RankRizz
JEE MAIN 2018 · 15 APR S2+4 / −1MEDIUMTRANSCRIBED

JEE Main 2018 Physics question — Hydrogen spectrum and spectral series

Muon (μ−1\mu^{-1}) is negatively charged (|q| = |e|) with a mass mμ_\mu = 200 me_e, where me_e is the mass of the electron and e is the electronic charge. If μ−1\mu^{-1} is bound to a proton to form a hydrogen like atom, identify the correct statements:
(A) Radius of the muonic orbit is 200 times smaller than that of the electron
(B) The speed of the μ−1\mu^{-1} in the nth orbit is 1200\frac{1}{200} times that of the electron in the nth orbit
(C) The ionization energy of muonic atom is 200 times more than that of an hydrogen atom
(D) The momentum of the muon in the nth orbit is 200 times more than that of the electron

SOLUTION

Let us compare an ordinary hydrogen atom (electron + proton) with the “muonic-hydrogen” atom (muon μ−\mu^{-} + proton) by using the usual Bohr formulas. Everywhere the electronic charge magnitude is denoted by ee and the Coulomb constant by k=14πε0k=\dfrac{1}{4\pi\varepsilon_{0}}.

Bohr first‐postulate formula for the radius of the nth orbit is

rn=n2ℏ2k m e2,r_{n}=\frac{n^{2}\hbar^{2}}{k\,m\,e^{2}},

where mm is the mass of the orbiting particle. For an electron we write m=mem=m_{e}, while for the muon we have m=mμ=200 mem=m_{\mu}=200\,m_{e}. Taking the ratio of the two radii for the same quantum number nn we obtain

rn(muon)rn(electron)=n2ℏ2/(k mμe2)n2ℏ2/(k mee2)=memμ=1200.\frac{r_{n}(\text{muon})}{r_{n}(\text{electron})}=\frac{n^{2}\hbar^{2}/(k\,m_{\mu}e^{2})}{n^{2}\hbar^{2}/(k\,m_{e}e^{2})} =\frac{m_{e}}{m_{\mu}} =\frac{1}{200}.

So the muonic orbit is 200 times smaller than the electronic one. Statement (A) is therefore correct.

The Bohr expression for the speed in the nth orbit reads

vn=k e2ℏ  1n,v_{n}=\frac{k\,e^{2}}{\hbar}\;\frac{1}{n},

which is obtained from the angular-momentum quantisation m vn rn=nℏm\,v_{n}\,r_{n}=n\hbar together with the Coulomb force centripetal balance m vn2rn=k e2rn2\dfrac{m\,v_{n}^{2}}{r_{n}}=\dfrac{k\,e^{2}}{r_{n}^{2}}. Notice that in the final form the mass has cancelled out; hence the speed depends only on nn and is the same for electron and muon:

vn(muon)=vn(electron).v_{n}(\text{muon})=v_{n}(\text{electron}).

Consequently the claim that the muon speed is 1200\dfrac{1}{200} of the electron speed is false. Statement (B) is incorrect.

The total energy of the nth orbit in the Bohr model is

En=−m k2e42ℏ2  1n2.E_{n}=-\frac{m\,k^{2}e^{4}}{2\hbar^{2}}\;\frac{1}{n^{2}}.

The ionisation energy is the magnitude of E1E_{1}, so for the ground state we have

∣E1(muon)∣=mμme  ∣E1(electron)∣=200  ∣E1(electron)∣.|E_{1}(\text{muon})|=\frac{m_{\mu}}{m_{e}}\;|E_{1}(\text{electron})| =200\;|E_{1}(\text{electron})|.

Thus the muonic atom is 200 times harder to ionise. Statement (C) is correct.

The momentum in the nth Bohr orbit is simply

pn=m vn.p_{n}=m\,v_{n}.

Since we have just seen that vn(muon)=vn(electron)v_{n}(\text{muon})=v_{n}(\text{electron}), substituting mμ=200 mem_{\mu}=200\,m_{e} gives

pn(muon)=mμvn=200 me vn=200 pn(electron).p_{n}(\text{muon})=m_{\mu}v_{n}=200\,m_{e}\,v_{n}=200\,p_{n}(\text{electron}).

Therefore the muon’s orbital momentum is 200 times larger. Statement (D) is also correct.

To summarise, statements (A), (C) and (D) are correct, while (B) is wrong. Among the given choices, this set corresponds to Option 4.

Hence, the correct answer is Option 4.

Tagged Hydrogen spectrum and spectral series. Machine-assigned, so read it as a strong shortlist rather than a verdict.

SubjectPhysics
TopicHydrogen spectrum and spectral series
TypeMultiple choice