RankRizz
JEE MAIN 2020 · 09 JAN S2+4 / −1MEDIUMTRANSCRIBED

JEE Main 2020 Physics question — Properties of EM waves: fields, energy, intensity and momentum

A plane electromagnetic wave is propagating along the direction i^+j^2\frac{\hat{i}+\hat{j}}{\sqrt{2}}, with its polarization along the direction k^\hat{k}. The correct form of the magnetic field of the wave would be (here B0B_0 is an appropriate constant):

SOLUTION

For a monochromatic plane electromagnetic wave in free space we usually write the electric and magnetic fields in the form

E⃗=E⃗0cos⁡(ωt−k⃗⋅r⃗),B⃗=B⃗0cos⁡(ωt−k⃗⋅r⃗).\vec E = \vec E_0 \cos(\omega t - \vec k \cdot \vec r), \qquad \vec B = \vec B_0 \cos(\omega t - \vec k \cdot \vec r).

The three vectors k⃗,  E⃗,  B⃗\vec k,\; \vec E,\; \vec B must satisfy two vector relations that follow directly from Maxwell’s equations:

1. All three are mutually perpendicular, so k⃗⋅E⃗=0\vec k \cdot \vec E = 0 and k⃗⋅B⃗=0.\vec k \cdot \vec B = 0.

2. The magnetic field is obtained from the electric field through the vector product

k⃗×E⃗=ωc B⃗,\vec k \times \vec E = \dfrac{\omega}{c}\,\vec B,

where cc is the speed of light. The factor ωc\dfrac{\omega}{c} merely fixes the magnitudes, while the cross-product fixes the direction of B⃗\vec B relative to k⃗\vec k and E⃗\vec E. We therefore concentrate on directions; the overall constant will be written simply as B0B_0.

According to the statement of the problem, the wave is propagating along

n^=i^+j^2.\hat n = \dfrac{\hat i + \hat j}{\sqrt 2}.

Hence the wave-vector can be written as

k⃗=k n^=k i^+j^2,\vec k = k\,\hat n = k\,\dfrac{\hat i + \hat j}{\sqrt 2},

where k=ωck = \dfrac{\omega}{c} is the magnitude. The polarization (i.e. the direction of the electric field) is given to be along k^\hat k (the positive zz-axis):

E⃗0=E0 k^.\vec E_0 = E_0\,\hat k.

Because k⃗⋅E⃗0=0\vec k \cdot \vec E_0 = 0 is automatically satisfied (the dot-product of i^+j^2\dfrac{\hat i + \hat j}{\sqrt 2} with k^\hat k is zero), we proceed directly to the second relation. We compute the cross product k⃗×E⃗0\vec k \times \vec E_0 step by step:

First write the cross product explicitly:

k⃗×E⃗0=(k i^+j^2)×(E0 k^)=kE0 12  (i^+j^)×k^.\vec k \times \vec E_0 = \left(k\,\dfrac{\hat i + \hat j}{\sqrt 2}\right) \times \left(E_0\,\hat k\right) = kE_0\,\dfrac{1}{\sqrt 2}\;\bigl(\hat i + \hat j\bigr)\times\hat k.

Now evaluate each elementary cross product, recalling the right-handed basis rule i^×j^=k^,  j^×k^=i^,  k^×i^=j^,\hat i \times \hat j = \hat k,\;\hat j \times \hat k = \hat i,\;\hat k \times \hat i = \hat j, and therefore i^×k^=−j^,  j^×i^=−k^,  k^×j^=−i^.\hat i \times \hat k = -\hat j,\;\hat j \times \hat i = -\hat k,\;\hat k \times \hat j = -\hat i. We need i^×k^\hat i \times \hat k and j^×k^\hat j \times \hat k:

i^×k^=−j^,j^×k^=i^.\hat i \times \hat k = -\hat j,\qquad \hat j \times \hat k = \hat i.

Substituting these results, we obtain

(i^+j^)×k^=i^×k^  +  j^×k^=(−j^)+(i^)=i^−j^.\bigl(\hat i + \hat j\bigr)\times\hat k = \hat i \times \hat k \;+\; \hat j \times \hat k = (-\hat j) + (\hat i) = \hat i - \hat j.

Therefore

k⃗×E⃗0=kE0 12  (i^−j^).\vec k \times \vec E_0 = kE_0\,\dfrac{1}{\sqrt 2}\;(\hat i - \hat j).

From the relation k⃗×E⃗=ωc B⃗\vec k \times \vec E = \dfrac{\omega}{c}\,\vec B we identify the direction of B⃗\vec B to be exactly that of i^−j^\hat i - \hat j divided by 2\sqrt 2. All magnitude factors can be absorbed into a single constant B0=E0cB_0 = \dfrac{E_0}{c}, so we may write

B⃗0=B0 i^−j^2.\vec B_0 = B_0\,\dfrac{\hat i - \hat j}{\sqrt 2}.

The space-time dependence of the magnetic field must share the same argument ωt−k⃗⋅r⃗\omega t - \vec k \cdot \vec r as the electric field, because the wave propagates in the +n^\hat n direction. Writing that explicitly we have

B⃗(r⃗,t)=B0 i^−j^2  cos⁡ ⁣(ωt−k⃗⋅r⃗).\vec B(\vec r,t) = B_0\,\dfrac{\hat i - \hat j}{\sqrt 2}\; \cos\!\Bigl(\omega t - \vec k \cdot \vec r\Bigr).

Using k⃗=k i^+j^2\vec k = k\,\dfrac{\hat i + \hat j}{\sqrt 2}, the scalar product k⃗⋅r⃗\vec k \cdot \vec r can be left indicated in vector form, exactly as it appears in the alternatives given. Hence the magnetic field is

  B⃗=B0 i^−j^2  cos⁡ ⁣(ωt−k i^+j^2⋅r⃗)  \boxed{\; \vec B = B_0\,\dfrac{\hat i - \hat j}{\sqrt 2}\; \cos\!\left(\omega t - k\,\dfrac{\hat i + \hat j}{\sqrt 2}\cdot\vec r\right) \;}

This expression is identical to Option A when one recognises that the dot product with r⃗\vec r is implicit. No other option has both the correct direction (i^−j^)/2(\hat i - \hat j)/\sqrt 2 and the correct phase (ωt−k⃗⋅r⃗).(\omega t - \vec k \cdot \vec r).

Hence, the correct answer is Option A.

Tagged Properties of EM waves: fields, energy, intensity and momentum. Machine-assigned, so read it as a strong shortlist rather than a verdict.

SubjectPhysics
TopicProperties of EM waves: fields, energy, intensity and momentum
TypeMultiple choice