JEE Main 2019 Mathematics question — Distance, foot and image with respect to a plane
The direction ratios of normal to the plane through the points (0,-1,0) and (0,0,1) and making an angle 4π with the plane y−z+5=0 are: 2,-1,1; 2,2−2; 2,1,−1; 23,1,−1
SOLUTION
Let the required plane be denoted by the equation
ax+by+cz+d=0,
where a,b,c are the direction ratios of its normal and d is the constant term. Because only the direction ratios are asked, we shall work exclusively with the normal vector n=(a,b,c).
First, the plane has to pass through the two given points
A(0,−1,0)andB(0,0,1).
Hence the vector
AB=B−A=(0,1,1)
lies entirely in the required plane. A normal to the plane must therefore be perpendicular to every vector lying in the plane, so in particular we must have
n⋅AB=0.
Substituting, this condition is
a⋅0+b⋅1+c⋅1=0⟹b+c=0⟹c=−b.
Thus we can write the normal in the form
n=(a,b,−b).
Next, the angle between the required plane and the given plane
y−z+5=0
is stated to be 4π. The normal of this given plane is
n0=(0,1,−1).
The formula for the angle θ between two planes, via their normals, is
cosθ=∥n∥∥n0∥∣n⋅n0∣.
We substitute θ=4π,n=(a,b,−b),n0=(0,1,−1).
First the dot product:
n⋅n0=(a,b,−b)⋅(0,1,−1)=a⋅0+b⋅1+(−b)⋅(−1)=b+b=2b.
The magnitudes:
∥n∥=a2+b2+(−b)2=a2+2b2,
∥n0∥=02+12+(−1)2=2.
Now enforce the angle condition:
cos(4π)=2a2+2b2∣2b∣⟹2a2+2b2∣2b∣=21.
Multiplying by 2 gives
∣2b∣=a2+2b2.
Squaring both sides,
4b2=a2+2b2⟹a2=4b2−2b2=2b2⟹a=±2b.
Combining this with c=−b, the normal can therefore be written (taking an arbitrary non-zero b)
n=(2b,b,−b)orn=(−2b,b,−b).
Because any non-zero scalar multiple represents the same set of direction ratios, we may conveniently choose b=1. The two possible normals are then
n1=(2,1,−1),
n2=(−2,1,−1)≡(2,−1,1)(after multiplying by −1).
We now compare these with the four collections of direction ratios supplied in the question.
Option 1: 2,−1,1 is proportional to (2,−1,1).
The ratio of the first components to (2,−1,1) is 2/2=2, whereas the second components ratio is (−1)/(−1)=1. Since the proportionality factors differ, Option 1 is not acceptable.
Option 2: 2,2,−2 is a constant multiple of (2,1,−1) (multiply by 2), so it is acceptable.
Option 3: 2,1,−1 is exactly n1, hence acceptable.
Option 4: 23,1,−1 is not proportional to either acceptable normal, so it is rejected.
Therefore the correct sets of direction ratios are those given in Options 2 and 3.
Hence, the correct answer is Option B.
Tagged Distance, foot and image with respect to a plane. Machine-assigned, so read it as a strong shortlist rather than a verdict.