RankRizz
JEE MAIN 2009TRANSCRIBED

JEE Main 2009 Mathematics question — Scalar triple product and coplanarity

If u⃗,v⃗,w⃗\vec{u}, \vec{v}, \vec{w} are non-coplanar vectors and p,qp, q are real numbers, then the equality [3u⃗    pv⃗    pw⃗]−[pv⃗    w⃗    qu⃗]−[2w⃗    qv⃗    qu⃗]=0[3\vec{u} \;\; p\vec{v} \;\; p\vec{w}] - [p\vec{v} \;\; \vec{w} \;\; q\vec{u}] - [2\vec{w} \;\; q\vec{v} \;\; q\vec{u}] = 0 holds for

SOLUTION

Let [ a⃗  b⃗  c⃗ ][\,\vec{a}\;\vec{b}\;\vec{c}\,] denote the scalar triple product a⃗⋅(b⃗×c⃗)\vec{a}\cdot(\vec{b}\times\vec{c}). It is

(i) linear in every argument     (ii) unchanged by a cyclic permutation     (iii) changes sign when two vectors are interchanged.

Because u⃗,v⃗,w⃗\vec{u},\vec{v},\vec{w} are non-coplanar, [u⃗  v⃗  w⃗]≠0[\vec{u}\;\vec{v}\;\vec{w}] \neq 0.

Evaluate each bracket separately using linearity:

[3u⃗  pv⃗  pw⃗]=3p2 [u⃗  v⃗  w⃗][3\vec{u}\; p\vec{v}\; p\vec{w}] = 3p^2\, [\vec{u}\;\vec{v}\;\vec{w}]

For the second bracket, perform a cyclic shift v⃗→w⃗→u⃗\vec{v}\rightarrow\vec{w}\rightarrow\vec{u} (no sign change):

[pv⃗  w⃗  qu⃗]=pq [v⃗  w⃗  u⃗]=pq [u⃗  v⃗  w⃗][p\vec{v}\; \vec{w}\; q\vec{u}] = pq\, [\vec{v}\;\vec{w}\;\vec{u}] = pq\, [\vec{u}\;\vec{v}\;\vec{w}]

For the third bracket, interchange the first and third entries of the cyclic set—one transposition introduces a minus sign:

[2w⃗  qv⃗  qu⃗]=2q2 [w⃗  v⃗  u⃗]=2q2 (−[u⃗  v⃗  w⃗])=−2q2 [u⃗  v⃗  w⃗][2\vec{w}\; q\vec{v}\; q\vec{u}] = 2q^{2}\,[\vec{w}\;\vec{v}\;\vec{u}] = 2q^{2}\,(-[\vec{u}\;\vec{v}\;\vec{w}]) = -2q^{2}\,[\vec{u}\;\vec{v}\;\vec{w}]

Insert these results in the given equality

[3u⃗  pv⃗  pw⃗]  −  [pv⃗  w⃗  qu⃗]  −  [2w⃗  qv⃗  qu⃗]=0\bigl[3\vec{u}\; p\vec{v}\; p\vec{w}\bigr]\;-\;\bigl[p\vec{v}\; \vec{w}\; q\vec{u}\bigr]\;-\;\bigl[2\vec{w}\; q\vec{v}\; q\vec{u}\bigr]=0

⟹  (3p2−pq+2q2) [u⃗  v⃗  w⃗]=0\Longrightarrow \; \bigl(3p^{2} - pq + 2q^{2}\bigr)\,[\vec{u}\;\vec{v}\;\vec{w}] = 0

Since [u⃗  v⃗  w⃗]≠0[\vec{u}\;\vec{v}\;\vec{w}] \neq 0, we require

3p2−pq+2q2=0−(1)3p^{2} - pq + 2q^{2} = 0 \quad -(1)

Equation (1) is a homogeneous quadratic form Ap2+2Bpq+Cq2Ap^{2} + 2Bpq + Cq^{2} with A=3,  2B=−1,  C=2A=3,\;2B=-1,\;C=2. Check its definiteness:

Determinant AC−B2=3⋅2−(−12)2=6−14=234>0,A=3>0.AC-B^{2}=3\cdot2-\left(-\tfrac12\right)^{2}=6-\tfrac14=\tfrac{23}{4}\gt0,\qquad A=3\gt0.

Because the determinant is positive and A>0A\gt0, the form is positive definite. Hence

3p2−pq+2q2>0 for every (p,q)≠(0,0).3p^{2} - pq + 2q^{2} \gt 0 \text{ for every } (p,q)\neq(0,0).

Therefore equation (1) is satisfied only when p=0p=0 and q=0q=0. There is exactly one ordered pair (p,q)(p,q) that makes the original equality true.

Option A which is: exactly one value of (p,q)(p, q)

Tagged Scalar triple product and coplanarity. Machine-assigned, so read it as a strong shortlist rather than a verdict.

TopicScalar triple product and coplanarity
TypeMultiple choice