We first read the values written on the four capacitors in the figure. Moving clockwise from the positive terminal of the battery we have
C1=1μF, C2=2μF, C3=2μF, C4=1μF.
The battery maintains the upper horizontal conductor at +10V while the lower horizontal conductor is at 0V.
The internal junctions are
a(betweenC1andC2),b(betweenC3andC4).
At the start the switch S between a and b is OPEN, so the two branches charge independently.
1. Charging of the left branch (with the switch open).
The two capacitors C1 and C2 are in series, so the same charge QL flows through each. The equivalent capacitance of the branch is
CeqL=C1+C2C1C2=1+2(1)(2)=32μF.
The battery is across this equivalent capacitance, hence
QL=CeqLV=(32)×10=6.667μC.
Because Q=CV, the individual voltage drops are
VC1=C1QL=16.667=6.667V,VC2=C2QL=26.667=3.333V.
Hence the potential of junction a (which is the lower plate of C1 and the upper plate of C2) is
Va=10−VC1=10−6.667=3.333V.
2. Charging of the right branch (with the switch open).
Exactly the same reasoning gives for the right branch
CeqR=C3+C4C3C4=2+1(2)(1)=32μF,
so
QR=CeqRV=(32)×10=6.667μC.
The individual drops are
VC3=C3QR=26.667=3.333V,VC4=C4QR=16.667=6.667V,
so the potential of junction b is
Vb=10−VC3=10−3.333=6.667V.
Thus, before the switch is closed we have
Vb−Va=6.667−3.333=3.334V(≈10/3V).
3. Situation immediately after closing the switch.
Closing S connects the two junctions, forcing their common potential to a single value, say Vf.
Because the conducting strip has negligible resistance, no appreciable potential difference can remain along it, so
Vf=Va′=Vb′.
The four capacitors are now arranged as follows:
- C1 and C3 are each between +10V and Vf,
- C2 and C4 are each between Vf and 0V.
Let us use charge conservation at the combined node.
At that node the algebraic sum of the charges on the four plates which touch it must remain zero, because the conductor was initially neutral and it is not connected to the battery. Writing the charges on those plates after equilibrium:
−C1(10−Vf)−C3(10−Vf)+C2Vf+C4Vf=0.
Simplifying gives
−(C1+C3)(10−Vf)+(C2+C4)Vf=0,
and therefore
Vf=C1+C2+C3+C410(C1+C3)=1+2+2+110(1+2)=630=5V.
4. New charges on the capacitors.
Applying Q=CV again with the new voltages we obtain
Q1′=C1(10−Vf)=1(10−5)=5μC,
Q2′=C2Vf=2(5)=10μC,
Q3′=C3(10−Vf)=2(10−5)=10μC,
Q4′=C4Vf=1(5)=5μC.
(The primes denote charges after the switch is closed. A positive value means the plate touching the junction carries positive charge; a negative value would mean negative charge.)
5. Charge that has to pass through the switch.
Only charges situated on the plates that meet at a and b can flow from one junction to the other; the plates attached to the battery cannot. So we look at the change suffered by the junction plates:
At a (the plate of C2 and the plate of C1):
Initial charge = (+6.667)+(−6.667)=0,
Final charge = (+10)+(−5)=+5μC.
Thus a has gained +5μC.
At b (the plate of C4 and the plate of C3):
Initial charge = (+6.667)+(−6.667)=0,
Final charge = (+5)+(−10)=−5μC.
Thus b has lost 5μC.
Because the only path joining the two points is the wire of the switch, the same 5μC must have travelled from the higher-potential junction b to the lower-potential junction a to equalise them.
6. Direction.
Before closing, Vb>Va, so positive charge naturally flows from b towards a, exactly the direction stated in Option C.
Hence, the correct answer is Option C.