RankRizz
JEE MAIN 2007TRANSCRIBED

JEE Main 2007 Physics question — Electric charge and Coulomb's law

If gEg_E and gmg_m are the accelerations due to gravity on the surfaces of the earth and the moon respectively and if Millikan's oil drop experiment could be performed on the two surfaces, one will find the ratio electronic charge on the moonelectronic charge on the earth\frac{\text{electronic charge on the moon}}{\text{electronic charge on the earth}} to be

SOLUTION

In Millikan’s oil-drop experiment the charge qq on a floating drop is obtained by balancing the gravitational force on the drop with the electric force exerted by a uniform electric field.

Gravitational force on the drop: Fg=mgF_g = mg where mm is the mass of the drop and gg is the local acceleration due to gravity.

Electric force on the drop: FE=qEF_E = qE where EE is the applied uniform electric field.

At equilibrium, Fg=FEF_g = F_E, so

qE=mg⇒q=mgE(-1)qE = mg \quad\Rightarrow\quad q = \frac{mg}{E} \tag{-1}

When the experiment is shifted from Earth to Moon:

• The charge qq obtained from (1)(1) might seem to depend on the local gg, but the mass mm of the drop is never measured through its weight. Instead, mm is calculated from the radius rr, the density ρ\rho of the oil, and the buoyant correction: m=43πr3ρm = \frac{4}{3}\pi r^{3}\rho - a purely mechanical expression that involves no factor of gg.

Because the same oil, the same radius-measuring method, and the same density are used on both Earth and Moon, the numerator mgmg in (1)(1) changes to

mgmon Moon,mgEon Earth.m g_m \quad\text{on Moon}, \qquad m g_E \quad\text{on Earth}.

The applied electric field EE is adjusted separately in each location until equilibrium is reached, so the ratio of charges measured becomes

qMoonqEarth  =  mgm/EMoonmgE/EEarth=gmgE EEarthEMoon.\frac{q_{\text{Moon}}}{q_{\text{Earth}}} \;=\; \frac{m g_m / E_{\text{Moon}}}{m g_E / E_{\text{Earth}}} = \frac{g_m}{g_E}\,\frac{E_{\text{Earth}}}{E_{\text{Moon}}}.

But in either case the experimenter tunes the field exactly so that qq comes out to an integer multiple of the fundamental electronic charge ee. Since ee is a universal constant, the same integer multiple must be obtained at both places. Therefore the ratio above must equal unity:

qMoonqEarth=1.\frac{q_{\text{Moon}}}{q_{\text{Earth}}} = 1.

Hence the electronic charge measured on the Moon is the same as that measured on the Earth.

Option A which is: 1

Tagged Electric charge and Coulomb's law. Machine-assigned, so read it as a strong shortlist rather than a verdict.

SubjectPhysics
TopicElectric charge and Coulomb's law
TypeMultiple choice