RankRizz
JEE MAIN 2016 · 10 APR ONLINE+4 / −1MEDIUMTRANSCRIBED

JEE Main 2016 Physics question — Properties of EM waves: fields, energy, intensity and momentum

Consider an electromagnetic wave propagating in vacuum. Choose the correct statement:

SOLUTION

For a monochromatic plane electromagnetic wave travelling through vacuum we always have three experimentally verified geometric relations:

1. The wave-vector k⃗\vec k (hence the direction of propagation), the electric field E⃗\vec E and the magnetic field B⃗\vec B are mutually perpendicular. Mathematically

k⃗⋅E⃗=0,k⃗⋅B⃗=0,E⃗⋅B⃗=0.\vec k\cdot\vec E = 0,\qquad \vec k\cdot\vec B = 0,\qquad \vec E\cdot\vec B = 0.

2. The right-hand rule fixes their relative orientation. Stating it formally, the Poynting vector is

S⃗=1μ0 E⃗×B⃗,\vec S=\frac1{\mu_0}\,\vec E\times\vec B,

and this S⃗\vec S points in the same direction as k⃗\vec k.

3. Their magnitudes are related by ∣B⃗∣=∣E⃗∣c|\vec B|=\dfrac{|\vec E|}{c}, but for the present multiple-choice problem only the directions matter.

Now we test every option against the two purely geometrical requirements written in (1) and (2).

Option A
Propagation is specified as +y+y, i.e. k⃗=+y^\vec k=+\hat y. The proposal is

E⃗=12Eyz(x,t) z^,B⃗=12Bz(x,t) y^.\vec E=\frac1{\sqrt2}E_{yz}(x,t)\,\hat z,\qquad \vec B=\frac1{\sqrt2}B_{z}(x,t)\,\hat y.

Immediately we notice B⃗\vec B is parallel to k⃗\vec k because both point along y^\hat y, so k⃗⋅B⃗≠0\vec k\cdot\vec B\neq 0. This violates k⃗⋅B⃗=0\vec k\cdot\vec B=0, therefore Option A is incorrect.

Option B
Again the propagation direction is +y+y but here

E⃗=12Eyz(x,t) y^,B⃗=12Byx(x,t) z^.\vec E=\frac1{\sqrt2}E_{yz}(x,t)\,\hat y,\qquad \vec B=\frac1{\sqrt2}B_{yx}(x,t)\,\hat z.

Now E⃗\vec E itself is parallel to k⃗\vec k, giving k⃗⋅E⃗≠0\vec k\cdot\vec E\neq 0, contradicting k⃗⋅E⃗=0\vec k\cdot\vec E=0. Hence Option B is also wrong.

Option C
Propagation is along +x+x, so k⃗=+x^\vec k=+\hat x. The fields are given as

E⃗=12Eyz(y,z,t) (y^+z^),B⃗=12Eyz(y,z,t) (y^+z^).\vec E=\frac1{\sqrt2}E_{yz}(y,z,t)\,(\hat y+\hat z),\qquad \vec B=\frac1{\sqrt2}E_{yz}(y,z,t)\,(\hat y+\hat z).

Although each vector lies in the yzyz‐plane and is therefore perpendicular to k⃗\vec k (good so far), notice that E⃗\vec E and B⃗\vec B are identical. Their dot product equals their magnitudes squared:

E⃗⋅B⃗=∣E⃗∣ ∣B⃗∣≠0,\vec E\cdot\vec B=|\vec E|\,|\vec B|\neq 0,

so they are not perpendicular, violating E⃗⋅B⃗=0\vec E\cdot\vec B=0. Consequently Option C is ruled out.

Option D
Propagation is again along +x+x, i.e. k⃗=+x^\vec k=+\hat x. Here we are told

E⃗=12Eyz(x,t) (y^−z^),B⃗=12Byz(x,t) (y^+z^).\vec E=\frac1{\sqrt2}E_{yz}(x,t)\,(\hat y-\hat z),\qquad \vec B=\frac1{\sqrt2}B_{yz}(x,t)\,(\hat y+\hat z).

First, both E⃗\vec E and B⃗\vec B lie wholly in the yzyz‐plane, so each is automatically perpendicular to k⃗\vec k; thus k⃗⋅E⃗=0\vec k\cdot\vec E=0 and k⃗⋅B⃗=0\vec k\cdot\vec B=0 are satisfied.

Next we check their mutual perpendicularity:

E⃗⋅B⃗=12(y^−z^)⋅(y^+z^)=12(1−1)=0,\vec E\cdot\vec B=\frac12(\hat y-\hat z)\cdot(\hat y+\hat z) =\frac12(1-1)=0,

so E⃗\vec E and B⃗\vec B are indeed perpendicular.

Finally we verify the right-hand rule by computing E⃗×B⃗\vec E\times\vec B:

E⃗×B⃗=12(y^−z^)×(y^+z^)=12[y^×y^+y^×z^−z^×y^−z^×z^]=12[0+x^−(−x^)+0]=12(2x^)=x^.\begin{aligned} \vec E\times\vec B &=\frac12(\hat y-\hat z)\times(\hat y+\hat z)\\[4pt] &=\frac12\bigl[\hat y\times\hat y+\hat y\times\hat z-\hat z\times\hat y-\hat z\times\hat z\bigr]\\[4pt] &=\frac12\bigl[0+\hat x-(-\hat x)+0\bigr]\\[4pt] &=\frac12(2\hat x)=\hat x. \end{aligned}$

The cross product points along +x^+\hat x, exactly the specified direction of propagation. Therefore Option D satisfies all the requirements imposed by Maxwell’s equations.

Hence, the correct answer is Option D.

Tagged Properties of EM waves: fields, energy, intensity and momentum. Machine-assigned, so read it as a strong shortlist rather than a verdict.

SubjectPhysics
TopicProperties of EM waves: fields, energy, intensity and momentum
TypeMultiple choice