RankRizz
JEE MAIN 2015 · 11 APR ONLINE+4 / −1EASYTRANSCRIBED

JEE Main 2015 Physics question — Properties of EM waves: fields, energy, intensity and momentum

For plane electromagnetic waves propagating in the +z+z-direction, which one of the following combinations gives the correct possible direction for E⃗\vec{E} and B⃗\vec{B} field respectively?

SOLUTION

We are told that a plane electromagnetic (EM) wave is propagating in the +z+z-direction. For such a wave we recall two basic facts from Maxwell’s theory:

1. The electric field E⃗\vec E, the magnetic field B⃗\vec B and the propagation vector k⃗\vec k are mutually perpendicular. Since the wave travels along +z+z, we have k⃗=k z^\vec k = k\,\hat z, so both E⃗\vec E and B⃗\vec B must lie completely in the xyxy-plane; they can have i^\hat i and j^\hat j components but no k^\hat k component.

2. The quantitative relation between the three vectors is

k⃗×E⃗=k z^×E⃗=ωc B⃗,\vec k \times \vec E = k\,\hat z \times \vec E = \dfrac{\omega}{c}\,\vec B,

or, after introducing the unit vector k^=z^\hat k = \hat z, more compactly

  B⃗=1c k^×E⃗  .\;\vec B = \dfrac1c\,\hat k \times \vec E\;.

Because the constant factor 1/c1/c only rescales the vector, the important geometric statement is simply

  B⃗  ∣∣  (z^×E⃗)  .\;\vec B \;||\; (\hat z \times \vec E)\;.

In words: “B⃗\vec B must be the cross-product of z^\hat z with E⃗\vec E, so its direction is fixed once E⃗\vec E is chosen.” We will apply this to each option.

Write a general E⃗\vec E in the xyxy-plane as

E⃗=Ex i^+Ey j^+0 k^.\vec E = E_x\,\hat i + E_y\,\hat j + 0\,\hat k. Then

z^×E⃗  =  ∣i^j^k^001ExEy0∣=i^(0⋅0−1⋅Ey)−j^(0⋅0−1⋅Ex)+k^(0⋅Ey−0⋅Ex)\hat z \times \vec E \;=\; \begin{vmatrix} \hat i & \hat j & \hat k\\ 0 & 0 & 1\\ E_x & E_y & 0 \end{vmatrix} =\hat i(0\cdot0-1\cdot E_y) -\hat j(0\cdot0-1\cdot E_x) + \hat k(0\cdot E_y-0\cdot E_x)

=  (−Ey) i^+(Ex) j^+0 k^.=\;(-E_y)\,\hat i + (E_x)\,\hat j + 0\,\hat k. So the rule becomes

  B⃗∝(−Ey) i^+(Ex) j^  .⋯(∗)\;\vec B \propto (-E_y)\,\hat i + (E_x)\,\hat j\;. \cdots(*)

Now we test each given pair.

Option A: E⃗=(1)i^+(2)j^,B⃗=(2)i^+(−1)j^.\vec E = (1)\hat i + (2)\hat j,\qquad \vec B = (2)\hat i + (-1)\hat j. Using (*), the required B⃗\vec B would be (−Ey)i^+(Ex)j^=(−2)i^+(1)j^,(-E_y)\hat i + (E_x)\hat j = (-2)\hat i + (1)\hat j, which is the negative of the given B⃗\vec B. So Option A does not satisfy the rule.

Option B: E⃗=(−2)i^+(−3)j^,B⃗=(3)i^+(−2)j^.\vec E = (-2)\hat i + (-3)\hat j,\qquad \vec B = (3)\hat i + (-2)\hat j. Applying (*), (−Ey)i^+(Ex)j^=−(−3)i^+(−2)j^=3i^−2j^.(-E_y)\hat i + (E_x)\hat j = -(-3)\hat i + (-2)\hat j = 3\hat i - 2\hat j. This is exactly the given B⃗\vec B. Hence Option B is consistent with electromagnetic-wave theory.

Option C: E⃗=(2)i^+(3)j^,B⃗=(1)i^+(2)j^.\vec E = (2)\hat i + (3)\hat j,\qquad \vec B = (1)\hat i + (2)\hat j. Formula (*) demands (−Ey)i^+(Ex)j^=(−3)i^+(2)j^,(-E_y)\hat i + (E_x)\hat j = (-3)\hat i + (2)\hat j, which differs from the given B⃗\vec B. Therefore Option C is invalid.

Option D: E⃗=(3)i^+(4)j^,B⃗=(4)i^+(−3)j^.\vec E = (3)\hat i + (4)\hat j,\qquad \vec B = (4)\hat i + (-3)\hat j. Rule (*) gives (−Ey)i^+(Ex)j^=(−4)i^+(3)j^,(-E_y)\hat i + (E_x)\hat j = (-4)\hat i + (3)\hat j, again the negative of the listed B⃗\vec B, so Option D fails.

Only Option B satisfies the mandatory cross-product relation, so it is the only physically admissible choice.

Hence, the correct answer is Option B.

Tagged Properties of EM waves: fields, energy, intensity and momentum. Machine-assigned, so read it as a strong shortlist rather than a verdict.

SubjectPhysics
TopicProperties of EM waves: fields, energy, intensity and momentum
TypeMultiple choice