RankRizz
JEE MAIN 2019 · 12 JAN S2+4 / −1MEDIUMTRANSCRIBED

JEE Main 2019 Mathematics question — Distance, foot and image with respect to a plane

Let S be the set of all real values of λ\lambda such that a plane passing through the points (−λ2,1,1)(-\lambda^2, 1, 1), (1,−λ2,1)(1, -\lambda^2, 1) and (1,1,−λ2)(1, 1, -\lambda^2) also passes through the point (−1,−1,1)(-1, -1, 1). Then S is equal to:

SOLUTION

We have three given points P(−λ2, 1, 1),  Q(1, −λ2, 1),  R(1, 1, −λ2).P(-\lambda^{2},\,1,\,1),\;Q(1,\,-\lambda^{2},\,1),\;R(1,\,1,\,-\lambda^{2}). Any plane through these three points must also pass through the point S(−1, −1, 1).S(-1,\,-1,\,1). We shall translate this geometric condition into an algebraic equation in λ\lambda.

First we determine a normal vector to the required plane. To do that we form two non-parallel direction vectors lying on the plane:

Vector PQ→=Q−P\overrightarrow{PQ}=Q-P is PQ→=(1−(−λ2),  −λ2−1,  1−1)=(1+λ2,  −λ2−1,  0).\overrightarrow{PQ}=(1-(-\lambda^{2}),\;-\lambda^{2}-1,\;1-1) =(1+\lambda^{2},\;-\lambda^{2}-1,\;0).

Vector PR→=R−P\overrightarrow{PR}=R-P is PR→=(1−(−λ2),  1−1,  −λ2−1)=(1+λ2,  0,  −λ2−1).\overrightarrow{PR}=(1-(-\lambda^{2}),\;1-1,\;-\lambda^{2}-1) =(1+\lambda^{2},\;0,\;-\lambda^{2}-1).

The normal vector n\mathbf{n} to the plane is given by the cross product n=PQ→×PR→.\mathbf{n}= \overrightarrow{PQ}\times\overrightarrow{PR}.

We compute the cross product using the determinant formula a→×b→=∣ijka1a2a3b1b2b3∣.\overrightarrow{a}\times\overrightarrow{b}= \begin{vmatrix} \mathbf{i}&\mathbf{j}&\mathbf{k}\\ a_{1}&a_{2}&a_{3}\\ b_{1}&b_{2}&b_{3} \end{vmatrix}. So

n=∣ijk1+λ2−λ2−101+λ20−λ2−1∣=i((−λ2−1)(−λ2−1)−0)−j((1+λ2)(−λ2−1)−0)+k((1+λ2)⋅0−(1+λ2)(−λ2−1)).\mathbf{n}= \begin{vmatrix} \mathbf{i}&\mathbf{j}&\mathbf{k}\\ 1+\lambda^{2}&-\lambda^{2}-1&0\\ 1+\lambda^{2}&0&-\lambda^{2}-1 \end{vmatrix} = \mathbf{i}\Bigl((-\lambda^{2}-1)(-\lambda^{2}-1)-0\Bigr) - \mathbf{j}\Bigl((1+\lambda^{2})(-\lambda^{2}-1)-0\Bigr) + \mathbf{k}\Bigl((1+\lambda^{2})\cdot0-(1+\lambda^{2})(-\lambda^{2}-1)\Bigr).

Simplifying step by step, notice that −λ2−1=−(1+λ2).-\lambda^{2}-1=-(1+\lambda^{2}). Put a=1+λ2  ,b=−(1+λ2)=−a.a=1+\lambda^{2}\;,\quad b=-(1+\lambda^{2})=-a. Then

n=(b⋅b,  −a⋅b,  −a⋅b)=((−a)(−a),  −a(−a),  −a(−a))=(a2, a2, a2).\mathbf{n}=(b\cdot b,\;-a\cdot b,\;-a\cdot b) =\bigl((-a)(-a),\;-a(-a),\;-a(-a)\bigr) =(a^{2},\,a^{2},\,a^{2}).

Since a2≠0a^{2}\neq 0 for every real λ\lambda, a convenient normal vector is n=(1, 1, 1)\mathbf{n}=(1,\,1,\,1) (we divide by a2a^{2} to keep coefficients simple).

With normal vector (1, 1, 1)(1,\,1,\,1), the equation of the plane through point P(−λ2,1,1)P(-\lambda^{2},1,1) is written using the point-normal form (x−x0)+(y−y0)+(z−z0)=0.(x-x_{0})+(y-y_{0})+(z-z_{0})=0. Substituting (x0,y0,z0)=(−λ2, 1, 1)(x_{0},y_{0},z_{0})=(-\lambda^{2},\,1,\,1), we have

(x+λ2)+(y−1)+(z−1)=0.\bigl(x+ \lambda^{2}\bigr)+\bigl(y-1\bigr)+\bigl(z-1\bigr)=0. Collecting like terms,

x+y+z+λ2−2=0x+y+z+\lambda^{2}-2=0 or equivalently x+y+z=2−λ2.−(1)x+y+z=2-\lambda^{2}. \quad -(1)

The extra condition is that this same plane must contain the point S(−1,−1,1).S(-1,-1,1). Substituting x=−1,  y=−1,  z=1x=-1,\;y=-1,\;z=1 into equation (1):

(−1)+(−1)+1=2−λ2.(-1)+(-1)+1=2-\lambda^{2}. The left-hand side simplifies to −1.-1. So we obtain

−1=2−λ2.-1=2-\lambda^{2}. Rearranging,

λ2=2+1=3.\lambda^{2}=2+1=3.

Taking square roots (and remembering that both positive and negative roots are real possibilities),

λ=3orλ=−3.\lambda=\sqrt{3}\quad\text{or}\quad \lambda=-\sqrt{3}.

Thus the required set of real values is S={3,−3}.S=\{\sqrt{3},-\sqrt{3}\}.

Hence, the correct answer is Option D.

Tagged Distance, foot and image with respect to a plane. Machine-assigned, so read it as a strong shortlist rather than a verdict.

TopicDistance, foot and image with respect to a plane
TypeMultiple choice