RankRizz
JEE MAIN 2021 · 25 JUL S1+4 / −1EASYTRANSCRIBED

JEE Main 2021 Physics question — Properties of EM waves: fields, energy, intensity and momentum

A linearly polarised electromagnetic wave in vacuum is E=3.1cos⁡1.8z−5.4×106ti^E = 3.1\cos 1.8z - 5.4 \times 10^6 t \hat{i}NCN C−1^{-1}isincidentnormallyonaperfectlyreflectingwallatis incident normally on a perfectly reflecting wall atz=az = a$. Choose the correct option.

SOLUTION

We have been given an incident electric field in free space

E⃗i(z,t)=3.1cos⁡(1.8 z−5.4×106 t) i^  N C−1.\vec E_i(z,t)=3.1\cos(1.8\,z-5.4\times10^{6}\,t)\,\hat i\;{\rm N\,C^{-1}}.$

This is of the standard form E⃗i=E0cos⁡(kz−ωt)i^,\vec E_i=E_0\cos(kz-\omega t)\hat i, so by simple comparison

k=1.8  rad m−1,ω=5.4×106  rad s−1,E0=3.1  N C−1.k=1.8\;{\rm rad\,m^{-1}},\qquad \omega=5.4\times10^{6}\;{\rm rad\,s^{-1}},\qquad E_0=3.1\;{\rm N\,C^{-1}}.$

First, let us find the wavelength. The relation between the propagation constant and wavelength in vacuum is

k=2πλ  ⟹  λ=2πk.k=\frac{2\pi}{\lambda}\;\Longrightarrow\;\lambda=\frac{2\pi}{k}.

Substituting the numerical value

λ=2π1.8=6.28321.8≈3.49  m.\lambda=\frac{2\pi}{1.8}= \frac{6.2832}{1.8}\approx3.49\;{\rm m}.

This is clearly not equal to 5.4  m5.4\;{\rm m}, so statement A (“The wavelength is 5.4 m”) is wrong.

Next, let us calculate the ordinary frequency ff. The angular frequency and ordinary frequency are related by

ω=2πf  ⟹  f=ω2π.\omega=2\pi f\;\Longrightarrow\;f=\frac{\omega}{2\pi}.

Hence

f=5.4×1062π=5.4×1066.2832≈8.6×105  Hz.f=\frac{5.4\times10^{6}}{2\pi}= \frac{5.4\times10^{6}}{6.2832}\approx8.6\times10^{5}\;{\rm Hz}.$

The option claims 54×104  Hz=5.4×105  Hz54\times10^{4}\;{\rm Hz}=5.4\times10^{5}\;{\rm Hz}, which is different from 8.6×105  Hz8.6\times10^{5}\;{\rm Hz}. Therefore statement B is also wrong.

Because the wall is perfectly reflecting (perfect conductor), no electromagnetic field can be transmitted into it; the tangential component of E⃗\vec E must vanish at the surface. Hence there is no transmitted wave. Statement C therefore cannot be true.

We now construct the reflected wave. For normal incidence, the reflected field must travel in the −z-z direction and can be written in the general form

E⃗r(z,t)=E0cos⁡(kz+ωt+ϕ) i^,\vec E_r(z,t)=E_0\cos(kz+\omega t+\phi)\,\hat i,

where ϕ\phi is a phase constant to be fixed by the boundary condition at the wall situated at z=az=a.

The total tangential electric field on the wall must be zero, so we impose

E⃗i(a,t)+E⃗r(a,t)=0.\vec E_i(a,t)+\vec E_r(a,t)=0.

That gives

E0cos⁡(ka−ωt)+E0cos⁡(ka+ωt+ϕ)=0∀  t.E_0\cos(k a-\omega t)+E_0\cos(k a+\omega t+\phi)=0\qquad\forall\;t.$

Dividing through by E0E_0 and using the identity

cos⁡C+cos⁡D=2cos⁡C+D2 cos⁡C−D2,\cos C+\cos D=2\cos\frac{C+D}{2}\,\cos\frac{C-D}{2},

we obtain

2cos⁡ ⁣(ka+ϕ2)cos⁡ ⁣(−ωt−ϕ2)=0∀  t.2\cos\!\Bigl(k a+\frac{\phi}{2}\Bigr)\cos\!\Bigl(-\omega t-\frac{\phi}{2}\Bigr)=0\qquad\forall\;t.$

For the product of cosines to vanish at every instant, the first cosine must be zero:

cos⁡ ⁣(ka+ϕ2)=0.\cos\!\Bigl(k a+\tfrac{\phi}{2}\Bigr)=0.

This condition is satisfied if

ka+ϕ2=(2n+1)π2,n=0,1,2,…k a+\frac{\phi}{2}=\frac{(2n+1)\pi}{2},\qquad n=0,1,2,\dots

The simplest choice is to keep ϕ=0\phi=0 and take

ka=(2n+1)π2    (n=0,1,2,… ).k a=\frac{(2n+1)\pi}{2}\;\;(n=0,1,2,\dots).

With this choice, the reflected field becomes

  E⃗r(z,t)=3.1cos⁡(1.8 z+5.4×106 t) i^  N C−1  ,\boxed{\;\vec E_r(z,t)=3.1\cos(1.8\,z+5.4\times10^{6}\,t)\,\hat i\;{\rm N\,C^{-1}}\;},$

which is exactly the expression listed in option D.

We have therefore shown

• Options A and B disagree with the numerical values of wavelength and frequency.
• Option C is impossible because a perfectly reflecting wall allows no transmission.
• Option D is consistent with the required boundary condition and is therefore correct.

Hence, the correct answer is Option D.

Tagged Properties of EM waves: fields, energy, intensity and momentum. Machine-assigned, so read it as a strong shortlist rather than a verdict.

SubjectPhysics
TopicProperties of EM waves: fields, energy, intensity and momentum
TypeMultiple choice