RankRizz
JEE MAIN 2009TRANSCRIBED

JEE Main 2009 Physics question — Ohm's law, resistance, resistivity and colour code

This question contains Statement-1 and Statement-2. Of the four choices given after the statements, choose the one that best describes the two statements. 

Statement-1: The temperature dependence of resistance is usually given as R=R0(1+αΔt)R = R_0(1 + \alpha\Delta t). The resistance of a wire changes from 100Ω100\Omega to 150Ω150\Omega when its temperature is increased from 27°C27°C to 227°C227°C. This implies that α=2.5×10−3/°C\alpha = 2.5 \times 10^{-3}/°C. 

Statement 2: R=Rt(1+αΔT)R = R_t(1 + \alpha\Delta T) is valid only when the change in the temperature ΔT\Delta T is small and ΔR=(R−R0)≪R0\Delta R = (R - R_0) \ll R_0.

SOLUTION

The given relation is an experimental (empirical) relation for metals

R=R0(1+αΔT)R = R_0\bigl(1 + \alpha \Delta T\bigr)

where R0R_0 is the resistance at some reference temperature and α\alpha is called the (average) temperature coefficient of resistance between the two temperatures considered. Using this single-step linear relation does not require that the temperature change be infinitesimally small; it works quite accurately over a fairly wide range of temperatures for ordinary metals.

Evaluating Statement-1

The wire changes from
R0=100 ΩatT0=27∘CR_0 = 100 \,\Omega \quad\text{at}\quad T_0 = 27^{\circ}\text{C}
to
R=150 ΩatT=227∘CR = 150 \,\Omega \quad\text{at}\quad T = 227^{\circ}\text{C}

Hence ΔT=227−27=200∘C\Delta T = 227 - 27 = 200^{\circ}\text{C}. Putting these numbers in the empirical formula:

150=100(1+α×200)150 = 100\bigl(1 + \alpha \times 200\bigr)

⇒  1+200α=1.5\Rightarrow\; 1 + 200\alpha = 1.5

⇒  200α=0.5    ⟹    α=2.5×10−3/∘C\Rightarrow\; 200\alpha = 0.5 \;\;\Longrightarrow\;\; \alpha = 2.5\times10^{-3}/^{\circ}\text{C}

The value quoted in the statement is exactly this, so Statement-1 is true.

Evaluating Statement-2

Statement-2 claims that the linear formula is valid only when the temperature rise is small and consequently ΔR≪R0\Delta R \ll R_0. In practice, for common metals the resistance varies almost linearly with temperature over several hundreds of degrees Celsius. The same linear law is routinely used, for example, from room temperature up to the red-hot range in platinum resistance thermometers. Therefore the restriction “only when ΔT\Delta T is small and ΔR≪R0\Delta R \ll R_0” is not correct; the formula remains a good empirical fit even when the change is large (as in the present problem where ΔR=0.5R0\Delta R = 0.5 R_0).

Hence Statement-2 is false.

Combining the results:

Statement-1 is true and Statement-2 is false.

Option A which is: Statement-1 is true, Statement-2 is false.

Tagged Ohm's law, resistance, resistivity and colour code. Machine-assigned, so read it as a strong shortlist rather than a verdict.

SubjectPhysics
TopicOhm's law, resistance, resistivity and colour code
TypeMultiple choice