RankRizz
JEE MAIN 2007TRANSCRIBED

JEE Main 2007 Physics question — Electric field due to point charges and superposition

Charges are placed on the vertices of a square as shown. Let E⃗\vec{E} be the electric field and VV the potential at the centre. If the charges on AA and BB are interchanged with those on DD and CC respectively, thenFigure for JEE Main 2007 Physics question on Electric field due to point charges and superposition

SOLUTION

Let the centre of the square be OO and the side of the square be aa. Choose Cartesian axes through OO so that the four vertices have co-ordinates

A (+a/2,+a/2),  B (−a/2,+a/2),  C (−a/2,−a/2),  D (+a/2,−a/2).A\,(+a/2,+a/2),\;B\,(-a/2,+a/2),\;C\,(-a/2,-a/2),\;D\,(+a/2,-a/2).

The distance of every vertex from the centre is the same,

r=a2.r = \frac{a}{\sqrt{2}}. Hence all four charges are equidistant from OO.

Denote the initial charges by qA,  qB,  qC,  qDq_A,\;q_B,\;q_C,\;q_D placed at A,B,C,DA,B,C,D respectively.

Potential at the centre (before interchange)
Using the superposition principle, the electric potential at a point is the algebraic sum of the potentials due to individual charges because potential is a scalar. Therefore

Vold  =  k qA+qB+qC+qDr,V_{\text{old}} \;=\; k\,\frac{q_A + q_B + q_C + q_D}{r}, where k=14πε0.k = \tfrac{1}{4\pi\varepsilon_0}.

Electric field at the centre (before interchange)
For any vertex the magnitude of the field at OO is

Ei=k ∣qi∣r2=k 2 qia2,E_i = k\,\frac{|q_i|}{r^2} = k\,\frac{2\,q_i}{a^{2}},

and its direction is along the line joining that vertex to the centre (outward for a positive charge, inward for a negative one). Writing the four position vectors from OO to the vertices,

r⃗A=a2 (i^+j^),  r⃗B=a2 (−i^+j^),  r⃗C=a2 (−i^−j^),  r⃗D=a2 (i^−j^),\vec{r}_A = \tfrac{a}{2}\,(\hat{i}+\hat{j}),\; \vec{r}_B = \tfrac{a}{2}\,(-\hat{i}+\hat{j}),\; \vec{r}_C = \tfrac{a}{2}\,(-\hat{i}-\hat{j}),\; \vec{r}_D = \tfrac{a}{2}\,(\hat{i}-\hat{j}),

the electric field at OO is

E⃗old  =  k 2a2 (qA r^A+qB r^B+qC r^C+qD r^D),\vec{E}_{\text{old}} \;=\; k\,\frac{2}{a^{2}}\, \Bigl(q_A\,\hat{r}_A + q_B\,\hat{r}_B + q_C\,\hat{r}_C + q_D\,\hat{r}_D\Bigr), where each r^i\hat{r}_i is the unit vector along r⃗i\vec{r}_i.

Interchange of charges
The question says: “charges on AA and BB are interchanged with those on DD and CC respectively.” In symbols this means

qA⟷qD,qB⟷qC.q_A \longleftrightarrow q_D,\qquad q_B \longleftrightarrow q_C.

After interchange, the charges occupying the vertices become

A:D,  B:C,  C:B,  D:A.A:D,\; B:C,\; C:B,\; D:A.

Potential after interchange
Because the distance rr is unchanged and the potential is a scalar sum, the new potential is

Vnew=k qD+qC+qB+qAr=k qA+qB+qC+qDr=Vold.V_{\text{new}} = k\,\frac{q_D + q_C + q_B + q_A}{r} = k\,\frac{q_A + q_B + q_C + q_D}{r} = V_{\text{old}}.

Hence the electric potential at the centre does not change.

Electric field after interchange
The magnitudes are the same as before, but the charges now multiply different direction vectors:

E⃗new=k 2a2 (qD r^A+qC r^B+qB r^C+qA r^D).\vec{E}_{\text{new}} = k\,\frac{2}{a^{2}}\, \Bigl(q_D\,\hat{r}_A + q_C\,\hat{r}_B + q_B\,\hat{r}_C + q_A\,\hat{r}_D\Bigr).

In general E⃗new≠E⃗old\vec{E}_{\text{new}}\neq\vec{E}_{\text{old}} unless the pairs qA=qDq_A=q_D and qB=qCq_B=q_C already happened to be equal. Therefore the electric field changes.

Conclusion
The interchange leaves the potential unchanged but alters the electric field.

Option D which is: E⃗\vec{E} changes, VV remains unchanged.

Tagged Electric field due to point charges and superposition. Machine-assigned, so read it as a strong shortlist rather than a verdict.

SubjectPhysics
TopicElectric field due to point charges and superposition
TypeMultiple choice