RankRizz
JEE MAIN 2014 · 19 APR ONLINE+4 / −1EASYTRANSCRIBED

JEE Main 2014 Physics question — Elements of communication and propagation of EM waves

Long-range radio transmission is possible when the radio waves are reflected from the ionosphere. For this to happen the frequency of the radio waves must be in the range:

SOLUTION

Long-range radio transmission via ionospheric reflection depends on the radio waves having a frequency that allows them to be reflected by the ionosphere rather than penetrating it or being absorbed. The ionosphere's ability to reflect waves is determined by the maximum electron density, NmaxN_{\text{max}}, in electrons per cubic meter (m⁻³). The critical frequency fcf_c, which is the maximum frequency that can be reflected, is given by the formula:

fc=9Nmaxf_c = 9 \sqrt{N_{\text{max}}}

The electron density NmaxN_{\text{max}} varies with atmospheric conditions, time of day, and solar activity. Typically, NmaxN_{\text{max}} ranges from about 101010^{10} to 101210^{12} m⁻³. Let's calculate the critical frequencies for these extremes.

For Nmax=1010N_{\text{max}} = 10^{10} m⁻³:

fc=9×1010=9×105 Hz=900 kHzf_c = 9 \times \sqrt{10^{10}} = 9 \times 10^{5} \text{ Hz} = 900 \text{ kHz}

For Nmax=1012N_{\text{max}} = 10^{12} m⁻³:

fc=9×1012=9×106 Hz=9 MHzf_c = 9 \times \sqrt{10^{12}} = 9 \times 10^{6} \text{ Hz} = 9 \text{ MHz}

However, during periods of high solar activity, NmaxN_{\text{max}} can reach higher values, such as 8×10128 \times 10^{12} m⁻³. For this density:

fc=9×8×1012=9×8×106=9×22×106f_c = 9 \times \sqrt{8 \times 10^{12}} = 9 \times \sqrt{8} \times 10^{6} = 9 \times 2\sqrt{2} \times 10^{6}

Calculating 8=22≈2×1.414=2.828\sqrt{8} = 2\sqrt{2} \approx 2 \times 1.414 = 2.828:

fc≈9×2.828×106=25.452×106 Hz≈25 MHzf_c \approx 9 \times 2.828 \times 10^{6} = 25.452 \times 10^{6} \text{ Hz} \approx 25 \text{ MHz}

Thus, the critical frequency can extend up to approximately 25 MHz under extreme conditions. For reflection to occur, the frequency must be less than or equal to fcf_c. However, absorption in the lower ionospheric layers (like the D layer during the day) affects lower frequencies. Frequencies below about 5 MHz experience significant daytime absorption, limiting their use for long-range transmission. Therefore, the optimal range avoids severe absorption while staying below the maximum critical frequency.

Now, evaluating the options:

  • Option A (150-500 kHz): This range is too low. Although reflection may occur at night when D-layer absorption decreases, daytime absorption is high, and long-range transmission is unreliable.
  • Option B (80-150 MHz): These frequencies are in the VHF band and exceed typical critical frequencies (≤ 25 MHz). They penetrate the ionosphere and are not reflected, making them unsuitable.
  • Option C (1-3 MHz): This lower HF range suffers from strong daytime D-layer absorption. While usable at night, it is not reliable for consistent long-range communication.
  • Option D (8-25 MHz): This HF range minimizes daytime absorption (frequencies > 5 MHz) and includes frequencies up to the maximum critical frequency (25 MHz under extreme conditions). It aligns with the typical ionospheric reflection range for long-range transmission.

Hence, the correct answer is Option D.

Tagged Elements of communication and propagation of EM waves. Machine-assigned, so read it as a strong shortlist rather than a verdict.

SubjectPhysics
TopicElements of communication and propagation of EM waves
TypeMultiple choice