RankRizz
JEE MAIN 2020 · 05 SEP S2+4 / −1MEDIUMTRANSCRIBED

JEE Main 2020 Mathematics question — Line and plane: intersection, coplanarity and projection

If for some α∈R\alpha \in \mathbb{R}, the lines L1:x+12=y−2−1=z−11L_1 : \frac{x+1}{2} = \frac{y-2}{-1} = \frac{z-1}{1} and L2:x+2α=y+15−α=z+11L_2 : \frac{x+2}{\alpha} = \frac{y+1}{5-\alpha} = \frac{z+1}{1} are coplanar, then the line L2L_2 passes through the point:

SOLUTION

We have two lines given in symmetric form. For line L1L_1 the equation is

x+12=y−2−1=z−11.\frac{x+1}{2}= \frac{y-2}{-1}= \frac{z-1}{1}.

In this form, the numerators give one fixed point on the line while the denominators give the direction ratios. So, for L1L_1

Point on the line (taking the parameter λ=0\lambda=0): S1(−1, 2, 1).S_1(-1,\,2,\,1).

Direction vector v1⃗=(2, −1, 1).\vec{v_1}=(2,\,-1,\,1).

Similarly, for line L2L_2 we have

x+2α=y+15−α=z+11.\frac{x+2}{\alpha}= \frac{y+1}{5-\alpha}= \frac{z+1}{1}.

So, for L2L_2

Point on the line (again parameter μ=0\mu=0): S2(−2, −1, −1),S_2(-2,\,-1,\,-1),

Direction vector v2⃗=(α, 5−α, 1).\vec{v_2}=(\alpha,\,5-\alpha,\,1).

Now, the two lines will be coplanar when the scalar triple product of v1⃗, v2⃗\vec{v_1},\ \vec{v_2} and the vector joining the two given points w⃗=S2S1\vec{w}=S_2S_1 is zero. The condition we use is:

[w⃗ v1⃗ v2⃗]=0.[\vec{w}\ \vec{v_1}\ \vec{v_2}]=0.

First we find the joining vector

w⃗=S2−S1=(−2−(−1), −1−2, −1−1)=(−1, −3, −2).\vec{w}=S_2-S_1 =(-2-(-1),\,-1-2,\,-1-1) =(-1,\,-3,\,-2).

Next we evaluate the cross-product v1⃗×v2⃗.\vec{v_1}\times\vec{v_2}. Writing the determinant,

v1⃗×v2⃗=∣ijk2−11α5−α1∣.\vec{v_1}\times\vec{v_2}= \begin{vmatrix} \mathbf i & \mathbf j & \mathbf k\\ 2 & -1 & 1\\ \alpha & 5-\alpha & 1 \end{vmatrix}.

Expanding,

i:  (−1)(1)−1(5−α)=−1−(5−α)=α−6,j:  −(2⋅1−1⋅α)=−(2−α)=α−2,k:  2(5−α)−(−1)α=10−2α+α=10−α.\begin{aligned} \mathbf i:&\;(-1)(1)-1(5-\alpha)= -1-(5-\alpha)=\alpha-6,\\ \mathbf j:&\;-\bigl(2\cdot1-1\cdot\alpha\bigr)=-(2-\alpha)=\alpha-2,\\ \mathbf k:&\;2(5-\alpha)-(-1)\alpha=10-2\alpha+\alpha=10-\alpha. \end{aligned}

Hence

v1⃗×v2⃗=(α−6, α−2, 10−α).\vec{v_1}\times\vec{v_2}=(\alpha-6,\ \alpha-2,\ 10-\alpha).

We now take the dot product with w⃗\vec{w}:

w⃗⋅(v1⃗×v2⃗)=(−1)(α−6)+(−3)(α−2)+(−2)(10−α).\vec{w}\cdot(\vec{v_1}\times\vec{v_2}) =(-1)(\alpha-6)+(-3)(\alpha-2)+(-2)(10-\alpha).

Expanding each term carefully,

(−1)(α−6)=−α+6,(−3)(α−2)=−3α+6,(−2)(10−α)=−20+2α.\begin{aligned} (-1)(\alpha-6)&=-\alpha+6,\\ (-3)(\alpha-2)&=-3\alpha+6,\\ (-2)(10-\alpha)&=-20+2\alpha. \end{aligned}

Adding them:

(−α+6)+(−3α+6)+(−20+2α)=0.(-\alpha+6)+(-3\alpha+6)+(-20+2\alpha)=0.

Combining like terms,

Coefficient of α:−α−3α+2α=−2α,\alpha: -\alpha-3\alpha+2\alpha=-2\alpha, Constant term: 6+6−20=−8.6+6-20=-8.

So we obtain

−2α−8=0.-2\alpha-8=0.

Dividing by −2-2 gives

α+4=0    ⟹    α=−4.\alpha+4=0 \;\;\Longrightarrow\;\; \alpha=-4.

This is the only real value of α\alpha for which the two lines are coplanar.

We now substitute α=−4\alpha=-4 back into the equation of L2L_2. With α=−4\alpha=-4 the line becomes

x+2−4=y+15−(−4)=y+19=z+11.\frac{x+2}{-4}= \frac{y+1}{5-(-4)}= \frac{y+1}{9}= \frac{z+1}{1}.

Let the common ratio be tt. Then

x+2=−4t    ⟹    x=−2−4t,y+1=9t    ⟹    y=−1+9t,z+1=t    ⟹    z=−1+t.\begin{aligned} x+2&=-4t \;\;\Longrightarrow\;\; x=-2-4t,\\ y+1&=9t \;\;\Longrightarrow\;\; y=-1+9t,\\ z+1&=t \;\;\Longrightarrow\;\; z=-1+t. \end{aligned}

We examine the four given points to see which one satisfies these equations for the same value of tt.

Take the coordinate zz because its relation is simplest. For the point (2,−10,−2)(2,-10,-2) (Option B) we have

z=−2  ⇒  −1+t=−2  ⇒  t=−1.z=-2\;\Rightarrow\;-1+t=-2\;\Rightarrow\;t=-1.

Using t=−1t=-1 in the remaining equations,

x=−2−4(−1)=−2+4=2,x=-2-4(-1)= -2+4=2, y=−1+9(−1)=−1−9=−10.y=-1+9(-1)= -1-9=-10.

Both xx and yy match perfectly, so (2,−10,−2)(2,-10,-2) indeed lies on L2L_2 when α=−4\alpha=-4.

Checking quickly, none of the other three options satisfy all three coordinates for a single value of tt, hence they cannot lie on the required line.

Hence, the correct answer is Option B.

Tagged Line and plane: intersection, coplanarity and projection. Machine-assigned, so read it as a strong shortlist rather than a verdict.

TopicLine and plane: intersection, coplanarity and projection
TypeMultiple choice