RankRizz
JEE MAIN 2020 · 07 JAN S1+4 / −1MEDIUMTRANSCRIBED

JEE Main 2020 Physics question — Series LCR circuits: impedance and phase

A LCR circuit behaves like a clamped harmonic oscillator. Comparing it with a physical spring-mass damped oscillator having damping constant 'b', the correct equivalence would be:

SOLUTION

We first recall the loop equation for a series L C RL\,C\,R circuit. Applying Kirchhoff’s voltage law around the closed loop, the algebraic sum of the potential drops across the inductor, resistor and capacitor is zero, i.e.

VL+VR+VC=0.V_L+V_R+V_C = 0.

For each element we write its constitutive relation: the inductor obeys VL=L dIdt,V_L = L\,\dfrac{dI}{dt}, the resistor obeys Ohm’s law VR=R I,V_R = R\,I, and the capacitor obeys VC=qC,V_C = \dfrac{q}{C}, where qq is the charge on the capacitor and I=dqdtI=\dfrac{dq}{dt} is the circuit current. Substituting these three expressions into the loop equation gives

L dIdt+R I+qC=0.L\,\dfrac{dI}{dt}+R\,I+\dfrac{q}{C}=0.

Now we eliminate the current in favour of charge. Because I=dqdt,I=\dfrac{dq}{dt}, we have dIdt=d2qdt2.\dfrac{dI}{dt}=\dfrac{d^2q}{dt^2}. Writing everything in terms of q(t)q(t) yields the second-order differential equation

L d2qdt2+R dqdt+1C q=0.(1)L\,\dfrac{d^2q}{dt^2}+R\,\dfrac{dq}{dt}+\dfrac{1}{C}\,q=0.\qquad(1)

This equation is the electrical analogue of the mechanical damped spring-mass system. For the mechanical oscillator of mass m,m, damping constant bb and spring constant k,k, Newton’s second law gives

m d2xdt2+b dxdt+k x=0.(2)m\,\dfrac{d^2x}{dt^2}+b\,\dfrac{dx}{dt}+k\,x=0.\qquad(2)

Comparing equation (1) term by term with equation (2), we match the coefficients of the second derivative, the first derivative and the displacement/charge terms. We obtain

Coefficient of d2dt2:L⟷m,Coefficient of ddt:R⟷b,Coefficient of the variable itself:1C⟷k.\begin{aligned} \text{Coefficient of }\dfrac{d^2}{dt^2}:&\quad L \longleftrightarrow m,\\[6pt] \text{Coefficient of }\dfrac{d}{dt}:&\quad R \longleftrightarrow b,\\[6pt] \text{Coefficient of the variable itself}:&\quad \dfrac{1}{C} \longleftrightarrow k. \end{aligned}

The last line tells us that 1C=k,\dfrac{1}{C}=k, or equivalently C=1k.C=\dfrac{1}{k}. Therefore the complete correspondence is

L↔m,C↔1k,R↔b.L \leftrightarrow m,\qquad C \leftrightarrow \dfrac{1}{k},\qquad R \leftrightarrow b.

This mapping is precisely the one stated in Option D.

Hence, the correct answer is Option D.

Tagged Series LCR circuits: impedance and phase. Machine-assigned, so read it as a strong shortlist rather than a verdict.

SubjectPhysics
TopicSeries LCR circuits: impedance and phase
TypeMultiple choice