The half-life of element A, denoted as T1/2,A, is given by T1/2,A=λAln2, where λA is the decay constant for A. The mean-life of element B, denoted as τB, is given by τB=λB1, where λB is the decay constant for B. The problem states that T1/2,A=τB, so:
λAln2=λB1
Solving for λB:
λB=ln2λA
Since ln2≈0.693<1, it follows that:
λB=0.693λA≈1.443λA
Thus, λB>λA.
The decay rate (activity) at any time t is given by R=λN, where N is the number of atoms remaining. Initially, both A and B have the same number of atoms, say N0. The initial decay rates are:
RA(0)=λAN0
RB(0)=λBN0=ln2λAN0≈1.443λAN0
Since 1.443>1, RB(0)>RA(0). Therefore, initially, B decays faster than A.
To compare the decay rates generally, consider the decay rates at time t:
NA(t)=N0e−λAt⇒RA(t)=λAN0e−λAt
NB(t)=N0e−λBt⇒RB(t)=λBN0e−λBt=ln2λAN0e−ln2λAt
The ratio of the decay rates is:
RA(t)RB(t)=λAλBe−(λB−λA)t=ln21e−(ln2λA−λA)t=ln21e−λAt(ln21−1)
Simplify the exponent:
ln21−1=ln21−ln2
Since ln2≈0.693, 1−ln2≈0.307>0, so the exponent is negative. Thus, the ratio RA(t)RB(t) decreases over time from its initial value of approximately 1.443. However, at t=0, RB>RA, and since λB>λA, B decays faster initially.
Evaluating the options:
- Option A: A and B decay at the same rate always. This is false because initially RB(0)>RA(0).
- Option B: A and B decay at the same rate initially. This is false because RB(0)=RA(0).
- Option C: A decays faster than B. This is false initially since RB(0)>RA(0), and while A may become faster later, the general statement does not hold.
- Option D: B decays faster than A. Given that λB>λA and initially RB(0)>RA(0), B decays faster than A initially and for some time thereafter. The decay constant λB being larger indicates B decays faster overall.
Hence, the correct answer is Option D.