC,x} = F_{AC,y} = -\dfrac{kQ^2}{2a^{2}}\dfrac{1}{\sqrt{2}} = -\dfrac{kQ^2}{2\sqrt{2}\,a^{2}}.

2. Force due to qq at B(a,0)B(a,0) (adjacent corner on the x-axis)
  Distance AB=aAB = a.
  Magnitude FAB=k∣Qq∣a2F_{AB} = k\dfrac{|Qq|}{a^{2}}.
  Direction: along the x-axis. Writing the x-component with sign included,
FAB,x=−kQqa2F_{AB,x}= -\dfrac{kQq}{a^{2}} (positive if qq is opposite in sign to QQ, negative if same sign).

3. Force due to qq at D(0,a)D(0,a) (adjacent corner on the y-axis) is analogous:
  FAD,y=−kQqa2F_{AD,y}= -\dfrac{kQq}{a^{2}}.

Setting the net force to zero

Total x-component:
Fx=FAB,x+FAC,x=−kQqa2−kQ222 a2=0F_x = F_{AB,x} + F_{AC,x}= -\dfrac{kQq}{a^{2}}-\dfrac{kQ^2}{2\sqrt{2}\,a^{2}}=0.

Total y-component gives the same equation, so one condition suffices:

−kQqa2−kQ222 a2=0-\dfrac{kQq}{a^{2}}-\dfrac{kQ^2}{2\sqrt{2}\,a^{2}}=0

Cancel the common factor ka2\dfrac{k}{a^{2}}:

−Qq−Q222=0-Qq-\dfrac{Q^{2}}{2\sqrt{2}}=0

Qq=−Q222Qq = -\dfrac{Q^{2}}{2\sqrt{2}}

Divide by Q  (Q≠0)Q\;(Q\neq0):

q=−Q22q = -\dfrac{Q}{2\sqrt{2}}

Hence

Qq=−22\dfrac{Q}{q}= -2\sqrt{2}

which matches Option A.

Therefore, the required ratio is:
Option A which is: −22-2\sqrt{2}

Tagged Electric charge and Coulomb's law. Machine-assigned, so read it as a strong shortlist rather than a verdict.

SubjectPhysics
TopicElectric charge and Coulomb's law
TypeMultiple choice