RankRizz
JEE MAIN 2026 · 24 JAN S2+4 / −1MEDIUMTRANSCRIBED

JEE Main 2026 Physics question — Nuclear size, mass defect and binding energy

The binding energy for the following nuclear reactions are expressed in MeV.
2He3+0n1→2He4+20_{2}He^{3}+ _{0}n^{1} \rightarrow {}_{2}He^{4}+20 MeV
2He4+0n1→2He5−0.9_{2}He^{4}+ _{0}n^{1} \rightarrow {}_{2}He^{5}-0.9 MeV
If X3X_{3}, X4X_{4}, X5X_{5} denote the stability of 2He3,2He4{}_{2}He^{3}, {}_{2}He^{4} and 2He5,{}_{2}He^{5}, respectively, then the correct order is :

SOLUTION

The stability of a nucleus is measured by its total binding energy: larger binding energy ⇒\Rightarrow greater stability.
Let the binding energies of 2He3,  2He4{}_{2}He^{3},\; {}_{2}He^{4} and 2He5{}_{2}He^{5} be B3,  B4B_3,\; B_4 and B5B_5 (in MeV).

Write the given reactions in the form
2He3+0n1  ⟶  2He4+20  MeV{}_{2}He^{3} + {}_{0}n^{1} \;\longrightarrow\; {}_{2}He^{4} + 20\;{\rm MeV}
2He4+0n1  ⟶  2He5−0.9  MeV{}_{2}He^{4} + {}_{0}n^{1} \;\longrightarrow\; {}_{2}He^{5} - 0.9\;{\rm MeV}

For any nuclear reaction,
energy released =  (binding energy of products)−(binding energy of reactants)=\;(\text{binding energy of products})-(\text{binding energy of reactants}).

Case 1:
Products’ binding energy =  B4=\;B_4, reactants’ binding energy =  B3+0=\;B_3 + 0 (a free neutron has zero binding energy).
Hence
B4−(B3+0)=20B_4 - (B_3 + 0) = 20 −(1)-(1)
⇒  B4=B3+20\Rightarrow\; B_4 = B_3 + 20

Case 2:
Products’ binding energy =  B5=\;B_5, reactants’ binding energy =  B4+0=\;B_4 + 0.
Here the reaction absorbs 0.9 MeV, so energy released = −0.9-0.9 MeV:
B5−(B4+0)=−0.9B_5 - (B_4 + 0) = -0.9 −(2)-(2)
⇒  B5=B4−0.9\Rightarrow\; B_5 = B_4 - 0.9

Substitute B4B_4 from (1)(1) into (2)(2):
B5=(B3+20)−0.9=B3+19.1B_5 = (B_3 + 20) - 0.9 = B_3 + 19.1

Thus
B4=B3+20B_4 = B_3 + 20
B5=B3+19.1B_5 = B_3 + 19.1
Since 20>19.1>020 \gt 19.1 \gt 0, we get the order
B4>B5>B3B_4 \gt B_5 \gt B_3.

Greater binding energy means higher stability, so
X4>X5>X3X_4 \gt X_5 \gt X_3.

Therefore the correct option is Option A.

Tagged Nuclear size, mass defect and binding energy. Machine-assigned, so read it as a strong shortlist rather than a verdict.

SubjectPhysics
TopicNuclear size, mass defect and binding energy
TypeMultiple choice