RankRizz
JEE MAIN 2019 · 09 APR S1+4 / −1MEDIUMTRANSCRIBED

JEE Main 2019 Mathematics question — Distance, foot and image with respect to a plane

A plane passing through the points (0,−1,0)(0, -1, 0) and (0,0,1)(0, 0, 1) and making an angle π4\frac{\pi}{4} with the plane y−z+5=0y - z + 5 = 0, also passes through the point:

SOLUTION

We are asked to locate a point that lies on a plane which (i) passes through the two fixed points P(0,−1,0)P(0,-1,0) and Q(0,0,1)Q(0,0,1) and (ii) makes an angle π4\dfrac{\pi}{4} with the plane y−z+5=0.y - z + 5 = 0. We analyse everything one algebraic step at a time.

First, every plane that contains the two points PP and QQ must also contain the line PQ.PQ. We therefore start by finding a direction vector along this line.

We have PQ→=Q−P=(0−0,  0−(−1),  1−0)=(0,1,1).\overrightarrow{PQ}=Q-P=(0-0,\;0-(-1),\;1-0)=(0,1,1).

For any plane, its normal vector is perpendicular to every direction lying within that plane; hence the normal vector, say (A,B,C),(A,B,C), of our required plane must satisfy (A,B,C)⋅(0,1,1)=0.(A,B,C)\cdot(0,1,1)=0. Performing the dot product gives the simple relation 0⋅A  +  1⋅B  +  1⋅C  =  B+C=0  ⟹  C=−B.0\cdot A\;+\;1\cdot B\;+\;1\cdot C\;=\;B+C=0 \;\Longrightarrow\; C=-B.

So every admissible normal vector may be written in the form (A,  B,  −B),(A,\;B,\;-B), where AA and BB are real numbers not both zero.

Using the point-normal form of a plane - “the plane with normal (A,B,C)(A,B,C) passing through a point (x0,y0,z0)\bigl(x_0,y_0,z_0\bigr) has equation A(x−x0)+B(y−y0)+C(z−z0)=0A(x-x_0)+B(y-y_0)+C(z-z_0)=0 - we substitute the normal (A,B,−B)(A,B,-B) and the fixed point P(0,−1,0).P(0,-1,0). This yields A(x−0)+B(y−(−1))+(−B)(z−0)=0,A(x-0)+B\bigl(y-(-1)\bigr)+(-B)(z-0)=0, that is Ax+B(y+1)−Bz=0.Ax+B(y+1)-Bz=0. Writing the terms in a single line we have Ax+By−Bz+B=0.A x + B y - B z + B = 0.

So the complete one-parameter family of planes through PP and QQ is Ax+By−Bz+B=0,with (A,B)≠(0,0).A x + B y - B z + B = 0,\qquad\text{with }(A,B)\neq(0,0).

Next we enforce the angular condition. For two planes, the cosine of the angle θ\theta between them equals the absolute value of the dot product of their normals divided by the product of their magnitudes. Symbolically, cos⁡θ=∣n1⋅n2∣∥n1∥ ∥n2∥.\cos\theta=\dfrac{|\mathbf n_1\cdot\mathbf n_2|}{\|\mathbf n_1\|\,\|\mathbf n_2\|}. Here:

• The normal of our unknown plane is n1=(A,B,−B).\mathbf n_1=(A,B,-B). • The normal of the given plane y−z+5=0y-z+5=0 is n2=(0,1,−1).\mathbf n_2=(0,1,-1).

The two planes are to meet at the angle θ=π4,\theta=\dfrac{\pi}{4}, for which cos⁡θ=cos⁡π4=12.\cos\theta=\cos\dfrac{\pi}{4}=\dfrac1{\sqrt2}. We therefore write

∣ n1⋅n2 ∣∥n1∥  ∥n2∥=12.\dfrac{|\,\mathbf n_1\cdot\mathbf n_2\,|}{\|\mathbf n_1\|\;\|\mathbf n_2\|}=\dfrac1{\sqrt2}.

