JEE Main 2019 Mathematics question — Scalar triple product and coplanarity
Let α∈R and the three vectors a=αi^+j^+3k^, b=2i^+j^−αk^ and c=αi^−2j^+3k^. Then the set S = {α: a, b and c are coplanar}
SOLUTION
We are asked to find all real numbers α for which the three vectors a=αi^+j^+3k^, b=2i^+j^−αk^ and c=αi^−2j^+3k^ are coplanar.
Coplanarity of three vectors is tested by the scalar triple product. The condition is: a set of three vectors is coplanar if and only if the scalar triple product vanishes, that is, we must have
a⋅(b×c)=0.
Now we compute the cross product b×c first. Writing the two vectors in component form
b=(2,1,−α),c=(α,−2,3),
we use the determinant formula for the cross product:
b×c=i^2αj^1−2k^−α3.
Expanding this determinant along the first row we obtain
For the i^ component:
1⋅3=3,(−α)(−2)=2α,3−2α=3−2α.
For the j^ component:
2⋅3=6,(−α)(α)=−α2,6−(−α2)=6+α2.
For the k^ component:
2⋅(−2)=−4,1⋅α=α,−4−α=−4−α.
Putting these results back, we have
b×c=(3−2α)i^−(6+α2)j^+(−4−α)k^.
Thus in component form
b×c=(3−2α,−(6+α2),−4−α).
Next we take the dot product of a=(α,1,3) with this result. The dot-product formula is
a⋅(b×c)=α(3−2α)+1⋅(−(6+α2))+3⋅(−4−α).
We now expand each term carefully:
First term:
α(3−2α)=3α−2α2.
Second term:
1⋅(−(6+α2))=−6−α2.
Third term:
3⋅(−4−α)=−12−3α.
Adding all three expressions gives
(3α−2α2)+(−6−α2)+(−12−3α).
Collecting like terms for clarity:
• α terms: 3α−3α=0.
• α2 terms: −2α2−α2=−3α2.
• Constant terms: −6−12=−18.
Thus the scalar triple product simplifies to
−3α2−18.
For coplanarity we set this equal to zero:
−3α2−18=0.
Dividing both sides by −3 (so that the sign and coefficient become simpler), we get
α2+6=0.
We now solve this quadratic equation. Rearranged, it is
α2=−6.
But α2, being a square of a real number, is always non-negative, while the right-hand side −6 is strictly negative. Hence there is no real value of α satisfying this equation.
Therefore the set S={α∈R:a,b,c are coplanar} contains no elements; in other words, S is empty.
Hence, the correct answer is Option C.
Tagged Scalar triple product and coplanarity. Machine-assigned, so read it as a strong shortlist rather than a verdict.