RankRizz
JEE MAIN 2013 · 07 APR ONLINE+4 / −1MEDIUMTRANSCRIBED

JEE Main 2013 Physics question — Series and parallel combinations of capacitors

Two capacitors C1C_1 and C2C_2 are charged to 120 V and 200 V respectively. It is found that by connecting them together the potential on each one can be made zero. Then:

SOLUTION

We have two capacitors. The first has capacitance C1C_1 and is charged to a potential of 120  V120\;{\rm V}, so the magnitude of charge on it is

Q1=C1×120.Q_1 = C_1 \times 120.

The second has capacitance C2C_2 and is charged to 200  V,200\;{\rm V}, therefore the magnitude of charge on it is

Q2=C2×200.Q_2 = C_2 \times 200.

To be able to bring the potential on each capacitor down to zero only by inter-connecting them, the obvious idea is to join plates carrying charges of opposite sign, so that the two initial charges can neutralise each other. Hence we connect

  • the positive plate of the first capacitor to the negative plate of the second, and

  • the negative plate of the first capacitor to the positive plate of the second.

After this cross-connection both capacitors share the same two conducting nodes; let us call the node that now carries the charges +Q1+Q_1 (from the first capacitor) and −Q2-Q_2 (from the second capacitor) node PP. The other node, which we call Q,Q, automatically carries the algebraically opposite charge. So the net charge residing on node PP is

Qnet=+Q1  −  Q2=C1×120  −  C2×200.Q_{\text{net}} = +Q_1 \;-\; Q_2 = C_1 \times 120 \;-\; C_2 \times 200.

Because both capacitors now lie in parallel between the same two nodes, their equivalent capacitance is simply the sum

Ceq=C1+C2.C_{\text{eq}} = C_1 + C_2.

The final common potential difference between the two nodes is therefore obtained from the elementary formula

Vf=QnetCeq.V_f = \dfrac{Q_{\text{net}}}{C_{\text{eq}}}.

Substituting the expressions just written gives

Vf  =   C1×120  −  C2×200 C1+C2.V_f \;=\; \dfrac{\,C_1 \times 120 \;-\; C_2 \times 200\,}{C_1 + C_2}.

The statement of the problem tells us that this potential can be made zero. Hence we impose the condition

Vf=0.V_f = 0.

Setting the numerator equal to zero gives

C1×120  −  C2×200=0.C_1 \times 120 \;-\; C_2 \times 200 = 0.

Now we perform the algebra step by step:

120 C1=200 C2,120\,C_1 = 200\,C_2,

C1C2=200120,\dfrac{C_1}{C_2} = \dfrac{200}{120},

C1C2=53.\dfrac{C_1}{C_2} = \dfrac{5}{3}.

Cross-multiplying finally gives

3 C1=5 C2.3\,C_1 = 5\,C_2.

Thus the required relation between the two capacitances is exactly the one written in Option D.

Hence, the correct answer is Option 4.

Tagged Series and parallel combinations of capacitors. Machine-assigned, so read it as a strong shortlist rather than a verdict.

SubjectPhysics
TopicSeries and parallel combinations of capacitors
TypeMultiple choice