RankRizz
JEE MAIN 2017 · 02 APR OFFLINE+4 / −1MEDIUMTRANSCRIBED

JEE Main 2017 Physics question — Electric dipole and dipole in external field

An electric dipole has fixed dipole moment p⃗\vec{p}, which makes angle θ\theta with respect to xx-axis. When subjected to an electric field E⃗1=Ei^\vec{E}_{1} = E\hat{i}, it experiences a torque T⃗1=τk^\vec{T}_{1} = \tau\hat{k}. When subjected to another electric field E⃗2=3E1j^\vec{E}_{2} = \sqrt{3}E_{1}\hat{j}, it experiences a torque T⃗2=−T⃗1\vec{T}_{2} = -\vec{T}_{1}. The angle θ\theta is:

SOLUTION

We recall the vector relation for the torque experienced by an electric dipole in a uniform electric field. The formula is stated first:

τ⃗  =  p⃗  ×  E⃗\vec{\tau} \;=\; \vec{p}\;\times\;\vec{E}

Here p⃗\vec{p} is the dipole moment and E⃗\vec{E} is the electric field. The dipole moment is fixed in the xy-plane and makes an angle θ\theta with the positive xx-axis, so we may write it component-wise as

p⃗=p(cos⁡θ i^+sin⁡θ j^).\vec{p}=p\bigl(\cos\theta\,\hat{i}+\sin\theta\,\hat{j}\bigr).

Now the first electric field is purely along the xx-axis:

E⃗1=E i^.\vec{E}_{1}=E\,\hat{i}.

Using the cross-product formula, the torque produced by E⃗1\vec{E}_{1} is

τ⃗1=p⃗×E⃗1=p(cos⁡θ i^+sin⁡θ j^)×(E i^).\vec{\tau}_{1}= \vec{p}\times\vec{E}_{1} = p(\cos\theta\,\hat{i}+\sin\theta\,\hat{j})\times (E\,\hat{i}).

Because i^×i^=0\hat{i}\times\hat{i}=0 and j^×i^=−k^,\hat{j}\times\hat{i}=-\hat{k}, only the second term survives:

τ⃗1=pEsin⁡θ  (−k^)=− pEsin⁡θ k^.\vec{\tau}_{1}=pE\sin\theta\;(-\hat{k}) = -\,pE\sin\theta\,\hat{k}.

The question tells us that for this same field the torque vector is T⃗1=+τ k^.\vec{T}_{1}=+\tau\,\hat{k}. Thus the magnitude is clearly

τ1=pEsin⁡θ.\tau_{1}=pE\sin\theta.

Next, consider the second electric field, which points along the positive yy-axis and is 3\sqrt{3} times stronger than E⃗1\vec{E}_{1} in magnitude:

E⃗2=3 E j^.\vec{E}_{2}=\sqrt{3}\,E\,\hat{j}.

The torque produced by this field is obtained in the same way:

τ⃗2=p⃗×E⃗2=p(cos⁡θ i^+sin⁡θ j^)×(3 E j^).\vec{\tau}_{2}= \vec{p}\times\vec{E}_{2} = p(\cos\theta\,\hat{i}+\sin\theta\,\hat{j})\times(\sqrt{3}\,E\,\hat{j}).

Here j^×j^=0\hat{j}\times\hat{j}=0 and i^×j^=+k^,\hat{i}\times\hat{j}=+\hat{k}, giving

τ⃗2=p3Ecos⁡θ k^.\vec{\tau}_{2}=p\sqrt{3}E\cos\theta\,\hat{k}.

Therefore the magnitude of the second torque is

τ2=p3Ecos⁡θ.\tau_{2}=p\sqrt{3}E\cos\theta.

The statement in the problem is that the second torque is the negative of the first:

T⃗2=− T⃗1.\vec{T}_{2}=-\,\vec{T}_{1}.

This implies that their magnitudes are equal while their directions are opposite, so we set

τ2=τ1.\tau_{2}=\tau_{1}.

Substituting the expressions just obtained, we have

p3Ecos⁡θ  =  pEsin⁡θ.p\sqrt{3}E\cos\theta \;=\; pE\sin\theta.

The factors pp and EE cancel immediately, leaving

3cos⁡θ=sin⁡θ.\sqrt{3}\cos\theta=\sin\theta.

Dividing both sides by cos⁡θ\cos\theta (which is non-zero for the angles listed) gives the tangent:

tan⁡θ=3.\tan\theta=\sqrt{3}.

The standard value that satisfies this equation in the interval 0∘≤θ≤90∘0^{\circ}\le\theta\le 90^{\circ} is

θ=60∘.\theta=60^{\circ}.

Hence, the correct answer is Option D.

Tagged Electric dipole and dipole in external field. Machine-assigned, so read it as a strong shortlist rather than a verdict.

SubjectPhysics
TopicElectric dipole and dipole in external field
TypeMultiple choice