RankRizz
JEE MAIN 2020 · 05 SEP S1+4MEDIUMTRANSCRIBED

JEE Main 2020 Physics question — Hydrogen spectrum and spectral series

A particle of mass 200 MeV c−2200\,\text{MeV c}^{-2} collides with a hydrogen atom at rest. Soon after the collision, the particle comes to rest, and the atom recoils and goes to its first excited state. The initial kinetic energy of the particle (in eV) is N4\frac{N}{4}. The value of NN is: (Given the mass of the hydrogen atom to be 1 GeV c−21\,\text{GeV c}^{-2})........

SOLUTION

We have a particle whose rest-mass is given as m=200 MeV c−2m = 200\,\text{MeV}\,c^{-2}. The hydrogen atom, initially at rest, has rest-mass M=1 GeV c−2=1000 MeV c−2M = 1\,\text{GeV}\,c^{-2} = 1000\,\text{MeV}\,c^{-2}. The particle strikes the atom, and immediately after the collision the following facts are stated:

1. The particle itself is brought to rest, so its final momentum is zero.
2. The hydrogen atom recoils (so it acquires kinetic energy) and is simultaneously promoted to its first excited state.

The first excited state of hydrogen corresponds to the principal quantum number n=2n = 2. Using the well-known Bohr energy formula, the ground-state energy is E1=−13.6 eVE_1 = -13.6\,\text{eV}, while for n=2n = 2 we have

E2=E1n2=−13.64 eV=−3.4 eV.E_2 = \frac{E_1}{n^{2}} = \frac{-13.6}{4}\,\text{eV} = -3.4\,\text{eV}.

Hence the excitation (internal) energy absorbed by the atom is

ΔE=E2−E1=(−3.4)−(−13.6) eV=10.2 eV.\Delta E = E_2 - E_1 = (-3.4) - (-13.6)\,\text{eV} = 10.2\,\text{eV}.

We now apply the two conservation laws.

Conservation of linear momentum
Initially only the incoming particle has momentum. If its initial momentum is pp, then after the collision the same momentum must be carried by the recoiling hydrogen atom because the particle is at rest. Therefore

pinitial=pfinal⟹p=pH,p_{\text{initial}} = p_{\text{final}} \quad\Longrightarrow\quad p = p_{\text{H}},

where pHp_{\text{H}} is the recoil momentum of the hydrogen atom.

Classical (non-relativistic) expression for kinetic energy
Because the kinetic energies we shall obtain turn out to be of order only a few electronvolts, they are completely negligible compared with the rest-energies of hundreds of MeV. Hence it is consistent to use the non-relativistic formula

K=p22m.K = \frac{p^{2}}{2m}.

Let KK be the particle’s initial kinetic energy. Then

K=p22m⟹p2=2mK.K = \frac{p^{2}}{2m} \quad\Longrightarrow\quad p^{2} = 2mK.

The hydrogen atom’s recoil kinetic energy KHK_{\text{H}} is obtained from the same momentum pp:

KH=p22M.K_{\text{H}} = \frac{p^{2}}{2M}.

Substituting p2=2mKp^{2} = 2mK into this expression we get

KH=2mK2M=mM K.K_{\text{H}} = \frac{2mK}{2M} = \frac{m}{M}\,K.

Conservation of total energy
All of the particle’s initial kinetic energy is converted into (i) the recoil kinetic energy of the hydrogen atom and (ii) the internal excitation energy ΔE=10.2 eV\Delta E = 10.2\,\text{eV}. Therefore

K=KH+ΔE.K = K_{\text{H}} + \Delta E.

Replacing KHK_{\text{H}} by mMK\dfrac{m}{M}K gives

K=mMK+ΔE.K = \frac{m}{M}K + \Delta E.

Now we isolate KK algebraically. First, move the term mMK\dfrac{m}{M}K to the left:

K−mMK=ΔE.K - \frac{m}{M}K = \Delta E.

Factorising KK yields

K(1−mM)=ΔE.K\left(1 - \frac{m}{M}\right) = \Delta E.

Hence

K=ΔE1−mM.K = \frac{\Delta E}{1 - \dfrac{m}{M}}.

We substitute the numerical values. The mass ratio is

mM=200 MeV c−21000 MeV c−2=0.2.\frac{m}{M} = \frac{200\,\text{MeV}\,c^{-2}}{1000\,\text{MeV}\,c^{-2}} = 0.2.

Therefore

1−mM=1−0.2=0.8.1 - \frac{m}{M} = 1 - 0.2 = 0.8.

So the required kinetic energy of the incident particle is

K=10.2 eV0.8=12.75 eV.K = \frac{10.2\,\text{eV}}{0.8} = 12.75\,\text{eV}.

The problem statement writes this energy in the form N4 eV\dfrac{N}{4}\,\text{eV}. Setting

N4=12.75⟹N=12.75×4=51.\frac{N}{4} = 12.75 \quad\Longrightarrow\quad N = 12.75 \times 4 = 51.

Hence, the correct answer is Option 51.

Tagged Hydrogen spectrum and spectral series. Machine-assigned, so read it as a strong shortlist rather than a verdict.

SubjectPhysics
TopicHydrogen spectrum and spectral series
TypeNumerical answer