RankRizz
JEE MAIN 2021 · 01 SEP S2+4 / −1MEDIUMTRANSCRIBED

JEE Main 2021 Physics question — Radioactivity: decay law, half-life and decay modes

The half life period of a radioactive element xx is same as the mean life time of another radioactive element yy. Initially they have the same number of atoms. Then:

SOLUTION

First we recall two standard formulae of radioactivity:

1. The half-life of any radionuclide is given by T1/2=ln⁡2λ,T_{1/2}=\dfrac{\ln 2}{\lambda} , where λ\lambda is its decay constant.

2. The mean (average) life is τ=1λ.\tau=\dfrac{1}{\lambda}.

The statement of the problem is that the half-life of element xx is numerically equal to the mean life of element yy. Expressing this relation in symbols,

T1/2,x=τy.T_{1/2,x}=\tau_y.

Substituting the two formulae written above, we get

ln⁡2λx=1λy.\dfrac{\ln 2}{\lambda_x}= \dfrac{1}{\lambda_y}.

Now we solve this equation step by step for the ratio of the two decay constants:

λy=1ln⁡2 λx.\lambda_y = \dfrac{1}{\ln 2}\,\lambda_x.

The numerical value of 1ln⁡2\dfrac{1}{\ln 2} is 1.443. Hence

λy=1.443 λx,\lambda_y = 1.443\,\lambda_x,

so that

λy>λx.\lambda_y > \lambda_x.

A larger decay constant means the nucleus disintegrates more rapidly. In other words, the element having the larger λ\lambda “decays faster.” Therefore element yy, whose decay constant is 1.443 times that of xx, is intrinsically the faster-decaying nuclide.

To see the same fact through the exponential decay law, we note that the number of undecayed nuclei at time tt is

Nx(t)=N0e−λxt,Ny(t)=N0e−λyt,N_x(t)=N_0e^{-\lambda_x t},\qquad N_y(t)=N_0e^{-\lambda_y t},

because the two samples start with the same initial number N0N_0 of atoms. Taking their ratio,

Ny(t)Nx(t)=e−(λy−λx)t=e−0.443 λxt.\dfrac{N_y(t)}{N_x(t)} = e^{-(\lambda_y-\lambda_x)t} = e^{-0.443\,\lambda_x t}.

For every positive time tt the exponent is negative, so the ratio is always less than 1. This means that at any instant t>0t>0 the sample of element yy has fewer atoms left than the sample of element xx; hence element yy is losing its atoms more quickly than element xx.

Thus, in all practical senses of the phrase “decays faster,” the element yy outpaces element xx.

Hence, the correct answer is Option C.

Tagged Radioactivity: decay law, half-life and decay modes. Machine-assigned, so read it as a strong shortlist rather than a verdict.

SubjectPhysics
TopicRadioactivity: decay law, half-life and decay modes
TypeMultiple choice