RankRizz
JEE MAIN 2019 · 10 JAN S1+4 / −1MEDIUMTRANSCRIBED

JEE Main 2019 Mathematics question — Equations with parameters and trigonometric inequalities

If 5, 5rr, 5r2r^2 are the lengths of the sides of a triangle, then rr can not be equal to:

SOLUTION

We are told that the three sides of a triangle have lengths 5,  5r,  5r25,\;5r,\;5r^{2}, where r>0r\gt 0. For any three positive numbers to be the sides of a triangle, they must satisfy the triangle‐inequality theorem, which states:

Sum of any two sides > the remaining side.

Because the factor 55 is common to all three expressions, it is convenient to divide each inequality by 55. This leaves the simpler numbers 1,  r,  r21,\;r,\;r^{2}. Thus, the triangle inequalities become:

1+r>r2,r+r2>1,1+r2>r.\begin{aligned} 1+r \gt r^{2},\\[4pt] r+r^{2} \gt 1,\\[4pt] 1+r^{2} \gt r. \end{aligned}

The third inequality 1+r2>r1+r^{2}\gt r is automatically true for every positive r,r, so only the first two need detailed analysis. We examine them by separating the two natural cases r≥1r\ge 1 and 0<r≤1.0\lt r\le 1.

Case 1: r≥1.r\ge 1.} In this range r2≥r≥1,r^{2}\ge r\ge 1, so r2r^{2} is the largest of the three numbers 1,  r,  r2.1,\;r,\;r^{2}. The pertinent inequality is therefore

1+r>r2.1+r\gt r^{2}.

Rearranging gives

r2−r−1<0.r^{2}-r-1\lt 0.

We solve the quadratic r2−r−1=0r^{2}-r-1=0 by the quadratic formula:

r=1±1+42=1±52.r=\frac{1\pm\sqrt{1+4}}{2}=\frac{1\pm\sqrt5}{2}.

Thus the two real roots are 1−52  (negative)\dfrac{1-\sqrt5}{2}\;(\text{negative}) and 1+52≈1.618.\dfrac{1+\sqrt5}{2}\approx1.618. A quadratic with positive leading coefficient is negative between its roots, so

− 5−12<r<1+52.-\,\frac{\sqrt5-1}{2}\lt r\lt \frac{1+\sqrt5}{2}.

Because we are in the subcase r≥1,r\ge1, the combined condition is

1≤r<1+52⟹1≤r<1.618…1\le r\lt \frac{1+\sqrt5}{2}\quad\Longrightarrow\quad1\le r\lt 1.618\ldots

Case 2: 0<r≤1.0\lt r\le1.} Here the largest of the three numbers 1,  r,  r21,\;r,\;r^{2} is 1.1. Hence we must satisfy

r+r2>1.r+r^{2}\gt 1.

Rewriting yields

r2+r−1>0.r^{2}+r-1\gt 0.

We solve the quadratic r2+r−1=0r^{2}+r-1=0 in the same way:

r=−1±1+42=−1±52.r=\frac{-1\pm\sqrt{1+4}}{2}=\frac{-1\pm\sqrt5}{2}.

The positive root is 5−12≈0.618.\dfrac{\sqrt5-1}{2}\approx0.618. Because the quadratic opens upward, it is positive outside the interval between its roots, giving

r>5−12orr<−1+52.r\gt \frac{\sqrt5-1}{2}\quad\text{or}\quad r\lt -\frac{1+\sqrt5}{2}.

Only positive rr are relevant, so for this case

5−12<r≤1⟹0.618…<r≤1.\frac{\sqrt5-1}{2}\lt r\le1\quad\Longrightarrow\quad0.618\ldots\lt r\le1.

Combining both cases we see that a valid rr must lie in the single continuous interval

0.618…<r<1.618…0.618\ldots\lt r\lt 1.618\ldots

Now we test the four given choices:

34=0.75✓32=1.50✓54=1.25✓74=1.75×\begin{aligned} \frac34 &=0.75 &\checkmark\\[4pt] \frac32 &=1.50 &\checkmark\\[4pt] \frac54 &=1.25 &\checkmark\\[4pt] \frac74 &=1.75 &\times \end{aligned}

The only option that lies outside the required range is 74.\dfrac74. Therefore rr cannot be equal to 74.\dfrac74. Hence, the correct answer is Option D.

Tagged Equations with parameters and trigonometric inequalities. Machine-assigned, so read it as a strong shortlist rather than a verdict.

TopicEquations with parameters and trigonometric inequalities
TypeMultiple choice