JEE Main 2019 Mathematics question — Distance, foot and image with respect to a plane
A plane passing through the points (0,−1,0) and (0,0,1) and making an angle 4π with the plane y−z+5=0, also passes through the point:
SOLUTION
We are asked to locate a point that lies on a plane which (i) passes through the two fixed points P(0,−1,0) and Q(0,0,1) and (ii) makes an angle 4π with the plane y−z+5=0. We analyse everything one algebraic step at a time.
First, every plane that contains the two points P and Q must also contain the line PQ. We therefore start by finding a direction vector along this line.
We have
PQ=Q−P=(0−0,0−(−1),1−0)=(0,1,1).
For any plane, its normal vector is perpendicular to every direction lying within that plane; hence the normal vector, say (A,B,C), of our required plane must satisfy
(A,B,C)⋅(0,1,1)=0.
Performing the dot product gives the simple relation
0⋅A+1⋅B+1⋅C=B+C=0⟹C=−B.
So every admissible normal vector may be written in the form
(A,B,−B),
where A and B are real numbers not both zero.
Using the point-normal form of a plane - “the plane with normal (A,B,C) passing through a point (x0,y0,z0) has equation
A(x−x0)+B(y−y0)+C(z−z0)=0 -
we substitute the normal (A,B,−B) and the fixed point P(0,−1,0). This yields
A(x−0)+B(y−(−1))+(−B)(z−0)=0,
that is
Ax+B(y+1)−Bz=0.
Writing the terms in a single line we have
Ax+By−Bz+B=0.
So the complete one-parameter family of planes through P and Q is
Ax+By−Bz+B=0,with (A,B)=(0,0).
Next we enforce the angular condition.
For two planes, the cosine of the angle θ between them equals the absolute value of the dot product of their normals divided by the product of their magnitudes. Symbolically,
cosθ=∥n1∥∥n2∥∣n1⋅n2∣.
Here:
• The normal of our unknown plane is n1=(A,B,−B).
• The normal of the given plane y−z+5=0 is n2=(0,1,−1).
The two planes are to meet at the angle θ=4π, for which cosθ=cos4π=21. We therefore write
∥n1∥∥n2∥∣n1⋅n2∣=21.
Compute each factor explicitly. The dot product is
Multiplying both sides by 2 clears the common factor:
A2+2B2∣2B∣=1.
Squaring both sides (and therefore removing the absolute value) we arrive at
4B2=A2+2B2⟹A2=2B2.
Extracting square roots gives the proportionality
A=±2B.
Because only the ratio A:B matters, we may set B=1 for convenience. The two legitimate normal vectors are then
(2,1,−1)or(−2,1,−1).
Correspondingly, the two candidate planes become
2x+y−z+1=0and−2x+y−z+1=0.
We now test each of the four options to see which one satisfies at least one of these plane equations.
Option A:(2,−1,4).
Substituting into 2x+y−z+1=0 gives
2⋅2+(−1)−4+1=2−1−4+1=−2=0.
Substituting into −2x+y−z+1=0 gives
−2⋅2+(−1)−4+1=−2−1−4+1=−6=0.
So Option A lies on neither plane.
Option B:(2,1,4).
For 2x+y−z+1=0 we find
2⋅2+1−4+1=2+1−4+1=0,
which is indeed satisfied. Hence Option B lies on the required plane and needs no further checking.
Option C:(−2,−1,−4). A quick substitution into either plane immediately fails (the left-hand side evaluates to −2=0 in both cases), so Option C is rejected.
Option D:(−2,1,−4). Substitution again yields a non-zero left-hand side, so Option D is also rejected.
We have therefore identified that only Option B (listed as Option 2 in the question) satisfies all the required conditions.
Hence, the correct answer is Option 2.
Tagged Distance, foot and image with respect to a plane. Machine-assigned, so read it as a strong shortlist rather than a verdict.