RankRizz
JEE MAIN 2021 · 31 AUG S2+4 / −1MEDIUMTRANSCRIBED

JEE Main 2021 Physics question — Properties of EM waves: fields, energy, intensity and momentum

The magnetic field vector of an electromagnetic wave is given by B=B0i^+j^2cos⁡kz−ωtB = B_0\frac{\hat{i}+\hat{j}}{\sqrt{2}}\cos kz - \omega t where i^\hat{i}, j^\hat{j} represents unit vector along x and y-axis respectively. At t=0t = 0 s, two electric charges q1q_1 of 4π4\pi coulomb and q2q_2 of 2π2\pi coulomb located at (0,0,πk)\left(0, 0, \frac{\pi}{k}\right) and (0,0,3πk)\left(0, 0, \frac{3\pi}{k}\right), respectively, have the same velocity of 0.5ci^0.5c\hat{i}, (where cc is the velocity of light). The ratio of the force acting on charge q1q_1 to q2q_2 is:

SOLUTION

The magnetic field of the plane electromagnetic wave is given as

B⃗  =  B0 i^+j^2 cos⁡ ⁣(kz−ωt).\vec B \;=\;B_{0}\,\dfrac{\hat i+\hat j}{\sqrt2}\, \cos\!\bigl(kz-\omega t\bigr).

For a monochromatic wave travelling along the +z+z-direction, the electric field E⃗\vec E is always perpendicular to B⃗\vec B, and the three vectors E⃗,  B⃗,  k^\vec E,\;\vec B,\;\hat k form a right-handed triad. The magnitudes satisfy the relation

∣E⃗∣  =  c ∣B⃗∣,|\vec E| \;=\;c\,|\vec B|,

and the direction is obtained from the vector identity

k^  =  E⃗×B⃗∣E⃗×B⃗∣.\hat k \;=\;\dfrac{\vec E\times\vec B}{|\vec E\times\vec B|}. Because k^=k^z\hat k=\hat k_z in the present problem, we choose the electric field so that E⃗×B⃗\vec E\times\vec B points along k^z\hat k_z. With B⃗\vec B lying in the xx-yy plane, the appropriate E⃗\vec E is

E⃗  =  cB0 i^−j^2 cos⁡ ⁣(kz−ωt).\vec E \;=\;c B_0\,\dfrac{\hat i-\hat j}{\sqrt2}\, \cos\!\bigl(kz-\omega t\bigr).

At the instant t=0t=0 we have

B⃗(z,0)=B0 i^+j^2 cos⁡(kz),E⃗(z,0)=cB0 i^−j^2 cos⁡(kz).\vec B(z,0)=B_0\,\dfrac{\hat i+\hat j}{\sqrt2}\, \cos(kz),\qquad \vec E(z,0)=cB_0\,\dfrac{\hat i-\hat j}{\sqrt2}\, \cos(kz).

The two charges are situated at

z1=πk,z2=3πk.z_1=\dfrac{\pi}{k}, \qquad z_2=\dfrac{3\pi}{k}.

Substituting these zz-values,

cos⁡(kz1)=cos⁡ ⁣(k⋅πk)=cos⁡π=−1,\cos(kz_1)=\cos\!\bigl(k\cdot\tfrac{\pi}{k}\bigr)=\cos\pi=-1,

cos⁡(kz2)=cos⁡ ⁣(k⋅3πk)=cos⁡3π=−1.\cos(kz_2)=\cos\!\bigl(k\cdot\tfrac{3\pi}{k}\bigr)=\cos3\pi=-1.

Hence at both locations

B⃗=− B0 i^+j^2,E⃗=− cB0 i^−j^2.\vec B = -\,B_0\,\dfrac{\hat i+\hat j}{\sqrt2},\qquad \vec E = -\,cB_0\,\dfrac{\hat i-\hat j}{\sqrt2}.

Both charges possess the same velocity

v⃗=0.5 c i^.\vec v = 0.5\,c\,\hat i.

Now we invoke the Lorentz force formula

F⃗=q( E⃗+v⃗×B⃗ ).\vec F = q\bigl(\,\vec E + \vec v\times\vec B\,\bigr).

First we evaluate v⃗×B⃗\vec v\times\vec B (the subscript 00 on B0B_0 is suppressed below for brevity):

v⃗×B⃗=(0.5 c i^)×( − B0 i^+j^2)=− 0.5 c B02 (i^×i^+i^×j^)=− 0.5 c B02 (0+k^)=− 0.5 c B02 k^.\begin{aligned} \vec v\times\vec B &= \Bigl(0.5\,c\,\hat i\Bigr)\times\Bigl(\, -\,B_0\,\dfrac{\hat i+\hat j}{\sqrt2}\Bigr) \\[4pt] &= -\,\dfrac{0.5\,c\,B_0}{\sqrt2}\, \Bigl(\hat i\times\hat i+\hat i\times\hat j\Bigr) \\[4pt] &= -\,\dfrac{0.5\,c\,B_0}{\sqrt2}\, \Bigl(0+\hat k\Bigr) \\[4pt] &= -\,\dfrac{0.5\,c\,B_0}{\sqrt2}\,\hat k. \end{aligned}$

Adding the electric part, the bracket (E⃗+v⃗×B⃗)(\vec E+\vec v\times\vec B) at either charge position becomes

E⃗+v⃗×B⃗=− cB0 i^−j^2  −  0.5 c B02 k^=− c B02(i^−j^+0.5 k^).\begin{aligned} \vec E + \vec v\times\vec B &= -\,cB_0\,\dfrac{\hat i-\hat j}{\sqrt2} \;-\;\dfrac{0.5\,c\,B_0}{\sqrt2}\,\hat k \\[6pt] &= -\,\dfrac{c\,B_0}{\sqrt2} \Bigl(\hat i-\hat j+0.5\,\hat k\Bigr). \end{aligned}$

This vector is identical at z1z_1 and z2z_2. Therefore, the magnitude of the force on each charge is directly proportional to the magnitude of the charge itself:

∣F⃗1∣=∣q1∣  ∣E⃗+v⃗×B⃗∣,∣F⃗2∣=∣q2∣  ∣E⃗+v⃗×B⃗∣.|\vec F_1| = |q_1|\; \bigl|\vec E+\vec v\times\vec B\bigr|,\qquad |\vec F_2| = |q_2|\; \bigl|\vec E+\vec v\times\vec B\bigr|.

Taking the ratio, the common factor cancels:

∣F⃗1∣∣F⃗2∣  =  ∣q1∣∣q2∣  =  4π2π  =  2.\dfrac{|\vec F_1|}{|\vec F_2|} \;=\;\dfrac{|q_1|}{|q_2|} \;=\;\dfrac{4\pi}{2\pi} \;=\;2.

Thus the force on q1q_1 is twice the force on q2q_2, i.e.

F⃗1:F⃗2=2:1.\vec F_1 : \vec F_2 = 2 : 1.

Hence, the correct answer is Option D.

Tagged Properties of EM waves: fields, energy, intensity and momentum. Machine-assigned, so read it as a strong shortlist rather than a verdict.

SubjectPhysics
TopicProperties of EM waves: fields, energy, intensity and momentum
TypeMultiple choice