Compute each factor explicitly. The dot product is

n1⋅n2=(A,B,−B)⋅(0,1,−1)=0⋅A  +  1⋅B  +  (−1)(−B)=B+B=2B.\mathbf n_1\cdot\mathbf n_2 =(A,B,-B)\cdot(0,1,-1) =0\cdot A\;+\;1\cdot B\;+\;(-1)(-B) =B+B=2B.

The magnitudes are

∥n1∥=A2+B2+(−B)2=A2+2B2,∥n2∥=02+12+(−1)2=2.\|\mathbf n_1\|=\sqrt{A^{2}+B^{2}+(-B)^{2}} =\sqrt{A^{2}+2B^{2}}, \qquad \|\mathbf n_2\|=\sqrt{0^{2}+1^{2}+(-1)^{2}}=\sqrt2.

Substituting these into the cosine formula gives

∣2B∣A2+2B2  2=12.\dfrac{|2B|}{\sqrt{A^{2}+2B^{2}}\;\sqrt2}=\dfrac1{\sqrt2}.

Multiplying both sides by 2\sqrt2 clears the common factor:

∣2B∣A2+2B2=1.\dfrac{|2B|}{\sqrt{A^{2}+2B^{2}}}=1.

Squaring both sides (and therefore removing the absolute value) we arrive at

4B2=A2+2B2⟹A2=2B2.4B^{2}=A^{2}+2B^{2} \quad\Longrightarrow\quad A^{2}=2B^{2}.

Extracting square roots gives the proportionality

A=±2 B.A=\pm\sqrt2\,B.

Because only the ratio A:BA:B matters, we may set B=1B=1 for convenience. The two legitimate normal vectors are then

(2,1,−1)or(−2,1,−1).(\sqrt2,1,-1)\quad\text{or}\quad(-\sqrt2,1,-1).

Correspondingly, the two candidate planes become

2 x+y−z+1=0and−2 x+y−z+1=0.\sqrt2\,x+y-z+1=0 \qquad\text{and}\qquad -\sqrt2\,x+y-z+1=0.

We now test each of the four options to see which one satisfies at least one of these plane equations.

Option A: (2,−1,4).(\sqrt2,-1,4). Substituting into 2 x+y−z+1=0\sqrt2\,x+y-z+1=0 gives 2⋅2+(−1)−4+1=2−1−4+1=−2≠0.\sqrt2\cdot\sqrt2+(-1)-4+1=2-1-4+1=-2\neq0. Substituting into −2 x+y−z+1=0-\sqrt2\,x+y-z+1=0 gives −2⋅2+(−1)−4+1=−2−1−4+1=−6≠0.-\sqrt2\cdot\sqrt2+(-1)-4+1=-2-1-4+1=-6\neq0. So Option A lies on neither plane.

Option B: (2,1,4).(\sqrt2,1,4). For 2 x+y−z+1=0\sqrt2\,x+y-z+1=0 we find 2⋅2+1−4+1=2+1−4+1=0,\sqrt2\cdot\sqrt2+1-4+1=2+1-4+1=0, which is indeed satisfied. Hence Option B lies on the required plane and needs no further checking.

Option C: (−2,−1,−4).( -\sqrt2,-1,-4 ). A quick substitution into either plane immediately fails (the left-hand side evaluates to −2≠0-2\neq0 in both cases), so Option C is rejected.

Option D: (−2,1,−4).( -\sqrt2,1,-4 ). Substitution again yields a non-zero left-hand side, so Option D is also rejected.

We have therefore identified that only Option B (listed as Option 2 in the question) satisfies all the required conditions.

Hence, the correct answer is Option 2.

Tagged Distance, foot and image with respect to a plane. Machine-assigned, so read it as a strong shortlist rather than a verdict.

TopicDistance, foot and image with respect to a plane
TypeMultiple choice